Anthropology › Section Q · Medical anthropology › Topic Q.4

Applied medical anthropology

Health programmes succeed or fail in the details of daily life: who fetches the water, how the dead are mourned, whom patients trust. Applied medical anthropologists bring that knowledge to clinics, epidemics and health policy, working alongside communities rather than prescribing to them.

Putting research to work

Applied medical anthropology uses anthropological methods and theory to improve health and health care. Practitioners work for hospitals, ministries of health, the WHO, charities and community organisations, and many combine university research with practical projects. Their typical contribution is to explain how a health problem looks from the inside: how people understand it, what their choices cost them and what social conditions shape their risk. They then help design programmes that fit those realities. Their role is to inform and collaborate, not to replace clinical judgement or the decisions of the communities they work with.

Worked example: boiling water in Los Molinos

In the early 1950s, a health worker spent two years encouraging the 200 families of Los Molinos, a town in coastal Peru, to boil their drinking water. Edward Wellin analysed the results in Benjamin Paul's Health, Culture and Community (1955). 1. Outcome: only 11 of 200 families adopted the practice, 11 ÷ 200 = 5.5%. 2. Belief: in local hot-cold ideas, boiled water was associated with illness, so healthy people avoided it. 3. Cost: boiling took scarce fuel and time. 4. Social position: the health worker's visits carried less weight with some families than local opinion. 5. Lesson: the campaign failed because it treated germs as the only relevant fact, ignoring meaning, cost and trust.

Ebola and the care of the dead

The Ebola epidemic of 2014-2016 in Guinea, Liberia and Sierra Leone caused about 28,600 cases and about 11,300 deaths, according to WHO and CDC figures. The bodies of people who die of Ebola are highly infectious, and in many affected communities, families wash, touch and prepare the dead as a sacred duty. Early burial teams often removed bodies abruptly, in body bags, without rites, and some families hid the sick or the dead. Anthropologists, including those of the Ebola Response Anthropology Platform, helped responders understand why. Paul Richards, in Ebola: How a People's Science Helped End an Epidemic (2016), stressed how communities themselves adapted.

Worked example: designing a dignified burial

Plan a burial response with community input. 1. Problem: unsafe contact with bodies spreads infection, yet forced burials without rites drove people to hide cases. 2. Listening: interviews with religious leaders and families identify which parts of the rites matter most, such as prayers and the presence of relatives. 3. Design: trained teams wear protective equipment, but relatives may watch, prayers are said, and religious requirements are met as far as safety allows; the WHO issued a safe and dignified burial protocol along these lines in late 2014. 4. Effect: trust rises, so families report deaths sooner. 5. Lesson: respecting meaning can be a public health measure, not an obstacle to one.

Partners In Health

Paul Farmer (1959-2022) and Jim Yong Kim, both physicians with doctorates in anthropology, helped found Partners In Health in 1987 to bring care to rural Haiti. They trained community health workers, called accompagnateurs, to visit patients daily, bring medicines and food, and offer support, and they showed that poor patients could complete demanding treatment for HIV and drug-resistant tuberculosis when barriers were removed. Farmer used the idea of structural violence to argue that poverty, not patients' culture, explained poor outcomes. Kim later directed the WHO's HIV/AIDS department and was president of the World Bank from 2012 to 2019.

Birth and authoritative knowledge

Reproduction is a major applied field. Brigitte Jordan's Birth in Four Cultures (1978) compared childbirth among Maya women of Yucatán, Mexico, and in the Netherlands, Sweden and the United States. She later developed the concept of authoritative knowledge: the knowledge that counts in a setting, often held by those with institutional power, such as doctors with machines, rather than by the birthing woman. Robbie Davis-Floyd's Birth as an American Rite of Passage (1992) analysed hospital birth procedures as rituals that teach cultural values. Such work has informed debates over midwifery and patient choice.

Racism and maternal health

Applied work also documents inequality. In Reproductive Injustice: Racism, Pregnancy, and Premature Birth (2019), Dána-Ain Davis showed how Black women in the United States, including well-off women, described being disbelieved and dismissed in pregnancy care. National data show the scale. The National Center for Health Statistics reported that in 2023 the US maternal mortality rate was 18.6 deaths per 100,000 live births overall, but 50.3 for Black women and 14.5 for white women: 50.3 ÷ 14.5 is about 3.5 times as high. Anthropologists link such gaps to structural racism rather than to biology.

Cultural concepts of distress

The American Psychiatric Association's DSM-IV (1994) listed culture-bound syndromes, conditions thought specific to particular cultures. Its successor, DSM-5 (2013), replaced the term with cultural concepts of distress, ways groups experience and express suffering, and added a Cultural Formulation Interview for clinicians. Examples include ataque de nervios, an attack of nerves described in many Caribbean Latino communities, and susto, fright believed to cause soul loss, studied in Mexico by Arthur Rubel and colleagues. Mark Nichter (1981) called such expressions idioms of distress. Anthropologists stress that Western conditions, too, are shaped by culture.

From competence to humility

Many training programmes teach cultural competence, knowledge about the beliefs of patients' groups. Critics warn that it can become a checklist of stereotypes. In 1998 Melanie Tervalon and Jann Murray-García proposed cultural humility instead: lifelong self-reflection, recognising power imbalances between clinician and patient, and learning from each patient. In 2014 Jonathan Metzl and Helena Hansen proposed structural competency, training clinicians to recognise how housing, income, policing and policy shape patients' health. Each approach reflects anthropological findings that culture is varied and that social structures matter as much as beliefs.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, assuming people reject health advice from ignorance, when, as in Los Molinos, meaning, cost and trust explain choices. Second, treating funeral rites during epidemics as obstacles to remove rather than practices to adapt with communities. Third, blaming poor outcomes on patients' culture, when poverty and racism often explain them. Fourth, calling every unfamiliar condition culture-bound while treating Western conditions as culture-free. Fifth, reducing culture to a stereotype checklist. Sixth, assuming applied anthropologists make clinical decisions; they inform and collaborate.

Key takeaways

Applied medical anthropology uses research to improve health in partnership with communities. In Los Molinos only 11 of 200 families, 5.5%, boiled water, because meaning, cost and trust were ignored. In the 2014-2016 Ebola epidemic, about 28,600 cases and 11,300 deaths, safe and dignified burials showed respect aiding public health. Partners In Health's accompagnateurs showed poor patients could complete treatment. Jordan's authoritative knowledge and Davis-Floyd's rituals reshaped birth debates, and US maternal mortality in 2023 was about 3.5 times higher for Black women than for white women. DSM-5's cultural concepts of distress, cultural humility and structural competency carry anthropology into clinics.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Applied medical anthropology

Using anthropological research to improve health and health care

Informs and collaborates.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Why did the water-boiling campaign in Los Molinos largely fail?

Question 2 of 5

During the 2014-2016 Ebola epidemic, why did abrupt burials without rites backfire?

Question 3 of 5

A town's 400 families are encouraged to adopt a new practice, and 22 do so. What percentage adopted it?

Question 4 of 5

What does Brigitte Jordan's concept of authoritative knowledge describe?

Question 5 of 5

How does cultural humility differ from cultural competence as critics describe it?

← Previous topicNext topic →