Anthropology › Section S · Indigenous anthropology › Topic S.4
Applied and public anthropology with Indigenous peoples
The strongest answer to the critique of anthropology has come from research that Indigenous nations direct for their own purposes. Tribes now hire anthropologists, set research rules, map their own heritage and publish their own histories.
From subjects to directors
Applied anthropology uses anthropological methods to address practical problems, from health and housing to land and heritage. Public anthropology shares research beyond the academy, in plain language and accessible places. Both respond to the critique set out in Colonization and anthropology: Vine Deloria Jr. complained that researchers took from Native communities and gave little back. The change since then has been one of control. Many Indigenous nations now define the questions, fund the work, employ their own scholars and decide what is published. Anthropologists increasingly work for, or alongside, tribal governments rather than simply studying them.
Tribes set the rules
Because research has caused real harm, as the Havasupai case showed, many nations now review studies on their lands. The Navajo Nation set up its own Human Research Review Board in 1996, and in 2002 the Navajo Nation Council placed a moratorium on genetic research involving its citizens. Tribal review can require researchers to share results with the community, protect sacred knowledge, return or destroy samples, and seek approval before publication. Some universities now sign formal research agreements with tribes. Researchers sometimes find these rules slow, but they put into practice the principle that a people should control research about itself.
Data sovereignty
Indigenous data sovereignty is the right of a people to govern data collected about it, its members, lands and resources. In Canada, the First Nations Information Governance Centre promotes the OCAP principles, developed from 1998: First Nations' ownership, control, access and possession of their data. Internationally, the CARE principles of 2019, mentioned in Collections, museums, and repatriation, add collective benefit, authority to control, responsibility and ethics. These ideas matter as health records, genetic data and environmental information move into large databases, where communities can lose sight of how information about them is used.
Protecting heritage on the land
Amendments to the National Historic Preservation Act in 1992 allowed tribes to appoint Tribal Historic Preservation Officers, who take over a state preservation office's role on tribal lands and are consulted about projects that may affect sacred or historic places. Many tribes now run their own archaeology and cultural resources departments. They use geographic information systems (GIS), layered digital maps that combine archaeological sites, plant-gathering areas, place names and environmental change. Tribes can show outsiders some layers while keeping others, such as the locations of burials or ceremonial sites, confidential to protect them from looting.
Community-based research
In community-based participatory research, the community is a partner at every stage: choosing the question, designing the methods, collecting and interpreting data, and deciding how results are shared. The archaeologist Sonya Atalay, who is Anishinaabe-Ojibwe, set out this approach for her field in Community-Based Archaeology (2012). She argued for braiding Indigenous and scientific knowledge rather than ranking one above the other, and for research that answers questions communities themselves care about, such as how to protect a site, revive a practice or support a land claim. The approach takes longer, but it produces work people trust and use.
Worked example: planning a partnership
A tribe asks an anthropologist to help document traditional plant-gathering places threatened by a new road. Plan the project. 1. Agreement: sign a research agreement with the tribal government covering ownership of data, review of publications and payment. 2. Question: let the tribe's cultural committee define what must be documented and why. 3. Methods: record elders' knowledge with consent, visit sites with community members, and map locations in the tribe's own GIS. 4. Protection: keep sensitive locations in confidential layers and share only what the tribe approves for the road consultation. 5. Return: give the tribe all recordings and maps, and co-author any publication. 6. Check: at each step, decisions rest with the community.
Anthropology as evidence
Anthropological and historical research often supports Indigenous legal claims. A group seeking federal recognition in the United States must document, among other criteria, that it has existed as a distinct community with continuous political authority, which requires detailed ethnohistory, the study of a people's past from documents and oral sources. Anthropologists also prepare evidence for land claims, water rights and treaty cases, as Barbara Lane did in the Boldt fishing case discussed in Indigenous agency and rights. Such work carries responsibility, because published findings about a people's ancestry or continuity can strengthen or weaken its legal standing for decades.
Sharing management
Some protected areas are now governed jointly. Under the Gwaii Haanas Agreement of 1993, the Haida Nation and the Government of Canada manage the southern part of Haida Gwaii, off the coast of British Columbia, through a board with equal representation, even though they still disagree about who owns the land. Decisions draw on Haida knowledge of forests, fisheries and sites alongside scientific monitoring, and Haida Watchmen live at village sites to protect them and greet visitors. Co-management does not settle questions of sovereignty, but it shows how Indigenous authority and state agencies can share responsibility for land.
Worked example: a protected archive
Many communities want digital access to old photographs and recordings, but some material is sacred or restricted. Consider Mukurtu, a platform first developed with the Warumungu community of Tennant Creek, in Australia's Northern Territory, and launched in 2007 with the anthropologist Kimberly Christen. 1. Problem: open online archives treat all material as public, which ignores Warumungu rules about who may see what. 2. Design: the community assigns protocols, so access depends on kinship, gender or ceremonial status. 3. Sensitivity: images of people who have died can be restricted, in line with local mourning practices. 4. Result: the community controls its own heritage. 5. Lesson: access and protection can coexist when communities set the terms.
Public scholarship and networks
Indigenous scholars increasingly publish for the public. The historian David Lewis, a member of the Confederated Tribes of Grand Ronde, writes the Quartux Journal, a public blog of essays on western Oregon tribal history. Oregon's Senate Bill 13 (2017) required a curriculum on Native American history developed with the state's nine federally recognised tribes. Indigenous peoples also build networks across borders: the Inuit Circumpolar Council, founded in 1977, represents Inuit in Alaska, Canada, Greenland and Chukotka in Russia, and the annual Tribal Canoe Journeys, revived with the Paddle to Seattle in 1989, gather Pacific Northwest nations each summer.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, assuming tribal research review is obstruction; it protects communities from harms such as those in the Havasupai case. Second, treating community-based research as interviews with a few residents; it makes the community a partner at every stage. Third, thinking open access is always ethical; some knowledge is restricted by the community's own rules. Fourth, assuming co-management settles sovereignty: Gwaii Haanas is jointly managed while ownership is still disputed. Fifth, assuming applied work is less scholarly than academic research; legal and heritage cases demand rigorous evidence.
Key takeaways
Applied and public anthropology answer Deloria's critique by putting Indigenous nations in charge. Tribes review research, as the Navajo Nation has done since 1996, including a 2002 genetic research moratorium. Data sovereignty principles such as OCAP and CARE govern information about communities. Tribal Historic Preservation Officers, allowed from 1992, and tribal GIS protect heritage while keeping sensitive sites confidential. Atalay's community-based archaeology braids knowledge systems. Anthropology supplies evidence for recognition and treaty cases. Gwaii Haanas (1993) shows co-management, Mukurtu (2007) shows protocol-based archives, and public scholarship and networks such as the Inuit Circumpolar Council connect peoples.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Using anthropological methods to address practical problems
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
What is the main difference between community-based participatory research and traditional fieldwork?
Question 2 of 5
Why do tribes often keep some GIS map layers confidential?
Question 3 of 5
What do the OCAP principles stand for?
Question 4 of 5
What does the Gwaii Haanas Agreement of 1993 show about co-management?
Question 5 of 5
In the Mukurtu platform, how is access to a photograph decided?
