American Government › Section I · Political parties › Topic I.1
What parties are and how they formed
The Constitution never mentions political parties, and several of its framers hoped the country could do without them. Within a decade of ratification two parties were competing for power, and parties have organised American elections and government ever since.
A system nobody planned
Millions of voters disagree about taxes, schools, rights and foreign affairs. Someone has to gather those scattered opinions into a short list of programmes and people that voters can actually choose between, and then turn the winning programme into law. In the United States that job falls largely to political parties. They are not branches of government, yet they shape almost every election and organise Congress and the state legislatures from within.
What a political party is
A political party is an organisation of people with broadly shared goals who try to control government by winning elections under a common name, or label. Its positions are set out in a platform, which each major party adopts at its national convention every four years. Parties and interest groups are both linkage institutions, meaning they carry public preferences to officials. The difference is method. An interest group tries to influence whoever holds office, often working with both parties. A party puts forward its own candidates, so its members become the officeholders. The next section of this course, Interest groups and lobbying, looks at groups in detail.
What parties do
Political scientists list several jobs that parties perform. They recruit and nominate candidates, run campaigns, raise money and mobilise voters. Their labels simplify choices: a voter who knows little about two candidates for state treasurer can still use the party name as a guide to their likely views. In government, the majority party in each chamber of Congress chooses its leaders and committee chairs and largely controls which bills reach a vote. The party out of power acts as the loyal opposition, criticising the majority and offering voters an alternative at the next election.
Warnings against faction
Many founders distrusted parties. In Federalist No. 10, published in 1787, James Madison defined a faction as a group united by an interest or passion opposed to the rights of others or the good of the whole. He argued that factions could not be abolished without destroying liberty, so a large republic should be designed to control their effects. In his Farewell Address of 1796, George Washington, who usually backed Hamilton's policies but disliked organised parties, warned that party spirit could divide the nation and serve partisan ends instead of the common good. Ironically, Madison himself helped found one of the first two parties.
The first party system
The first split came over Alexander Hamilton's financial programme in the early 1790s, including a national bank and federal assumption of state war debts. Hamilton's supporters, the Federalists, favoured a strong national government that would promote commerce and manufacturing. Thomas Jefferson and Madison organised the Democratic-Republicans, who favoured a more limited national government, the interests of farmers and a strict reading of federal powers. The Federalist John Adams won the presidency in 1796, with Jefferson as his vice president. Jefferson won in 1800. The Federalists lost ground in the following years and faded after opposing the War of 1812, leaving a period of one-party rule.
Worked example: the tie of 1800
1. The rule: each elector cast two votes for president, with no separate vote for vice president. The runner-up became vice president. 2. The party move: Democratic-Republican electors voted as a bloc for both Jefferson and his running mate, Aaron Burr. 3. The result: Jefferson and Burr tied at 73 electoral votes each, and the House of Representatives had to choose. It took 36 ballots before Jefferson won in February 1801. 4. The fix: the Twelfth Amendment, ratified in 1804, gave electors separate votes for president and vice president. 5. Conclusion: the framers designed the system for individuals, and the amendment adapted it to party tickets.
Jackson and the first mass party
In 1824 four candidates, all Democratic-Republicans, ran for president. Andrew Jackson led in both popular and electoral votes, with 99 electoral votes, but no one had a majority, so the House chose among the top three. Henry Clay, who had finished fourth, backed John Quincy Adams, who won; when Adams made Clay secretary of state, Jackson's supporters called it a corrupt bargain. Jackson's followers, organised by Martin Van Buren, became the Democratic Party and won in 1828. States had largely dropped property requirements for White men, and the Democrats built local organisations to mobilise these new voters. Party loyalty was rewarded with government jobs, the spoils system. Jackson's opponents formed the Whig Party in the 1830s.
Republicans and the lasting pair
The Whigs broke apart in the 1850s over slavery. In 1854, opponents of the Kansas-Nebraska Act, which let settlers in the two new territories decide on slavery for themselves, founded the Republican Party, drawing on former Whigs, Free Soilers and anti-slavery Democrats. Its aim was to stop slavery's expansion into the territories. In 1860 Abraham Lincoln won the presidency with about 40 percent of the popular vote in a four-way race. Since 1860, every presidential election has been won by a Republican or a Democrat. Their coalitions have changed dramatically, as the next topic explains, but the two labels have endured.
Minor parties and their ideas
Parties outside the two major ones are called third parties or minor parties. They rarely win, but some have shaped policy. The People's Party, or Populists, formed by farmers in the early 1890s, demanded an income tax, direct election of senators and government ownership of the railroads. In 1912 Theodore Roosevelt ran for the Progressive Party, nicknamed the Bull Moose Party, on a platform that included direct election of senators, women's suffrage and an eight-hour workday. Both major parties later adopted several of these ideas: the Sixteenth Amendment allowed a federal income tax and the Seventeenth provided for direct election of senators, both ratified in 1913.
Worked example: party or interest group?
Classify each organisation from what it does. 1. An organisation nominates candidates for the state senate, and their names appear on the ballot under its label. It seeks to hold office itself, so it is a party. 2. A teachers' association endorses candidates from both parties and lobbies the state education committee. It seeks to influence officeholders rather than become them, so it is an interest group. 3. A small organisation runs a candidate for governor under its own name but wins only 2 percent of the vote. Winning is not the test: running candidates under its label makes it a minor party. 4. Check: the key question is always whether the organisation contests elections under its own name.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, thinking the Constitution created the parties: it never mentions them, and they grew up outside it. Second, assuming today's Democrats and Republicans have always held their present positions; their coalitions have shifted greatly. Third, confusing parties with interest groups: only parties run candidates under their own label. Fourth, believing the 1800 tie was between Jefferson and Adams; it was between Jefferson and his own running mate, Burr. Fifth, writing off third parties as pointless: several of their proposals became constitutional amendments.
Key takeaways
A political party seeks to control government by winning elections under a shared label and platform; interest groups influence officeholders without running candidates. Parties nominate, campaign, mobilise, simplify choices, organise government and provide a loyal opposition. Despite warnings against faction, Federalists and Democratic-Republicans formed in the 1790s, and the tie of 1800 led to the Twelfth Amendment. Jackson's Democrats built the first mass party, opposed by the Whigs, and the Republicans formed in 1854. Democrats and Republicans have won every presidential election since 1860, while third parties such as the Populists and Progressives pushed ideas the major parties later adopted.
Flashcards
Flashcard
An organisation that seeks to control government by winning elections under a shared label
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
What most clearly separates a political party from an interest group?
Question 2 of 5
Why was the Twelfth Amendment adopted in 1804?
Question 3 of 5
In the election of 1824, why did the House of Representatives choose the president?
Question 4 of 5
A voter knows nothing about the two candidates for state auditor but picks the one from the party she usually supports. Which function of parties is she relying on?
Question 5 of 5
Which Populist and Progressive proposal became part of the Constitution in 1913?
