Anthropology › Section P · Art, music, and sport › Topic P.1

Anthropology of the arts

Every known society decorates bodies, shapes objects with care and makes images, yet many languages have no single word for art. Anthropologists study art in its social world: who makes it, for whom, with what meanings, and how objects move between homes, markets and museums.

What counts as art?

The idea of fine art as a separate category, made to be contemplated for beauty alone, took shape in eighteenth-century Europe, as the historian Paul Oskar Kristeller showed. Before that, art meant any skill, as in the art of cooking. Many societies make no sharp line between a beautiful object and a useful or sacred one: a carved paddle, a woven basket or a painted shield can be all three. Anthropologists therefore use a broad working definition, skilled making intended to engage the senses or carry meaning, and then ask how each society itself sorts and values such work.

From primitive art to art worlds

Early museums often filed objects from colonised peoples as primitive art or ethnographic specimens, a label now used only when analysing that history. Franz Boas, in Primitive Art (1927), used the term of his day but argued against its implications: he showed that formal skill and design rules exist in every society, from Northwest Coast carving to Plains beadwork. Later, Sally Price's Primitive Art in Civilized Places (1989) criticised how Western collectors and curators presented such works as anonymous and timeless, erasing named makers and their histories. Today anthropologists study whole art worlds: makers, patrons, dealers, critics and audiences.

Art as agency

The British anthropologist Alfred Gell, in Art and Agency (1998), proposed treating artworks as objects that act on people within social relationships. His best-known example is the carved and painted canoe prow board of the Trobriand Islands, used in the kula exchange of shell valuables. Gell argued that its dazzling design was meant to awe and disarm exchange partners, so that they would give more generously, a technology of enchantment. The question shifts from what an object means to what it does, and for whom.

Beauty in local terms

Aesthetic standards differ, and anthropologists try to learn them from the inside. Howard Morphy, working with Yolngu artists of Arnhem Land in northern Australia from the 1970s, described how painters fill bark paintings with fine crosshatching that produces a shimmering effect, which Yolngu call bir'yun. For Yolngu viewers that brilliance is not mere decoration: it is a sign of ancestral power shining through the painting. Designs also belong to particular clans, so the right to paint them is governed by kinship and ceremony, not by individual artistic choice alone.

The deep history of images

Image-making is very old. At Blombos Cave in South Africa, pieces of ochre were engraved with crosshatched lines, and in 2018 researchers reported a crosshatched drawing in ochre about 73,000 years old. In January 2026, Adhi Agus Oktaviana and colleagues reported in Nature that a hand stencil in Liang Metanduno cave on Muna Island, Indonesia, is at least 67,800 years old, the oldest dated rock art yet known. Hand stencils in Spanish caves dated to about 65,000 years have been attributed to Neanderthals, though that interpretation is debated. Famous European paintings, such as those at Chauvet in France, are about 36,000 years old.

Worked example: what a minimum date means

A thin crust of calcite has formed over a painted hand stencil. Uranium-series dating of the crust gives about 70,000 years. Interpret the result. 1. Order of events: the paint must be older than any crust that formed on top of it. 2. So the date is a minimum: the stencil is at least about 70,000 years old, and could be older. 3. Weakness: if a crust sample is contaminated or the calcite chemistry is disturbed, dates can be wrong, so researchers date several samples. 4. Cross-check: a crust beneath the paint, if present, would give a maximum age. 5. Conclusion: headlines saying a painting is exactly a certain age overstate what the method shows.

Useful and beautiful

Pottery shows how function and beauty combine. Fragments from Xianrendong Cave in China, about 20,000 years old, are among the oldest known pots, made by foragers rather than farmers. Over millennia potters everywhere added shapes, slips, paint and texture far beyond what cooking or storage required. Pueblo potters of the American Southwest, such as those of Acoma and San Ildefonso, have long made vessels with designs tied to family, place and meaning. Archaeologists use pottery styles to trace contacts and changes between communities, because style is a learned, shared choice.

Worked example: from household pot to signed artwork

Trace how Maria Martinez of San Ildefonso Pueblo became a celebrated artist. 1. Starting point: Pueblo women made pottery for household and ceremonial use. 2. Innovation: around 1919, Maria and her husband Julian developed a polished black-on-black ware fired in a smothered flame. 3. Market: tourists, collectors and museums wanted the pots, and Maria began signing them in the 1920s, a practice buyers valued. 4. Effect: income supported Pueblo families, and other potters adopted the style. 5. Lesson: the category of artwork was produced through markets and relationships between a Pueblo community and outsiders, a process Nelson Graburn analysed in Ethnic and Tourist Arts (1976).

The body as canvas

All societies decorate or modify the body in some way. Ötzi, a man who died in the Alps about 5,300 years ago, has 61 tattoos made by rubbing charcoal into small cuts, many over joints, which some researchers interpret as treatment for pain. The English word tattoo comes from the Polynesian tatau, recorded on James Cook's voyages in the 1760s and 1770s. Among Māori, tā moko marks genealogy and status; suppressed under colonial rule, it has revived strongly since the late twentieth century. Henna designs mark weddings and festivals across South Asia, the Middle East and North Africa.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, assuming every society has a separate category of fine art like eighteenth-century Europe's. Second, using primitive art as a description rather than as a historical label to analyse. Third, judging other traditions only by Western ideas of beauty, rather than learning local standards such as Yolngu bir'yun. Fourth, reading a rock-art minimum date as an exact age. Fifth, assuming useful objects such as pots or baskets cannot be art. Sixth, treating body art elsewhere as exotic while ignoring tattoos and cosmetics at home.

Key takeaways

Art as a separate category is a recent European idea, so anthropologists define it broadly and study whole art worlds. Boas showed formal skill exists everywhere, and Price criticised the erasure of named makers. Gell saw art as agency, as in Trobriand prow boards; Morphy described Yolngu bir'yun as ancestral power. Images go back at least 67,800 years on Muna Island, and dates from crusts are minimums. Pots from Xianrendong are about 20,000 years old, and Maria Martinez shows markets shaping art. Body art, from Ötzi's tattoos to tā moko and henna, marks identity everywhere.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Fine art

Art valued for contemplation alone, a category formed in eighteenth-century Europe

Kristeller traced its history.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Why do anthropologists use a broad working definition of art?

Question 2 of 5

What did Alfred Gell argue about the Trobriand canoe prow board?

Question 3 of 5

A calcite crust over a painted stencil is dated to 50,000 years. What can be concluded?

Question 4 of 5

What does the Yolngu concept of bir'yun show?

Question 5 of 5

What does the career of Maria Martinez illustrate?

← Previous topicNext topic →