Anthropology › Section S · Indigenous anthropology › Topic S.3

Indigenous agency and rights

Indigenous peoples have never been passive victims of colonisation. Through treaties, courts, protest, language schools and international diplomacy, they have defended their lands and rebuilt their nations, and in 2007 the United Nations adopted a declaration of their rights.

Agency under pressure

Agency means the capacity of people to act on their own goals, even within powerful constraints. For Indigenous peoples, those constraints have included conquest, removal, disease and laws written by others. Yet the record is full of action: nations negotiated treaties, sued governments, occupied land, kept ceremonies alive in secret, built schools for their languages and lobbied at the United Nations. This topic follows that story mainly in the United States and in international law, building on Indigenous peoples and on Resistance, revolution, and social movements.

Removal and treaties

The Indian Removal Act of 1830 let President Andrew Jackson negotiate, and in practice force, the exchange of Native lands east of the Mississippi for land in what became Oklahoma. Choctaw, Muscogee (Creek), Chickasaw, Cherokee and Seminole people were driven west during the 1830s and 1840s. In 1838 and 1839 about 16,000 Cherokee were marched to Indian Territory, and an estimated 4,000 or more died, the journey Cherokee people remember as the Trail of Tears. Across the West, treaties ceded vast lands in return for reserved territory, payments and promised services, often delivered late, partly or not at all. Those treaties remain law, and nations still use them to defend their rights.

Domestic dependent nations

Three Supreme Court decisions under Chief Justice John Marshall, the Marshall trilogy, still shape tribal status. Johnson v. M'Intosh (1823) held that, under the doctrine of discovery, European claims gave the United States ultimate title to Native land, so tribes could sell it only to the federal government. Cherokee Nation v. Georgia (1831) called tribes domestic dependent nations. Worcester v. Georgia (1832) held that state laws had no force within Cherokee territory. Together they made tribes sovereign but under federal authority, with the federal government holding a trust responsibility, a duty that it often failed to honour.

Fish, water and rivers

Many treaties in the Pacific Northwest reserved the right to fish at usual and accustomed places. When states arrested Native fishers in the 1960s, tribes staged fish-ins. In United States v. Washington (1974), Judge George Boldt ruled that treaty tribes were entitled to up to half of the harvestable fish, and the anthropologist Barbara Lane's evidence about treaty-era fishing helped the court. On the Klamath River, the Klamath, Karuk, Yurok and other tribes campaigned for decades against dams that blocked salmon runs. Between 2023 and 2024 four hydroelectric dams were removed, the largest dam removal in US history, and salmon began returning upstream within months.

Protest and self-determination

From 1969 to 1971, Native activists calling themselves Indians of All Tribes occupied Alcatraz Island in San Francisco Bay. The American Indian Movement (AIM), founded in Minneapolis in 1968, organised the Trail of Broken Treaties march to Washington in 1972 and, in 1973, a 71-day occupation at Wounded Knee on the Pine Ridge Reservation. Pressure from such protests and from tribal governments helped end termination. Congress passed the Indian Self-Determination and Education Assistance Act (1975), letting tribes run federal programmes themselves, the Indian Child Welfare Act (1978), which the Supreme Court upheld in 2023, and the American Indian Religious Freedom Act (1978).

Rights in international law

Indigenous delegates also took their case to the world. The International Labour Organization's Convention 107 (1957) aimed at integration, but its Convention 169 (1989) recognised Indigenous peoples' rights to their lands, institutions and consultation, binding only the states that ratify it, mostly in Latin America. On 13 September 2007 the UN General Assembly adopted the Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (UNDRIP) by 144 votes to 4, with 11 abstentions. It affirms the right to self-determination, to lands and resources, to culture and language, and to free, prior and informed consent to measures affecting them. As a declaration, it is not a binding treaty.

Worked example: the UNDRIP vote

Analyse the 2007 vote: 144 in favour, 4 against and 11 abstaining. 1. States taking a position: 144 + 4 + 11 = 159. 2. Share of yes and no votes in favour: 144 divided by 148 is about 0.973, or 97.3%. 3. Share of all 159 in favour: 144 divided by 159 is about 90.6%. 4. Who voted no: Australia, Canada, New Zealand and the United States, all settler states with large Indigenous land claims. 5. Later change: all four endorsed the declaration in 2009 and 2010, Canada passed a law to implement it in 2021, and British Columbia did so in 2019. 6. Conclusion: near-universal support masked resistance from exactly the states where implementation mattered most.

Free, prior and informed consent

Free, prior and informed consent (FPIC) means that a people must be able to decide about a project affecting its lands without coercion, before it begins, with full information, and with the option of saying no. UNDRIP calls on states to seek such consent, for example before approving mining or relocating communities. States and companies often read it as a duty to consult rather than a right to refuse, so its meaning is disputed. Anthropologists studying extractive projects find that consultation is often rushed, held in languages people do not speak well, or arranged with individuals who lack the authority to speak for the community.

Worked example: testing a consultation

A company holds one meeting in a regional city, in the national language, two weeks after its mine was approved, and signs an agreement with a local mayor. Test it against FPIC. 1. Free: was there pressure? The agreement came after approval, so refusal had little effect. 2. Prior: consent was sought after the decision, so it fails. 3. Informed: one meeting in a language many residents do not speak well cannot convey environmental risks, so it fails. 4. Consent: a mayor may not hold authority under the community's own institutions, such as a council of elders. 5. Conclusion: the process meets none of FPIC's conditions, whatever the paperwork says.

Language and culture

Languages are among the most threatened parts of Indigenous heritage, and also among the most actively defended. Māori parents opened the first kōhanga reo, language nests where preschool children are immersed in te reo Māori, in 1982, and Hawaiian families followed with Pūnana Leo preschools from 1984. In California, the linguist Leanne Hinton and Native language activists began the Master-Apprentice programme in the early 1990s, pairing fluent elders with adult learners. The UN declared 2022 to 2032 the International Decade of Indigenous Languages. Nations also fight stereotypes: after decades of Native protest, Washington's football team became the Commanders in 2022 and Cleveland's baseball team the Guardians in 2021.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, treating Indigenous peoples only as victims and ignoring their political action. Second, describing removal as voluntary migration: it was enforced, and thousands died. Third, thinking UNDRIP is a binding treaty; it is a declaration, while ILO Convention 169 binds only ratifying states. Fourth, equating consultation with consent: FPIC includes the possibility of saying no. Fifth, assuming treaties are historical relics; courts still enforce them, as the Boldt decision shows.

Key takeaways

Indigenous agency runs through treaties, courts, protest, schools and diplomacy. Removal after 1830 included the Cherokee Trail of Tears, in which an estimated 4,000 or more died. The Marshall trilogy (1823 to 1832) made tribes domestic dependent nations. The Boldt decision (1974) affirmed fishing rights, and four Klamath dams came down by 2024. Alcatraz, AIM and Wounded Knee helped bring the self-determination era. ILO Convention 169 (1989) binds ratifying states; UNDRIP, adopted 13 September 2007 by 144 to 4 with 11 abstentions, affirms self-determination and FPIC. Language nests and the Master-Apprentice programme revive languages.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Agency

The capacity to act on one's own goals within constraints

Indigenous peoples acted, not only suffered.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

What did the Supreme Court call tribes in Cherokee Nation v. Georgia (1831)?

Question 2 of 5

Of the 148 states that voted yes or no on UNDRIP in 2007, 144 voted yes. What percentage is that?

Question 3 of 5

What is the legal status of UNDRIP?

Question 4 of 5

A company consults a community only after its project is approved. Which part of FPIC does this clearly fail?

Question 5 of 5

What did the Boldt decision of 1974 establish?

← Previous topicNext topic →