Anthropology › Section R · Humans and animals › Topic R.4
Pet-keeping
A cat on the sofa seems the most natural thing in the world, yet what a pet is, who keeps one and how it is treated differ greatly across cultures and centuries. Pets are living beings, and they are also cultural creations.
What is a pet?
A pet is an animal, domesticated or tamed, that people keep mainly for companionship and with whom they form a lasting social bond. The definition sounds simple, but its edges blur. A sheepdog works and is loved; a pet rabbit in one house is dinner in another; a free-roaming village dog may be fed by many households and owned by none. Anthropologists therefore treat the pet as a cultural artefact: not a fixed biological type but a role that societies create, with expectations about where the animal lives, what it eats, what it may do and what people owe it. That role has a long history and a wide geography.
Dominance and affection
The geographer Yi-Fu Tuan argued in Dominance and Affection (1984) that pet-keeping always mixes love with control. People shape pets' bodies through breeding, decide where they may go and when they eat, and can give them away or have them put down. Tuan compared pets with ornamental gardens and bonsai trees, other living things bent into pleasing forms. Affection softens domination but does not remove it, and the same society that pampers some animals may slaughter others without a second thought. Tuan's point was not that pet owners are cruel, but that care and power are bound together in the relationship.
Ancient companions
Close bonds with animals are very old. At Shillourokambos on Cyprus, archaeologists found a cat buried beside a person about 9,500 years ago; wild cats are not native to the island, so people must have brought them by boat. The Oberkassel puppy, discussed in Humans and animals, shows people caring for a sick dog about 14,000 years ago. In ancient Egypt cats were linked to the goddess Bastet and were mummified in huge numbers, and some households kept dogs, monkeys and birds. In imperial China, small palace dogs such as the Pekingese were prized possessions of the court. In many societies, pet-keeping long marked wealth and status.
The Victorian pet
Pet-keeping in its modern Western form, animals kept chiefly as companions by ordinary families, spread in the 19th century, as the historian Harriet Ritvo has shown for Britain. Urban life separated people from working animals, smaller families had more time, a growing middle class had money to spend, and veterinary care lowered the risk of zoonoses, diseases passed between animals and people. Britain's first dog show was held in Newcastle in 1859, the Kennel Club was founded in 1873 to register pedigrees, and many modern breeds were standardised in this period. Pet foods, vets and animal-welfare societies grew alongside, and the pet industry was born.
Pets in Indigenous societies
Pet-keeping is not a Western invention. The animal-welfare scholar James Serpell (1988) gathered reports of widespread pet-keeping among Indigenous peoples of the Americas. In lowland South America, people often raise the young of animals killed in hunts, such as monkeys, parrots and peccaries, and children help care for them. In many Amazonian societies a tamed animal is treated as a member of the household and is not eaten, even when its species is hunted. Anthropologists such as Carlos Fausto describe this as familiarisation: turning a wild being into kin by feeding and caring for it. Such pets also teach children animal behaviour.
Rez dogs
In a 2020 article, two Lakota writers, Richard Meyers and Ernest Weston Jr., explained the place of rez (reservation) dogs in their communities. Traditionally, they wrote, Lakota people do not own animals as property in the way many Americans own pets. Dogs live outdoors, move freely and may choose to attach themselves to a household or a whole community, offering protection and companionship; people in turn feed and care for them. The relationship rests on reciprocity and respect rather than mastery. Outsiders sometimes see free-roaming dogs as neglected strays, but that judgement assumes one culture's model of what a pet should be.
Worked example: is it a pet?
Apply the definition to four animals. 1. A parrot raised by an Amazonian family from a chick after its parents were hunted, never eaten: a pet, because it is tamed and kept for companionship within the household. 2. A sheepdog on a Welsh farm that works the flock and sleeps in the barn: a working animal, though it may be loved; the role is mixed. 3. A Lakota rez dog fed by several families but owned by none: a companion in a reciprocal relationship, not a pet in the ownership sense. 4. A potbellied pig living in a flat with its owners: a pet, although most pigs are raised for food. 5. Lesson: whether an animal is a pet depends on its role, not its species.
Breeding for cuteness
Domestication and pet breeding often favour neoteny, the keeping of juvenile features into adulthood. Physical neoteny includes large, wide-set eyes, a short muzzle, a rounded skull and small teeth; behavioural neoteny includes playfulness and dependence on people. Some of these traits may follow from selecting for tameness alone. From 1959, the Soviet geneticist Dmitry Belyaev and later Lyudmila Trut bred silver foxes near Novosibirsk, choosing only the tamest in each generation. Over the following decades many of the foxes developed floppy ears, curly tails, patchy coats and shorter snouts, a cluster of changes researchers call the domestication syndrome.
Worked example: the cost of a flat face
Breeding for extreme looks has costs. Breeds with very short, flat faces, called brachycephalic, such as bulldogs and pugs, often struggle to breathe. 1. Data: a 2010 study by Katy Evans and Vicki Adams, using a UK Kennel Club survey, found that 86.1% of bulldog litters were born by caesarean section. 2. Scale: 86.1% is about 6 litters in every 7, because 6 divided by 7 is about 0.857. 3. Cause: the puppies' large heads and their mothers' narrow pelvises make natural birth difficult. 4. Wider pattern: closed pedigree breeding narrows the gene pool, raising the risk of inherited disorders. 5. Conclusion: traits people find appealing can harm the animals, a clear case of Tuan's dominance within affection.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, assuming pets are a modern Western invention: Indigenous peoples and ancient societies kept them too. Second, treating the pet as a biological category; it is a social role, and the same species can be pet, worker or food. Third, judging other peoples' relationships with animals, such as free-roaming rez dogs, by one culture's model of ownership. Fourth, assuming affection excludes control: Tuan showed they go together. Fifth, assuming every juvenile trait was bred for on purpose: Belyaev's foxes suggest some arrive as side effects of selecting for tameness. Sixth, thinking breed standards are harmless, when some produce chronic health problems.
Key takeaways
A pet is a domesticated or tamed animal kept for companionship, and the pet is best seen as a cultural artefact. Tuan showed that pet-keeping mixes affection with dominance. Pets are ancient: a cat was buried with a person on Cyprus about 9,500 years ago. Modern Western pet-keeping spread in the 19th century, with dog shows from 1859 and the Kennel Club from 1873. Many Amazonian peoples familiarise wild young as kin, and Lakota rez dogs live in reciprocal relationships rather than as property. Breeding favours neoteny, and Belyaev's foxes suggest selecting for tameness brings such traits, but extreme breeding, as in flat-faced dogs, can harm animals.
Flashcards
Flashcard
A domesticated or tamed animal kept mainly for companionship, with a lasting bond
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
What did Yi-Fu Tuan mean by dominance and affection?
Question 2 of 5
What does the cat burial at Shillourokambos on Cyprus show?
Question 3 of 5
In many Amazonian societies, what happens to a young animal raised after its mother was killed in a hunt?
Question 4 of 5
Why did many of Belyaev's foxes develop floppy ears and curly tails?
Question 5 of 5
A UK survey found 86.1% of bulldog litters were born by caesarean section. Roughly how many litters in every 7 is that?
