Anthropology › Section R · Humans and animals › Topic R.5

Animal industries and the animal trade

Zoos, wildlife tours, laboratories and meat-packing plants all turn animals into sources of income, knowledge or food. Anthropologists study these industries to ask how societies justify them, who does the work, and how attitudes to animals are changing.

Animals as commodities

A commodity is something produced or obtained in order to be bought and sold. Over the past two centuries, industrial societies have increasingly treated animals in this way, as raw material for food, clothing, entertainment and science. This is a large change from the relationships of respect described among many hunters and herders in Animals and subsistence. Anthropologists study animal industries the way they study any economy: through fieldwork with the people who run them, work in them and consume their products. Four examples show the range: zoos, ecotourism, biomedical research and industrial meat production. Each mixes commercial interest with claims about education, conservation or human benefit.

Royal menageries

Keeping wild animals for display is ancient. At Hierakonpolis in southern Egypt, archaeologists found burials, more than 5,000 years old, of animals such as baboons, hippopotamuses, wildcats and an elephant near an elite cemetery; some had healed injuries suggesting long captivity. When Spanish invaders reached the Aztec capital, Tenochtitlan, in 1519, they described Moctezuma's great collection of jaguars, eagles, snakes and other creatures, cared for by a large staff. Such collections displayed a ruler's power and reach. Like early pet-keeping, keeping exotic animals marked wealth and status.

Zoos and empire

Modern public zoos arose with European science and empire. The Paris menagerie at the Jardin des Plantes opened in 1793, the Zoological Society of London founded its zoo in 1828, and the Philadelphia Zoo opened in 1874. Animals captured in colonies filled their cages, and visitors came to see the exotic. Some exhibitions also displayed people. In 1906 the Bronx Zoo in New York exhibited Ota Benga, a Mbuti man from the Congo, in its monkey house, until Black ministers protested and he was released from the display. Such human zoos, common in Europe and the United States into the early 20th century, expressed the racist ranking of peoples that anthropology later rejected.

Zoos reinvented

Since the 1970s many zoos have recast themselves as centres of conservation. The Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora (CITES), signed in 1973 and in force from 1975, and the US Endangered Species Act of 1973 restricted trade in wild animals, so zoos turned to breeding their own. Accredited zoos now run cooperative breeding programmes, exchanging animals to keep populations genetically diverse, and some release animals into the wild. Critics question whether most zoo species benefit, and whether confinement harms animals such as elephants and orcas. The debate is whether a zoo is chiefly a conservation centre, a museum or entertainment.

Worked example: counting condors

The California condor is a widely cited captive-breeding success. 1. Low point: about 22 condors survived in 1982, and by 1987 every remaining wild bird had been captured for breeding in zoos. 2. Recovery: at the end of 2025 the US Fish and Wildlife Service counted 607 condors, 392 of them flying free. 3. Growth: 607 divided by 22 is about 27.6, so the population is roughly 28 times its low point. 4. Wild share: 392 divided by 607 is about 0.646, so roughly 65% now live in the wild. 5. Caution: wild condors still die from lead in the carcasses they eat, so the species depends on continued management. 6. Conclusion: captive breeding can rescue a species, but only alongside work on the threats that caused its decline.

Ecotourism

Ecotourism is travel to natural areas that aims to conserve the environment and benefit local people. Visitors come to watch wildlife in its habitat, and their spending can fund protection, create local jobs and raise awareness of biological and cultural diversity. No global standard defines it, however. Some operations crowd animals for photographs, build in fragile habitats or send most profits abroad. Critics call claims of sustainability that hide damaging practices greenwashing. Anthropologists also ask who decides: protected areas have sometimes been created by removing Indigenous and local residents, who then see tourists enjoying land they may no longer use.

The Galápagos model

The Galápagos Islands of Ecuador, famous for the observations Charles Darwin made there in 1835, show ecotourism's promise and strain. Ecuador made most of the islands a national park in 1959, and UNESCO listed them as a World Heritage Site in 1978. The park now covers about 97% of the land, with people living in the remaining settled areas. Visitor numbers grew rapidly from the 1990s, bringing jobs but also pressure on water, wildlife and introduced species. On 1 August 2024 Ecuador doubled the park entry fee for most foreign adult visitors, from $100 to $200, its first rise since 1998, to fund conservation and community services.

Animals in the laboratory

A 2019 study by Katy Taylor and Laura Rego Alvarez estimated that about 192 million animals were used for scientific purposes worldwide in 2015, across 179 countries, with mice and rats the most commonly used. In the United States, the Animal Welfare Act of 1966 regulates the care of animals such as dogs, cats, rabbits and primates, but excludes the rats, mice and birds bred for research. Federally funded institutions must also have an Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee, which reviews every proposed study. Since 1959 researchers have been urged to follow the 3Rs: replace animals where possible, reduce their numbers and refine procedures to limit suffering. Animal research has contributed to vaccines and many treatments, and its ethics remain contested.

Worked example: the kill floor

The political scientist Timothy Pachirat worked for about five months in an industrial slaughterhouse in Omaha, Nebraska, and published Every Twelve Seconds (2011). 1. Pace: one animal killed every 12 seconds is 3,600 divided by 12, or 300 an hour, and 2,400 in an eight-hour shift. 2. Organisation: the work was divided into well over a hundred separate tasks, and only a few workers did the actual killing. 3. Effect: most workers, managers and inspectors never saw a death, and walls and procedures kept it hidden. 4. Argument: Pachirat called this a politics of sight, in which modern societies make large-scale killing tolerable by concealing it. 5. Conclusion: industrial meat depends on distance, both physical and moral.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, assuming zoos began as conservation centres; early zoos displayed empire and status, and some exhibited people. Second, treating every eco-labelled tour as sustainable without checking who benefits and what damage it does. Third, thinking US animal-welfare law covers all laboratory animals; the Animal Welfare Act excludes rats, mice and birds bred for research. Fourth, treating the 3Rs as a ban on animal research rather than a guide to reducing harm. Fifth, ignoring the workers in animal industries, whose labour and conditions are part of the story.

Key takeaways

Industrial societies increasingly treat animals as commodities. Menageries at Hierakonpolis and Moctezuma's Tenochtitlan displayed power; modern zoos from 1793 grew with empire, and human zoos such as the 1906 display of Ota Benga expressed racist hierarchy. After CITES and the Endangered Species Act in 1973, zoos turned to captive breeding, as with the California condor, which grew from about 22 birds in 1982 to 607 by 2025. Ecotourism can fund conservation but risks greenwashing, as the Galápagos shows. About 192 million animals were used in research in 2015, guided by the 3Rs. Pachirat showed that industrial slaughter relies on hiding killing from sight.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Commodity

Something produced or obtained to be bought and sold

Animals as raw material.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

What did the 1906 display of Ota Benga at the Bronx Zoo reveal about early zoos?

Question 2 of 5

The condor population grew from about 22 in 1982 to 607 at the end of 2025. Roughly how many times larger is it?

Question 3 of 5

Which animals does the US Animal Welfare Act exclude when they are bred for research?

Question 4 of 5

What did Timothy Pachirat mean by a politics of sight?

Question 5 of 5

Why do critics sometimes call ecotourism projects greenwashing?

← Previous topicNext topic →