Anthropology › Section P · Art, music, and sport › Topic P.2
Anthropology of music
Every society anthropologists have studied makes music, yet what counts as music, who may perform it and what it is for differ enormously. Ethnomusicology studies music as something people do together: a source of feeling, memory, identity, resistance and argument over who owns a sound.
A human universal with many forms
In 2019 the psychologist Samuel Mehr and colleagues, writing in Science, examined ethnographic records from 315 societies and found music in every one of them. Some song types recurred widely: lullabies, dance songs, healing songs and love songs, which listeners from other cultures could often identify by sound alone. Yet the details varied without limit: scales, rhythms, instruments, who sings, and whether music is a solo performance or a shared activity. Music is therefore both a universal human capacity and a deeply cultural practice, which is exactly the combination anthropology is equipped to study.
Ethnomusicology
Ethnomusicology studies music as part of social and cultural life, usually through fieldwork. The Dutch scholar Jaap Kunst popularised the name around 1950, and the Society for Ethnomusicology was founded in 1955. Alan Merriam's The Anthropology of Music (1964) proposed studying three linked levels: people's concepts about music, the behaviour that produces and surrounds it, and the sound itself. John Blacking, who worked among the Venda of South Africa in the 1950s, defined music as humanly organised sound in How Musical Is Man? (1973), stressing that musicality belongs to everyone, not only to trained specialists.
The oldest instruments
Instruments survive only when made of durable materials, so the record of music is thin. The oldest generally accepted instruments are flutes from caves in south-western Germany, including Hohle Fels and Geissenklösterle, carved from bird bone and mammoth ivory about 40,000 years ago. A pierced cave-bear bone from Divje Babe in Slovenia, about 50,000 years old, has been claimed as a Neanderthal flute, but many researchers think carnivore teeth made the holes. Voices, drums of wood and skin, and clapping leave no trace, so music is almost certainly older than any surviving instrument.
Sound and Sentiment
Steven Feld's Sound and Sentiment (1982) studied the Kaluli people of the Bosavi rainforest in Papua New Guinea in the 1970s. Feld found that Kaluli linked song, weeping and birdsong. A story told of a boy who became a muni bird after being denied food by his older sister, and its falling call was heard as a sad, abandoned voice. At ceremonies, performers sang of places in the forest so movingly that listeners wept, and in grief they sometimes burned the dancers. Feld showed that to understand the sound, one had to understand Kaluli ideas of loss, reciprocity and the forest.
Worked example: Merriam's three levels
Apply Merriam's model to a New Orleans jazz funeral. 1. Concept: many participants understand the procession as honouring the dead and then celebrating a life and its release from hardship. 2. Behaviour: a brass band leads mourners to the burial; on the way back, a crowd of followers, the second line, joins in dancing and waving handkerchiefs and umbrellas. 3. Sound: slow hymns and dirges on the way out, then up-tempo tunes on the return. 4. Links: the shift in sound marks the shift in meaning, and the shared dancing shows a community claiming public streets. 5. Lesson: describing only the notes would miss most of what the music does.
Recording and its responsibilities
Recording made new research possible and raised new questions. Frances Densmore (1867-1957) recorded thousands of songs from Native American nations on wax cylinders, many for the Smithsonian's Bureau of American Ethnology from 1907. Zora Neale Hurston (1891-1960), who trained under Franz Boas, collected Black folk songs and stories in Florida and the Caribbean in the 1930s. Today such archives are being reconnected with the communities whose ancestors sang, who may restrict sacred songs or reclaim songs lost from daily use. Ethnomusicologists increasingly ask who controls recordings, not only how to make them.
Music, identity and resistance
Music often gives voice to people denied other forms of power. Enslaved African Americans created spirituals that drew on biblical stories of exodus; Sarah Bradford's 1886 biography reported that Harriet Tubman used songs to signal to people preparing to escape. Freedom songs such as We Shall Overcome carried the civil rights movement of the 1950s and 1960s. In Chile, the nueva canción movement linked folk music to social change, and the singer Víctor Jara was killed in 1973 after the military coup. In Subculture: The Meaning of Style (1979), Dick Hebdige read British punk's sound and dress as a symbolic refusal of mainstream values.
Appropriation and power
The philosopher James Young (2008) analysed cultural appropriation: people outside a culture taking its music, styles or stories. Anthropologists stress power. When musicians from a dominant group profit from the music of a marginalised group, the original makers may receive little credit or income, as many Black American musicians did in the twentieth-century recording industry. Debates also arise over collaboration: Paul Simon's album Graceland (1986), recorded partly in South Africa with South African musicians, was praised for spreading their music and criticised for breaking the cultural boycott against apartheid.
Worked example: Old Town Road
Analyse the 2019 controversy over Lil Nas X's song Old Town Road. 1. Event: in March 2019 Billboard removed the song, by a young Black artist, from its Hot Country Songs chart, saying it did not contain enough elements of country music. 2. Response: Lil Nas X released a remix with the white country singer Billy Ray Cyrus, and the song held No. 1 on the Billboard Hot 100 for a record-setting 19 weeks. 3. Question: who decides what counts as country, a genre whose roots include Black musicians and the banjo, an instrument of African origin? 4. Lesson: genre labels are cultural categories that can track race and industry power, not only sound.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, assuming music means the same thing everywhere because it is universal; universal capacity is compatible with great diversity. Second, studying only the sound and ignoring concepts and behaviour, the two other levels in Merriam's model. Third, treating the oldest surviving flutes as the start of music, when voices and perishable instruments leave no trace. Fourth, reading the Divje Babe bone as a settled Neanderthal flute. Fifth, treating archive recordings as free for anyone to use, ignoring community rights. Sixth, treating genre boundaries as purely musical rather than shaped by race and markets.
Key takeaways
Music occurs in every society studied, as Mehr's 2019 survey of 315 societies found, but its forms and purposes vary. Ethnomusicology studies music in context; Merriam's model links concept, behaviour and sound, and Blacking called music humanly organised sound. The oldest accepted instruments are German flutes about 40,000 years old. Feld's Kaluli work tied song to weeping and loss. Densmore's and Hurston's recordings raise questions of community control. Music carries resistance, from spirituals to nueva canción and punk, and debates over appropriation and genre, such as Old Town Road, reveal power.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Found music in all 315 societies in their ethnographic sample
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
What did Mehr and colleagues' 2019 study find?
Question 2 of 5
In Merriam's model, the second-line dancing at a New Orleans jazz funeral belongs to which level?
Question 3 of 5
Why do many researchers doubt that the Divje Babe bone is a Neanderthal flute?
Question 4 of 5
What did Steven Feld show in Sound and Sentiment?
Question 5 of 5
What does the Old Town Road controversy best illustrate?
