American Government › Section N · State and local government › Topic N.1

State power and delegation

National politics fills the headlines, but the governments that pave your street, run your school and set your tuition are mostly state and local. This topic asks where their authority comes from and how states pass some of it down to counties and cities.

The governments closest to home

The water from the tap, the road to school, the police patrol and the public college down the road are run or paid for largely by state and local governments. States also license drivers and doctors, write most criminal law and run elections, even for federal offices. Yet turnout in state and local elections is usually lower than in presidential years. This section looks at those governments: how they gain power, how they differ and how they are organised.

From state supremacy to shared power

Under the Articles of Confederation the states held most of the power. Each state had one vote in Congress, legislatures chose and could recall their delegates, and Congress could only ask states for money. The Constitution of 1787 added a president and national courts, gave Congress listed powers and an elastic clause, and made valid federal law supreme. But it kept the states as partners, with reserved and concurrent powers, as the topic "The division of powers" explained.

States inside the national system

The Constitution gives states several roles in national government itself. Each state has two senators, whatever its population, and its number of House seats sets its weight in the Electoral College. States run federal elections, within rules Congress may set. They also control constitutional change: an amendment takes effect only when three-fourths of the states, 38 of 50, ratify it, usually through their legislatures. Only the Twenty-first Amendment (1933), which repealed Prohibition, was ratified by special state conventions instead. Article V also lets two-thirds of state legislatures, 34 of 50, apply for a convention to propose amendments, a route never yet used.

Worked example: a convention of the states

Many legislatures have applied for a convention to propose a federal balanced budget amendment, though counts of valid applications are disputed because some states later withdrew theirs. Suppose 30 valid applications exist. 1. Calling threshold: two-thirds of 50 is 33.3, so 34 are needed, 4 more. 2. If a convention proposes an amendment, three-fourths of 50 is 37.5, so 38 states must ratify. 3. So 13 refusing states can block it. 4. Supporters argue a convention would force fiscal discipline, as most state budgets must balance. 5. Opponents reply that Washington needs room to borrow in emergencies and that a first-ever convention's agenda is uncertain. 6. Conclusion: states control both ends of this route.

State constitutions

Every state has its own constitution. State constitutions are usually much longer and more detailed than the federal one, covering topics such as school funding and debt limits, and they are amended far more often, frequently by direct vote of the people. Almost every state must balance its operating budget, often under a constitutional rule. They can also protect rights more broadly than the U.S. Constitution, which sets only a minimum floor for individual rights. Finally, state constitutions and laws create the local governments below the state and decide what those governments may do.

Dillon's Rule: creatures of the state

The U.S. Constitution never mentions cities or counties, so power below the state level is a matter for each state. In an 1868 Iowa case, Judge John F. Dillon held that a local government has only the powers its state expressly grants, those clearly implied by them and those essential to its purpose; in doubtful cases, the local government loses. This is Dillon's Rule. The U.S. Supreme Court took a similar view in Hunter v. City of Pittsburgh (1907): states may create, merge, change or abolish their political subdivisions. In this sense, local governments exist at the pleasure of the state.

Home rule and state pre-emption

Many states loosen Dillon's Rule by granting home rule, which lets a local government manage its own affairs without asking the legislature each time. The grant is usually set out in a charter, a local document that works like a constitution. Home rule has limits, because state law generally wins a conflict. In 2014 voters in Denton, Texas, banned hydraulic fracturing inside the city; in 2015 the Texas legislature passed a law that blocked such local bans. States now pre-empt local rules on topics such as minimum wages and firearms. Supporters value uniform statewide rules; critics say pre-emption weakens local self-government.

How local governments pay their bills

Local governments spend most on schools, roads, policing and health. A large share of their money comes as transfers from the state and, less directly, from Washington. Their largest own source of revenue is the property tax on homes, land and business property: stable, but highly visible, because owners often pay it in one or two large bills. In 1978 California voters passed Proposition 13, which capped the basic tax at 1% of a property's assessed value, limited increases in that value to 2% a year and allowed a full reassessment only when the property changes hands. Many states later adopted their own limits.

Worked example: two neighbours under Proposition 13

Two identical houses stand side by side in California. 1. Owner A bought in 2000, when the house was assessed at $200,000. 2. Under Proposition 13, that value may rise by at most 2% a year, so after 25 years it can reach at most $200,000 × 1.02²⁵, about $328,000. 3. The basic tax is 1%, about $3,280 a year. 4. Owner B bought the house next door in 2025 for $900,000, so it was reassessed at the sale price, and B's basic tax is about $9,000. 5. Conclusion: similar homes can carry very different taxes. Supporters say this protects long-time owners; critics call it unfair to newer buyers.

When local budgets break

Local governments cannot print money and usually face state limits on taxing and borrowing. In a downturn they can be squeezed from several sides at once, as after the housing crash that began in 2007: falling property values, weaker sales tax receipts and cuts in state aid. Some cities turn to Chapter 9 of the federal bankruptcy code, which applies only to municipalities. Detroit filed in July 2013 with about $18 billion in debts and long-term obligations, the largest such case in U.S. history, after decades of population and job losses. It left bankruptcy in December 2014 with its debts restructured.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, local governments are not a third constitutional level like the states: the U.S. Constitution is silent about them, and states create them. Second, Dillon's Rule gives local governments narrow powers; it is home rule that widens them, and even home rule yields to state law in a conflict. Third, an Article V convention has never been held; every amendment so far was proposed by Congress. Fourth, Proposition 13 did not stop all reassessment: a property is reassessed when it changes hands. Fifth, Chapter 9 bankruptcy is only for municipalities; states themselves cannot use it.

Key takeaways

The Constitution strengthened the national government but kept the states as partners: they shape the Senate and Electoral College, run elections and control amendments, with 38 needed to ratify and 34 to call a convention. State constitutions are long, often amended and the source of local authority. Under Dillon's Rule and Hunter v. City of Pittsburgh (1907), local governments have only the powers states give them; home rule charters widen those powers, but states can still pre-empt. Local governments rely on state aid and property taxes, which limits such as Proposition 13 (1978) restrain, and can face severe fiscal stress, as in Detroit in 2013.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Articles of Confederation

The first US framework, under which the states held most power

One vote per state; Congress could not tax people directly.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A proposed amendment comes out of Congress. What is the minimum number of states that must ratify it?

Question 2 of 5

A city wants to create a new local tax, but the state constitution and laws are silent on it. Under a strict reading of Dillon's Rule, what follows?

Question 3 of 5

Under Proposition 13, why might two owners of identical neighbouring houses pay very different property taxes?

Question 4 of 5

In 2015 Texas passed a law blocking local fracking bans like Denton's. Which idea does this illustrate?

Question 5 of 5

Which statement about Detroit's 2013 bankruptcy is accurate?

← Previous topicNext topic →