American Government › Section M · The courts › Topic M.3
The federal court system
Below the Supreme Court sits a large network of trial and appeals courts that decides almost every federal case to its end. This topic explains how that network is built, why precedent holds it together, and how its judges are chosen.
Three tiers
The federal judiciary has a clear pyramid. Most cases begin in a district court, the trial level. A losing party can appeal to a court of appeals, also called a circuit court, and then ask the Supreme Court to review the case, which it agrees to do only rarely. Each level is bound by the rulings of the levels above it. Because the Supreme Court hears so few cases, the courts of appeals are the last word in the overwhelming majority of federal disputes. Article III requires only the Supreme Court; Congress created every lower federal court by statute and can reorganise them.
The district courts
There are 94 federal judicial districts. Eighty-nine are in the fifty states, with at least one in every state and up to four in the largest, and the others cover Washington DC, Puerto Rico, Guam, the US Virgin Islands and the Northern Mariana Islands. Districts have several judges, more than 600 in all, but a single judge presides over each case. District courts are where witnesses testify, evidence is presented and facts are found, sometimes by a jury. They also handle most federal criminal prosecutions, and specialised units within them hear bankruptcy cases.
The courts of appeals
There are 13 courts of appeals. Eleven numbered circuits each cover several states; the DC Circuit hears many cases about federal agencies; and the Federal Circuit, also in Washington, takes specialised appeals such as patent cases from anywhere in the country. Congress has authorised 179 appeals judges. Appeals courts hold no trials and hear no new evidence. A panel of three judges reviews the trial record for legal errors, and for an especially important case the whole circuit may rehear it together, called sitting en banc. Different circuits sometimes reach opposite answers to the same legal question, a circuit split that often draws the Supreme Court's attention.
How the system grew
The Judiciary Act of 1789 created 13 district courts and three circuit courts, but circuit courts had no judges of their own. Two Supreme Court justices and a local district judge sat together, and the justices travelled set routes, or circuits, to hear cases, which gave the courts their name. Justices long complained about these hard journeys. As caseloads grew, the Evarts Act of 1891 created separate circuit courts of appeals to handle most appeals, and in 1911 Congress abolished the old circuit courts and made the district courts the general federal trial courts. The structure has stayed largely the same since.
Specialised federal courts
Some federal courts handle one kind of case. The Court of International Trade hears disputes over imports and tariffs; the Court of Federal Claims hears money claims against the US government; the Tax Court hears disputes with the Internal Revenue Service. Courts-martial are reviewed by a separate military appeals court, and veterans' benefits disputes have their own appeals court too. The Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court reviews government requests for national security surveillance. Several of these are created under Congress's Article I powers, so their judges serve fixed terms rather than for life.
Precedent holds the system together
Federal courts follow stare decisis, Latin for "to stand by things decided": once a court has decided a legal question, it and the courts below it decide similar cases the same way. A Supreme Court ruling binds every court in the country; a circuit's ruling binds the district courts within that circuit. Precedent makes the law predictable and treats people in similar situations alike, which matters for unelected judges whose authority depends on public trust. It is not frozen, however. New judges, facts and arguments can lead courts to overturn precedent, as Brown v. Board of Education (1954) did to Plessy v. Ferguson (1896).
Worked example: one question, two circuits
Suppose a federal law bans a certain kind of online gambling, and its wording is unclear about whether a new app is covered. 1. A district court in Texas rules that the app is covered. 2. On appeal, the Fifth Circuit agrees. That precedent now binds every district court in Texas, Louisiana and Mississippi. 3. Meanwhile, a district court in California rules the opposite way, and the Ninth Circuit affirms. 4. Result: the same app is illegal in one region and legal in another under one national law. 5. This circuit split is a strong reason for the Supreme Court to take the case. 6. Once the Court rules, its answer binds every federal court, ending the split. 7. Lesson: precedent is binding vertically, so national uniformity depends on the top court.
Choosing federal judges
All Article III judges are nominated by the president and confirmed by a majority of the Senate, and they serve during good behaviour. The Senate Judiciary Committee holds hearings and votes before the full Senate decides. The American Bar Association often rates nominees' qualifications, though presidents differ in how much weight they give it. By the custom of senatorial courtesy, presidents consult home-state senators on district court vacancies, and through the blue slip, a form returned to the Judiciary Committee, those senators can still delay or block district court nominees; since 2017 the committee has stopped treating blue slips as a veto for appeals court nominees.
Ideology, legacy and surprises
Because judges serve for decades, appointments are among a president's longest-lasting legacies, and presidents usually choose nominees who share their judicial philosophy. Donald Trump's first term and Joe Biden's term each added more than 230 Article III judges. Yet judges do not always rule as expected. Dwight Eisenhower's choice of Earl Warren as chief justice led to a strongly liberal era. Republican appointees David Souter and Anthony Kennedy sometimes sided with liberal colleagues, and Chief Justice John Roberts cast the deciding vote upholding the Affordable Care Act's insurance mandate in 2012. Life tenure is meant to give judges exactly that independence.
Worked example: a more diverse bench
Read the record of Supreme Court firsts as evidence of change. 1. Until 1836 every justice was a white Protestant man, and until 1967 every justice was a white man. 2. Roger Taney became the first Catholic justice in 1836, and Louis Brandeis the first Jewish justice in 1916. 3. Thurgood Marshall became the first African American justice in 1967 and Sandra Day O'Connor the first woman in 1981. 4. Sonia Sotomayor became the first Hispanic justice in 2009, and Ketanji Brown Jackson the first African American woman in 2022. 5. Interpretation: the Court has slowly come to resemble the country more closely, a trend also seen in the lower courts, though white men remain overrepresented there compared with their share of the population.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, a district court has several judges, but each case is heard by one judge. Second, courts of appeals do not hold new trials; they review the record for legal error. Third, a circuit's precedent binds only courts within that circuit, while a Supreme Court ruling binds all courts. Fourth, the Constitution created only the Supreme Court; the lower courts exist by act of Congress. Fifth, not every federal judge has life tenure: judges of Article I courts such as the Tax Court serve fixed terms.
Key takeaways
Federal cases move from 94 district courts, where one judge hears each trial, to 13 courts of appeals, where three-judge panels review legal errors, and rarely to the Supreme Court. Congress built this system, from circuit riding in 1789 to the Evarts Act of 1891, and added specialised courts. Stare decisis binds lower courts to higher ones, and circuit splits invite Supreme Court review. The president nominates judges and the Senate confirms them, with home-state senators influential through the blue slip. Appointments shape legacies, though judges can surprise, and the bench has grown more diverse.
Flashcards
Flashcard
The 94 federal trial courts
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
What does a federal court of appeals do when it hears a case?
Question 2 of 5
The Fourth Circuit decides a legal question. Which courts must follow that precedent?
Question 3 of 5
Why are the federal circuit courts called "circuits"?
Question 4 of 5
How can home-state senators influence nominations to federal district courts?
Question 5 of 5
Which statement about federal judges is correct?
