Anthropology › Section R · Humans and animals › Topic R.1
Humans and animals
Animals feed us, work for us, live in our homes and fill our stories, yet every culture draws its own line between people and other creatures. Anthropologists study where that line falls, why it moves, and what animals themselves bring to the relationship.
Animals all around us
Count the animals in an ordinary day: eggs at breakfast, a leather belt, a neighbour's dog, a team mascot, a cartoon, perhaps a vaccine developed with laboratory mice. Animals enter human life as food, labour, companions, symbols, spirits and research subjects. Human-animal studies is the interdisciplinary field that examines these ties, and anthropology brings fieldwork, cross-cultural comparison and holism to it. What counts as an animal? Which animals are eaten, loved or feared, and why? And how do animals shape the people who live alongside them?
What is an animal?
In biology, animals are multicellular organisms that eat other living things for energy, and most of them move and reproduce sexually. By that definition humans are animals, a point Western science made long before Darwin. Aristotle, in the 4th century BCE, sorted animals into blooded and bloodless kinds and set humans among them as the animal with reason. Carl Linnaeus placed humans in his classification of the animal kingdom in 1735 and gave us the name Homo sapiens in 1758. Biology now sees a continuum of differences in degree between species, not a single gulf. Yet almost every society still talks as if people stood apart from animals.
Good to think with
Claude Lévi-Strauss held that every society defines culture against something it calls nature. In Totemism (1962) he wrote that animals are chosen as symbols not because they are good to eat but because they are good to think: the differences between species give people a ready-made way to talk about differences between themselves. Cultures sort the same creature very differently. Many Americans treat dogs as family members and pigs as food, yet potbellied pigs are kept as pets, and dogs have been eaten in parts of East and Southeast Asia. In January 2024 South Korea passed a law banning the dog-meat trade from 2027, a sign that such categories change.
Us, them and the animal
Groups often mark their boundaries with animal imagery. Many peoples' own names simply mean people or human beings: Inuit and Diné both mean roughly the people, and the Quechua word runa means person. Outsiders are sometimes given animal nicknames, as when the English called the French frogs. The same habit has a dark side. Denying a group full humanity by comparing it to vermin has repeatedly prepared the way for persecution. Nazi propaganda described Jews as rats, and a 1942 Nazi decree banned Jewish households from keeping pets. Before and during the 1994 genocide in Rwanda, extremist radio called Tutsi inyenzi, cockroaches. How a society talks about animals can reveal how it ranks people.
Beyond anthropocentrism
Classic ethnography treated animals as background: resources, property or symbols in human schemes. Recent work questions this anthropocentrism, the habit of treating humans as the only beings whose point of view matters. Multispecies ethnography, set out in a 2010 article by Eben Kirksey and Stefan Helmreich, studies how humans and other organisms, from dogs to fungi and microbes, shape one another's lives in shared environments. The approach has older roots. Lewis Henry Morgan published a detailed study of the American beaver in 1868, and E. E. Evans-Pritchard's The Nuer (1940) showed how the social life of the Nuer, in what is now South Sudan, was organised around cattle.
Worked example: two ways of herding reindeer
Kirill Istomin and Mark Dwyer (2010) compared two reindeer-herding peoples in northern Russia, the Izhma Komi and the Nenets, who live in similar climates with the same kind of reindeer. 1. Observation: Izhma Komi herders keep their animals in two large groups that are guided to separate pastures by day, while Nenets reindeer scatter in small groups and return to camp on their own at night. 2. Puzzle: the animals are the same, so why do they behave so differently? 3. Evidence: herders said that reindeer bought from another herd were hard to manage and often wandered off, because they did not know the new routine. 4. Interpretation: calves learn the herd's habits from their mothers and other adults. 5. Conclusion: reindeer behaviour is partly learned, so herds have something like their own traditions.
Domestication
Domestication is a long process in which humans come to control the breeding, feeding and movement of another species, so that over generations the animals change in body and behaviour. Farmers and herders tended to favour calm temperament, tolerance of people and of crowding, and, in herd animals, often smaller size. The archaeologist Melinda Zeder (2012) described three pathways. In the commensal pathway, animals such as wolves were drawn to human camps and gradually became dependent on people. In the prey pathway, hunters began managing the animals they hunted, as with sheep and goats. In the directed pathway, people deliberately captured and bred animals, as with horses.
The first domestic animal
The dog was almost certainly the first domesticated animal. Geneticists now think dogs descend from a population of grey wolves that has since died out; when and where it happened is still debated, but dogs were clearly present by about 15,000 years ago. Dogs have served people in many roles. They guard homes and herds, help hunters track and retrieve game, and herd sheep and cattle. They have hauled loads: Plains peoples such as the Blackfoot used a dog-drawn frame called a travois, and Inuit used dog sleds. In some places dogs were also food. A fragment of dog bone found in a human coprolite, preserved faeces, at Hinds Cave, Texas, is about 9,000 years old, and peoples of ancient Mexico raised dogs for meat.
Worked example: a puppy at Oberkassel
In 1914 quarry workers at Oberkassel, near Bonn in Germany, found a grave about 14,000 years old holding a man, a woman and the bones of a dog. A 2018 study by Luc Janssens and colleagues re-examined the dog. 1. Evidence: it was a young puppy, about 28 weeks old, whose teeth showed it had survived a severe bout of canine distemper. 2. Inference: a puppy that ill could not have survived without weeks of warmth, water and food from people. 3. Use: so young and sick an animal could hardly have worked as a hunter or guard. 4. Interpretation: the people probably cared for it out of attachment, and they buried it with humans. 5. Conclusion: emotional bonds between people and dogs are at least 14,000 years old.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, saying humans are not animals: biologically we are, and the human-animal boundary is drawn by culture. Second, assuming every society sorts animals the same way: the line between pet and food varies and changes over time. Third, treating animal imagery as harmless in every case: comparing people to vermin has been used to justify persecution. Fourth, thinking domestication was a single event or a deliberate plan; it took many generations and followed different pathways. Fifth, treating animal behaviour as purely instinctive, when herds and other groups can pass on learned habits.
Key takeaways
Biologically humans are animals, but cultures draw their own boundaries between people and other creatures, and Lévi-Strauss argued that animals are good to think with. Animal imagery marks group identity and can also dehumanise. Multispecies ethnography, set out in 2010, studies how humans and other species shape each other, building on older work such as Morgan's beavers and Evans-Pritchard's Nuer cattle. Domestication followed commensal, prey and directed pathways. Dogs, descended from an extinct wolf population and present by about 15,000 years ago, have guarded, hunted, herded, hauled and been eaten, and the Oberkassel puppy shows care for dogs at least 14,000 years ago.
Flashcards
Flashcard
The interdisciplinary study of relationships between people and other animals
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
What did Lévi-Strauss mean by saying animals are good to think?
Question 2 of 5
In Istomin and Dwyer's study, why were reindeer bought from another herd hard to manage?
Question 3 of 5
Wolves drawn to human camps that gradually became dependent on people illustrate which domestication pathway?
Question 4 of 5
What does the Oberkassel puppy suggest about early relationships between people and dogs?
Question 5 of 5
Which statement about the human-animal boundary is accurate?
