Anthropology › Section C · The culture concept › Topic C.4
Cultural groups and aggregates
Objects, practices and ideas rarely appear alone. They combine into larger units, symbols, rituals and social structures, and they are carried by groups at several levels at once, from a local community to a worldwide religion.
Putting the elements together
The elements of culture explained how anthropologists separate what people make, do and think. In real life the three are bundled together. A national flag is a piece of cloth (made), raised at dawn and saluted at ceremonies (done), and taken to stand for a nation's history and loyalty (thought). Such a combination is called an aggregate of culture. This topic looks at three important aggregates, symbols, rituals and social structures, and then at the groups that share culture, which range in scale from a neighbourhood to a global faith.
Symbols as shorthand
A symbol packs a complex set of ideas into a single object, image, gesture or sound. The British anthropologist Victor Turner, working among the Ndembu of what is now Zambia in the 1950s, showed how one symbol can carry many meanings at once. The mudyi tree, whose sap is milky white, stood for breast milk, for the bond between mother and child, and for the line of descent traced through women. Turner called such symbols multivocal: they speak with many voices, which is why they can unite people who read them slightly differently.
Symbols can be contested
Because symbols carry many meanings, groups can disagree about them. In Britain the red paper poppy worn each November honours those who died in war, and many people see wearing one as a duty of respect. Others prefer a white poppy, introduced in 1933 by the Co-operative Women's Guild, to stress peace and to remember all victims of war, while some critics see the red poppy as glorifying the military. The object is tiny, but the debate shows that a symbol's meaning is held in common and argued over at the same time.
Ritual
A ritual is a repeated, patterned set of actions with conventional meanings, combining symbols, roles and ideas about how the world works. Diwali, the Hindu festival of lights, also marked by many Sikhs and Jains, is a widely celebrated example. Families clean and decorate their homes, light rows of small clay lamps called diyas, share sweets and, in many households, worship the goddess Lakshmi. The lamps symbolise the victory of light over darkness and good over evil. By repeating the same actions each year, participants enact their worldview and renew bonds among family and community.
Rites of passage
Some rituals move people from one social status to another: naming ceremonies, coming-of-age rites, weddings and funerals. The French folklorist Arnold van Gennep, in The Rites of Passage (1909), identified three stages: separation from the old status, a transitional middle stage, and incorporation into the new status. Victor Turner later called the in-between stage liminal, a time when people are neither one thing nor the other and often share an intense sense of fellowship. Rituals of transition and conformity examines these rites in depth.
Worked example: a bat mitzvah
Analyse a Jewish bat mitzvah, held for a girl at 12 or 13. 1. Separation: in the months before, she studies Hebrew and a Torah portion apart from her usual routine. 2. Transition: on the day she stands before the congregation, no longer a child but not yet recognised as an adult member. 3. Incorporation: after reading from the Torah she is treated as responsible for keeping the commandments, and in many congregations can be counted in a prayer quorum. 4. Symbols and material culture: the Torah scroll and, often, a prayer shawl. 5. Check: the ritual combines objects, actions and ideas to change her status. Customs differ between Orthodox, Conservative and Reform communities.
Social structure
Social structure is the formal organisation of a realm of social life, such as politics, the economy or religion. It sets who does what, when, where and how, and it combines material culture (a meeting house), practices (meetings) and ideas (rules of procedure). Among the Haudenosaunee, the confederacy of nations that includes the Mohawk and Seneca, clan mothers have long nominated the chiefs who sit on the Grand Council and can remove them. Structures are not fixed machines: people keep remaking them through participation, reinterpretation and resistance.
Groups at many levels
Culture is carried by groups of different sizes, and every person belongs to several. Some culture is international, shared across borders, such as a world religion, a profession or global consumer culture. Some is national, shared by citizens through a common language, schooling and holidays. Within nations are subcultures, groups with distinctive ways of life based on region, ethnicity, religion, occupation or age, which the Sociology course explores further. A diaspora is a community that keeps cultural ties to a homeland while living across many countries.
Worked example: one person's groups
Map the cultural memberships of a Korean American nurse in Los Angeles. 1. National: she votes, celebrates Thanksgiving and speaks American English at work. 2. International: as a Catholic she shares rituals with believers worldwide, and as a nurse she shares professional norms with nurses in many countries. 3. Subculture: in the Korean American community she speaks Korean with her parents and marks the Lunar New Year. 4. Diaspora: she follows news from South Korea and visits relatives there. 5. Check: she moves between these levels daily, using each set of norms where it fits; no one level is her whole culture.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, assuming a symbol has a single fixed meaning: many are multivocal and some are contested. Second, treating every repeated habit as a ritual: ritual carries conventional, often sacred or social, meanings. Third, forgetting the middle stage of a rite of passage, the liminal period. Fourth, seeing social structure as a permanent machine rather than something people keep remaking. Fifth, assuming each person belongs to only one culture, when everyone moves between several levels.
Key takeaways
Aggregates combine what people make, do and think. Symbols are shorthand for complex ideas; Turner's Ndembu work (1950s) showed they can be multivocal, and symbols such as the remembrance poppy can be contested. Rituals are patterned, meaningful actions, such as Diwali. Van Gennep (1909) found three stages in rites of passage: separation, transition and incorporation; Turner called the middle stage liminal. Social structure organises a realm of life and is remade by people. Culture is shared at international, national and subcultural levels, and individuals belong to several.
Flashcards
Flashcard
A combination of objects, practices and ideas
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Victor Turner found that the Ndembu mudyi tree stood for breast milk, the mother-child bond and descent through women. What did he call such a symbol?
Question 2 of 5
What are the three stages of a rite of passage identified by van Gennep (1909)?
Question 3 of 5
In Britain some people wear a red poppy in November and others choose a white peace poppy. What does this show about symbols?
Question 4 of 5
During a bat mitzvah, the girl stands before the congregation no longer a child but not yet recognised as an adult member. Which stage is this?
Question 5 of 5
A Korean American nurse shares Catholic rituals worldwide, votes in US elections and speaks Korean with her parents. What does this best illustrate?
