American Government › Section I · Political parties › Topic I.2

The two-party system

Many democracies have five or more parties in their legislatures, yet American politics has run on two for more than 160 years. The main reason is not voter taste but the rules for counting votes, reinforced by laws and history.

Two parties, many voices

Since 1860 every presidential election has been won by a Democrat or a Republican, and almost every member of Congress has belonged to one of the two. A handful of independents sit in Congress, usually joining one party's caucus. That is unusual among democracies. Germany, the Netherlands and many others regularly send several parties to their parliaments and govern through coalitions. Political scientists explain the American pattern mainly through electoral rules, especially how winners are chosen, and then through the Electoral College, ballot laws and the country's history.

Winner-take-all and plurality

Most American legislators are elected from single-member districts: each district sends exactly one person, and the winner takes the whole seat. The usual rule is plurality voting, also called first past the post, under which whoever tops the count takes the seat, even without a majority. A majority means more than half of the votes cast; a plurality is simply more than anyone else. A few states use majoritarian rules instead, holding a runoff when no one passes half. In 1860 Abraham Lincoln won the presidency with about 40 percent of the popular vote because his three rivals split the rest. Under these rules a party that finishes second everywhere wins nothing.

Duverger's law

The French political scientist Maurice Duverger argued in the 1950s that plurality voting in single-member districts tends to produce two-party competition. He identified two effects. The mechanical effect: small parties win few or no seats because they rarely come first in any district. The psychological effect: voters who prefer a small party fear wasting their vote and switch to the major candidate they dislike least, and donors and strong candidates avoid parties that cannot win. Over time support drains away from minor parties. Duverger's law describes a strong tendency, not an iron rule, as the cases below show.

Worked example: a wasted vote

A district race ends: Candidate A 46 percent, Candidate B 44 percent, minor-party Candidate C 10 percent. 1. Apply plurality: A wins the seat with 46 percent, although most voters chose someone else. 2. Look at C's voters: suppose most of them preferred B to A. Their votes for C did not change the seat except by denying it to B. 3. Predict the next election: many of C's supporters switch to B to avoid helping A, Duverger's psychological effect. 4. Predict C's future: with fewer votes and no seats, C struggles to raise money or recruit candidates. 5. Conclusion: the rules reward joining one of two large coalitions.

Proportional representation

Many democracies use proportional representation instead. Voters mainly choose a party, often from a list of its candidates, and seats in multi-member districts or a national legislature are shared out roughly in proportion to each party's vote. A party with 12 percent of the vote wins about 12 percent of the seats, although many systems set a minimum threshold, such as 5 percent, before a party gets any. Proportional systems usually give voters more choices and smaller parties a foothold, but they often require coalition governments, which can take weeks or months to negotiate after an election.

Worked example: one vote, two systems

A country elects a 100-seat legislature. Party X wins 48 percent of the vote, Party Y 37 percent and Party Z 15 percent, with Z's support spread evenly but never leading in any district. 1. Plurality in 100 single-member districts: Z comes first nowhere, so it wins 0 seats; X and Y divide all 100. 2. Proportional representation with no threshold: X gets 48 seats, Y 37 and Z 15. 3. Majority check: under proportional rules no party has the 51 seats needed for a majority, so X must form a coalition, probably with Z. 4. Conclusion: the same votes can produce a two-party legislature or a three-party one.

More forces that protect two parties

Duverger's law is not the whole story. Britain and Canada also use plurality districts, yet several parties win seats there, often because their support is concentrated in particular regions. In the United States, other features add to the effect. The Electoral College awards all of a state's electors to the statewide winner in 48 states and Washington, D.C.; only Maine and Nebraska award some by congressional district. State ballot access laws often require new parties and independents to gather thousands of petition signatures. Presidential debate organisers have typically required about 15 percent support in national polls. Some scholars add that the country lacks large regional or ethnic blocs that sustain separate parties elsewhere.

Spoilers and influence

A third-party candidate who draws enough votes to change which major candidate wins is called a spoiler. In 1912 Theodore Roosevelt's Progressive campaign split the Republican vote and helped Woodrow Wilson win. In 2000 the Green candidate Ralph Nader won about 97,000 votes in Florida, which George W. Bush carried by 537 votes; some analysts argue Nader cost Al Gore the presidency, while others note that many Nader voters would not have voted for Gore. Ross Perot, an independent, won about 19 percent of the popular vote in 1992 but no electoral votes. Third parties also influence politics by raising issues the major parties then adopt.

Realignment and critical elections

The two parties have survived by changing. A party realignment is a lasting shift in which groups of voters change their party loyalties. It is often marked by a critical election that reshapes coalitions for decades. In 1932, during the Great Depression, Franklin D. Roosevelt won 472 electoral votes to Herbert Hoover's 59. His New Deal coalition of labour unions, urban voters, immigrant communities, White Southerners and, increasingly, Black voters kept Democrats dominant for a generation. A slower realignment followed the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and the Voting Rights Act of 1965: over several decades many White Southern voters moved from the Democrats to the Republicans.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, equating plurality with majority: a plurality is the most votes, a majority is more than half. Second, thinking the Constitution sets up two parties; electoral rules and history do. Third, treating Duverger's law as absolute; Britain and Canada show plurality systems can sustain several parties. Fourth, assuming proportional representation is simply better: it widens choice but tends to require coalitions. Fifth, claiming a spoiler definitely changed an outcome; that depends on what its voters would otherwise have done.

Key takeaways

Single-member districts with plurality voting reward only first place, so minor parties win few seats and voters shy away from them, as Duverger's law predicts. Proportional representation shares seats by vote share and usually produces more parties and coalition governments. The winner-take-all Electoral College, ballot access laws and debate thresholds reinforce two-party dominance in the United States. Third parties can act as spoilers and push new issues. The parties endure by realigning, as after the critical election of 1932 and the long Southern shift that followed the civil rights laws of the 1960s.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Single-member district

A district that elects exactly one representative

The winner takes the whole seat.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A state senate race ends 41 percent, 38 percent and 21 percent. Under plurality voting, what happens?

Question 2 of 5

Which statement best expresses Duverger's law?

Question 3 of 5

Under proportional representation with no threshold, a party wins 9 percent of the vote for a 200-seat legislature. About how many seats does it get?

Question 4 of 5

Why do political scientists call 1932 a critical election?

Question 5 of 5

What do the party systems of Britain and Canada show about Duverger's law?

← Previous topicNext topic →