Anthropology › Section C · The culture concept › Topic C.5

Modes of cultural analysis

Since the 19th century anthropologists have asked different questions of culture: where it came from, what it does, what patterns of thought lie beneath it, and what counts as real. Each question produced a school of analysis, and each still shapes how the field works.

Many questions, many methods

Faced with the same custom, anthropologists can ask very different questions. How did it develop over time? What need does it meet today? What hidden pattern of thinking does it express? What kind of world do the people who practise it live in? Over about 150 years, each question became the core of a mode of analysis. Some, such as ranking cultures on a ladder of progress, have been abandoned. Others remain in use, often combined. Knowing them helps you see why two anthropologists can study one festival and write two very different accounts.

Unilineal evolutionism

Inspired by ideas of evolution, many 19th-century scholars believed all cultures climbed the same ladder of stages. Edward Tylor and the American lawyer and ethnologist Lewis Henry Morgan both named the stages savagery, barbarism and civilisation, and Morgan's Ancient Society (1877) subdivided them; those labels are quoted here only as historical usage. Morgan tied each stage to technology, such as pottery or the alphabet. Foraging peoples were placed at the bottom and industrial Europe at the top. Because it assumes one line of development for everyone, this approach is called unilineal evolution.

Boas and historical particularism

The German-born American anthropologist Franz Boas rejected the ladder in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. He argued that there was no evidence all societies pass through the same stages, that the scheme simply ranked others by European values, and that it had been used to justify racism and colonial rule. Each culture, Boas said, has its own history, shaped by local conditions and by contact with neighbours. This view is called historical particularism. Boas stressed diffusion, the spread of traits between societies; the American anthropologist Ralph Linton's essay "One Hundred Percent American" (1937) traced how much of an American's day was borrowed from elsewhere.

Ecology and materialism

Some anthropologists kept looking for regular patterns of change without the ladder. Julian Steward, in Theory of Culture Change (1955), developed cultural ecology: people in similar environments, using similar ways of getting food, tend to develop similar core features. He spoke of multilinear evolution, many paths rather than one. Marvin Harris went further with cultural materialism, arguing that technology, economy and environment shape family life, politics and religion. Critics reply that ideas and meanings can drive change too, not only material conditions.

Malinowski's functionalism

Bronisław Malinowski, a Polish-born anthropologist working in Britain, lived among the Trobriand Islanders of what is now Papua New Guinea during the First World War and pioneered long-term participant observation. His functionalism asked what each custom does for people now, not where it came from. Culture meets basic needs such as food and shelter, derived needs such as organising work, and integrative needs for meaning and order, met by religion and law. His Argonauts of the Western Pacific (1922) showed that the Kula exchange of shell valuables was a complex, rational system.

Structural functionalism

The British anthropologist A. R. Radcliffe-Brown, author of The Andaman Islanders (1922), took a different line. Instead of individual needs, he asked how institutions such as kinship, law and religion fit together and keep a society stable, much as organs keep a body alive. This structural functionalism encouraged anthropologists to see culture as an integrated whole, an idea behind the holism described in Holism, anthropology's distinctive approach. Critics noted that it struggled to explain conflict and change, and that studies in this mode often ignored the colonial rule under which fieldwork took place.

Structuralism

The French anthropologist Claude Lévi-Strauss looked for structure in thought rather than in institutions. He argued that the human mind organises the world through binary oppositions such as raw and cooked, nature and culture, or male and female, and that myths, kinship and food rules work through these pairs. His four-volume study of Indigenous American myths began with The Raw and the Cooked (1964). The British anthropologist Mary Douglas, in Purity and Danger (1966), drew on similar ideas: things that break a culture's categories, such as the scaly, tree-climbing pangolin among the Lele of Congo, tend to be treated as dangerous, taboo or sacred.

The ontological turn

Since the 1990s some anthropologists have asked not only how people interpret one shared world, but whether they live in different worlds. Ontology is the study of what exists. The Brazilian anthropologist Eduardo Viveiros de Castro described Amazonian perspectivism, in which animals and spirits are persons who see themselves as human. Eduardo Kohn's How Forests Think (2013), based on work with Runa people in Ecuador, explores communication among people, dogs, jaguars and plants. Supporters say this takes Indigenous knowledge seriously; critics worry it can exaggerate difference and make others seem exotic.

Worked example: cattle in India

Many Hindus in India do not eat beef and honour cows. Compare three modes. 1. Cultural materialism: Marvin Harris argued in about 1966 that live cattle were worth more than meat, supplying oxen for ploughing, dung for fuel and fertiliser, and milk, so the taboo protected a vital resource. 2. Functionalism: shared reverence for the cow unites worshippers and marks group identity. 3. Structuralism: the cow sits in a scheme of pure and impure categories, so eating it would cross a basic boundary. 4. Historical particularism: attitudes changed over centuries, shaped by religious reform and politics. 5. Check: each mode answers a different question, and the answers can coexist.

Worked example: naming the mode

Match each research question to its mode. 1. "Why does this village's harvest festival unite rival clans each year?" This asks what a custom does now: functionalism. 2. "Why do this people's myths keep pairing the sky with men and the earth with women?" This seeks patterns of opposition in thought: structuralism. 3. "How did this pottery style reach the coast from inland trading partners?" This traces borrowing and local history: historical particularism. 4. "Do herders in dry grasslands everywhere develop similar ways of sharing land?" This links culture to environment: cultural ecology. 5. Check: identify what the question treats as the cause or key, whether needs, thought, history or environment.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, thinking unilineal evolutionism is still accepted: anthropologists rejected the ladder long ago. Second, confusing Malinowski's functionalism, about meeting human needs, with Radcliffe-Brown's structural functionalism, about institutions fitting together. Third, confusing structural functionalism, which studies social institutions, with structuralism, which studies patterns of thought. Fourth, assuming one mode must be right: each suits different questions. Fifth, reading the ontological turn as a claim that beliefs are mistaken; it asks what people take to be real.

Key takeaways

Unilineal evolutionism (Tylor; Morgan, 1877) ranked cultures on one ladder and was rejected as ethnocentric. Boas's historical particularism stressed each culture's own history and diffusion between cultures. Steward's cultural ecology (1955) and Harris's cultural materialism link culture to environment and technology. Malinowski's functionalism asks how culture meets needs; Radcliffe-Brown's structural functionalism asks how institutions fit together. Lévi-Strauss's structuralism and Douglas (1966) study categories and binary oppositions. The ontological turn asks what different peoples take to exist.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Unilineal evolution

The rejected idea that all cultures climb one ladder of stages

Tylor and Morgan, 19th century.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Why did Franz Boas reject unilineal evolutionism?

Question 2 of 5

Which approach asks how institutions such as kinship, law and religion fit together to keep a society stable?

Question 3 of 5

Marvin Harris explained the Hindu reverence for cattle by pointing to oxen for ploughing, dung for fuel and milk. Which mode of analysis is this?

Question 4 of 5

Mary Douglas argued that the Lele treated the pangolin as special because it has scales yet lives on land and climbs trees. What idea does this illustrate?

Question 5 of 5

What does the ontological turn in anthropology mainly ask?

← Previous topicNext topic →