American Government › Section M · The courts › Topic M.4

The Supreme Court

Thousands of people ask the Supreme Court to hear their case every year, and it agrees to hear only a tiny fraction. How nine justices choose their cases, who helps them, and how a case moves from petition to argument says a great deal about the Court's power.

Nine justices

The Judiciary Act of 1789 gave the Court six justices. Congress changed the number several times, between five and ten, before fixing it at nine in 1869, where it has stayed despite Franklin Roosevelt's failed plan of 1937 to add more. There is one chief justice and eight associate justices, all nominated by the president, confirmed by the Senate and serving during good behaviour. As of November 2026 the justices are Chief Justice John Roberts (appointed 2005) and Justices Clarence Thomas (1991), Samuel Alito (2006), Sonia Sotomayor (2009), Elena Kagan (2010), Neil Gorsuch (2017), Brett Kavanaugh (2018), Amy Coney Barrett (2020) and Ketanji Brown Jackson (2022).

Ideological balance

Six of the current justices were appointed by Republican presidents and three by Democratic presidents, and in many of the most closely watched cases the Court divides along those lines, six votes to three. Commentators therefore describe a conservative majority and a liberal minority. The labels oversimplify. Many decisions are unanimous, majorities often cross the usual lines, and individual justices sometimes break from their wing in particular areas, as Justice Gorsuch has in several cases on Native American treaty rights. The chief justice has no extra vote, but he presides, speaks first in private discussions and, when in the majority, decides who writes the opinion.

The Court's year and its helpers

The Court's term begins on the first Monday in October. It hears oral arguments from October to April and usually announces all its decisions by the end of June or early July. Each justice employs about four law clerks, usually recent top law graduates who serve for a year. Clerks screen petitions, many of them through a shared "cert pool" that most justices join, write memos recommending whether to hear cases, prepare justices for argument and help draft opinions. They also help with emergency applications, such as requests to halt an execution.

How cases arrive

A few cases, chiefly disputes between states, fall within the Court's original jurisdiction and begin there. Almost all others arrive by appeal, mostly through a petition for a writ of certiorari, which asks the Court to order a lower court to send up the record for review. The losing side below files the petition and is called the petitioner; the other side is the respondent. Cases can come from the federal courts of appeals or from a state's highest court when a federal question is involved. In recent years the Court has received roughly 4,000 petitions a term and granted only about 1%, hearing around 60 argued cases.

Worked example: reading a case name

Use Gideon v. Wainwright (1963) to decode a case name. 1. The first name is the petitioner, the party who lost below and asked for review: Clarence Earl Gideon, a Florida prisoner convicted without a lawyer. 2. The second is the respondent: Louie Wainwright, head of Florida's prison system, who held Gideon in custody. 3. Gideon sent a handwritten petition from prison, a reminder that the Court accepts petitions from people who cannot pay its fees. 4. The Court granted certiorari and appointed a lawyer to argue his side. 5. It ruled unanimously that states must provide lawyers to poor defendants in serious criminal cases. 6. Check: the order of names usually tells you who lost in the court below.

The rule of four and Rule 10

The justices vote on petitions in private conference, and a case is accepted if four of the nine agree, the rule of four. Their choices are guided by the Court's Rule 10, which stresses three kinds of conflict: courts of appeals disagreeing with each other on the same question, a lower court or state court deciding an important federal question in a way that conflicts with Supreme Court precedent, and state and federal courts in conflict. The Court also takes cases of great national importance, occasionally on a fast track, as in Bush v. Gore during the disputed 2000 election. Merely being wrongly decided below is rarely enough.

The solicitor general

The solicitor general is the Justice Department official who represents the United States before the Supreme Court. The office decides which lost cases the government will appeal, files the government's briefs and usually argues its cases. The federal government is a party in a large share of the Court's cases, and the justices sometimes invite the solicitor general to give the government's view on whether to hear a case in which it is not involved. Because the Court so often follows the office's advice, the solicitor general is nicknamed "the tenth justice". Thurgood Marshall held the office from 1965 to 1967, just before he joined the Court.

Briefs and amicus curiae

Once a case is accepted, the petitioner files a written brief setting out its legal arguments, the respondent replies, and the petitioner may answer. People and groups who are not parties but care about the outcome may file amicus curiae, or "friend of the court", briefs. Interest groups, businesses, states, members of Congress and the solicitor general all file them, and a major case can attract dozens. Amicus briefs can supply data, history or arguments the parties left out, and justices sometimes cite them in opinions. They are also a way for organised interests to take part in shaping the law, as the topic "Pathways of interest group influence" describes.

Worked example: will the Court take the case?

Weigh a petition the way the justices might. 1. Facts: a company lost in the Seventh Circuit over whether a federal employment law covers gig workers. 2. Check for a split: the Third Circuit has reached the opposite answer, so workers' rights now depend on where they live. That fits Rule 10. 3. Importance: millions of workers are affected, which raises the stakes. 4. Solicitor general: the justices invite the government's view, and it recommends granting review. 5. Vehicle: the facts are clear, so the case cleanly presents the legal question. 6. Conference: five justices vote to grant, more than the four needed. 7. Result: certiorari granted, and the case is scheduled for argument the following term.

Oral argument and the courtroom

In most cases each side gets 30 minutes to argue, but the justices interrupt constantly; argument is a chance for them to test the weak points of each position, not for lawyers to repeat their briefs. Since 2021 the justices have also each had a turn to ask questions in order of seniority once open questioning ends. Sessions open with the marshal's traditional cry of "Oyez! Oyez! Oyez!" The Court bans cameras, so television relies on artists' sketches, but it has released live audio of arguments since 2020. After argument the justices meet in private conference to vote; only the nine are present.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, the Court is not required to hear appeals; almost all of its cases are chosen through certiorari. Second, granting certiorari takes four votes, not a majority of five. Third, refusing to hear a case does not mean the Court agrees with the lower court; it simply leaves that ruling in place. Fourth, the number nine is set by Congress, not the Constitution. Fifth, the solicitor general is an executive branch lawyer, not a justice, despite the nickname "tenth justice".

Key takeaways

Congress fixed the Court at nine justices in 1869; as of November 2026, six were appointed by Republican presidents and three by Democratic ones. Terms begin in October, with arguments to April and decisions by early summer. Clerks screen petitions and help draft opinions. Most cases arrive by certiorari, granted under the rule of four and guided by Rule 10's focus on conflicts; only about 1% of petitions succeed. The solicitor general strongly influences the docket. Briefs and amicus briefs precede 30-minute oral arguments.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Nine justices

One chief justice and eight associate justices

Number fixed by Congress in 1869.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

How many justices must vote to grant a writ of certiorari?

Question 2 of 5

In the case name Gideon v. Wainwright, who was Gideon?

Question 3 of 5

Which situation does the Court's Rule 10 treat as a strong reason to grant review?

Question 4 of 5

Why is the solicitor general sometimes called "the tenth justice"?

Question 5 of 5

What does it mean when the Supreme Court denies a petition for certiorari?

← Previous topicNext topic →