Anthropology › Section H · Political anthropology › Topic H.1

Colonialism and categorizing political systems

Every human community makes decisions, settles quarrels and keeps order, yet most have done so without presidents, parliaments or police. Political anthropology began by sorting this variety into types, and its history shows how much those types owed to colonial rule.

Politics without presidents

In the news, politics means governments. Political anthropology takes a wider view: it studies power, authority and decision-making in every kind of community, from a camp of a few dozen foragers to an empire of millions. Seen across the roughly 300,000 years of our species, the nation-state is a newcomer, only a few centuries old. For most of human history, people organised collective life through families, elders and councils. The questions are always the same: who decides, how disputes are settled, and why people accept, or resist, the decisions made over them.

Colonial rule and the 'no government' myth

Political anthropology grew up inside colonialism. In the late 1800s, European powers extended formal rule over much of Africa, Asia and the Pacific, chiefly to secure raw materials and markets for their industrial economies. Administrators carried ethnocentric assumptions: they pictured colonised peoples as ruled either by cruel despots or by no one at all. British officers practising 'indirect rule', a policy Frederick Lugard applied in Northern Nigeria and set out in a 1922 book, needed to know whom to govern through, and they sometimes hired anthropologists to find out. Fieldwork done under these conditions repeatedly overturned the despot-or-chaos picture. As Talal Asad and colleagues argued in 1973, though, it also served the colonial project that made it possible.

African Political Systems, 1940

A landmark was African Political Systems (1940), edited by the British anthropologists Meyer Fortes and E. E. Evans-Pritchard. Its eight case studies showed African societies governing themselves through well-defined institutions. The editors drew one basic distinction. Centralised societies have rulers, such as chiefs or kings, with administrative and judicial offices. Acephalous societies, from the Greek for 'headless', have no such offices: power works through kin groups, elders and village meetings. Both, the book insisted, produced stable order. The volume used a structural-functionalist approach, asking how each part of a society helped the whole endure. Later critics noted that this made societies look timeless and left out the colonial conquest happening around them.

Service's four types

In 1962 Elman Service, part of a revival of evolutionary theory, proposed four types of social organisation, each with its own political form: band, tribe, chiefdom and state. He linked them to modes of subsistence. Bands go with gathering and hunting, tribes with horticulture and pastoralism, chiefdoms with farming that produces a surplus, and states with intensive agriculture, trade and conquest. Bands and tribes fall on the acephalous side of Fortes and Evans-Pritchard's line; chiefdoms and states are centralised. Service asked how societies moved from one type to the next. The vocabulary is still everywhere, but the model is heavily criticised.

Why the typology is criticised

Critics raise four main problems. First, it reads like a ladder from simple to complex, echoing older theories that ranked peoples; Service's own book title used the word 'primitive', a term anthropologists now reject. Second, real societies rarely fit one box: many mix lineage councils with chiefs, and some switched seasonally between more and less hierarchical arrangements, a point stressed by David Graeber and David Wengrow (2021). Third, change runs in many directions: chiefdoms broke apart as well as grew. Fourth, 'bands' and 'tribes' observed in the 1900s had often been reshaped by colonial pressure. Most anthropologists now treat the types as rough points on a spectrum from shared to centralised power, and focus on each society's history.

Power and Weber's three types of authority

Two terms run through this section. Power is the ability to influence people or shape social processes. Authority is power that people accept as legitimate. The sociologist Max Weber described three ideal types of legitimate authority, also covered in the Sociology course. Traditional authority rests on custom, as with elders or hereditary rulers. Charismatic authority rests on followers' belief in a leader's exceptional qualities. Rational-legal (or legal-rational) authority rests on rules attached to an office, such as a president or judge. Anthropologists add a related contrast. Persuasive power works only by convincing others, while coercive power can enforce decisions with sanctions backed by force. Acephalous societies rely mainly on persuasion; centralised ones add coercion.

Worked example: placing a society on the spectrum

A fieldworker describes a hypothetical community of about 600 horticulturalists. Disputes are heard by a council of lineage elders; no one can be jailed or fined against their will; a respected orator often sums up the council's view; and the colonial government has appointed one man as 'paramount chief', whom villagers consult only about tax. 1. Look for formal offices with coercive power: inside the community there are none, so it is mainly acephalous. 2. Identify the authority types: elders hold traditional authority and the orator persuasive, partly charismatic influence. 3. Note the outside layer: the appointed chief holds rational-legal authority granted by the colonial state. 4. Conclude: the community sits near the shared-power end, with a centralised office imposed from outside.

Worked example: reading a colonial report

Suppose a district officer in about 1905 wrote that a people 'have no government and live in constant disorder'. How should a student evaluate this source? 1. Ask who wrote it and why: an official seeking to justify rule had reasons to find disorder. 2. Ask what he could see: he looked for chiefs, courts and prisons, so councils and mediators may have been invisible to him. 3. Compare later evidence: ethnographies such as those in African Political Systems found organised dispute settlement in many acephalous societies. 4. Weigh the context: during a military campaign, 'disorder' may partly have been resistance to conquest. 5. Conclude: the source is strong evidence of colonial attitudes and weak evidence of how the people actually governed themselves.

Subsistence and politics: a link, not a law

Service's pairing of subsistence with political form captures a real tendency. Mobile foragers who store little food have few resources anyone can monopolise, so leadership tends to stay informal. Large-scale irrigated farming creates surpluses, stores and infrastructure that someone must manage, which favours centralised authority. But the link is a tendency, not a law. Some foragers, such as peoples of the North American Northwest Coast with rich salmon runs, had hereditary ranks and large permanent villages, while some farmers governed themselves through village assemblies. Subsistence is one influence among history, trade, warfare, religion and colonial intervention; the topic 'Modes of subsistence' gives the economic background.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, 'acephalous' does not mean disorderly; it means without formal offices of rule, and such societies maintain order by other means. Second, Service's four types are not stages that every society must climb, and none is more advanced in value. Third, authority is not the same as power: authority is power accepted as legitimate. Fourth, colonial descriptions are not neutral observations; read them as evidence of what officials believed and needed. Fifth, a society labelled a 'band' or 'tribe' in 1950 may have been shaped by decades of colonial contact, so its form is not a window on the ancient past.

Key takeaways

Political anthropology studies how all communities decide, settle disputes and keep order; the nation-state is only a few centuries old. The field grew within colonial rule, which both employed anthropologists and was challenged by their findings. African Political Systems (1940) distinguished centralised from acephalous societies and showed both were orderly. Service's band, tribe, chiefdom and state typology (1962) links politics to subsistence but is criticised as a ladder that ignores history and variety. Weber's traditional, charismatic and rational-legal authority, and the contrast between persuasive and coercive power, are tools for describing any case.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Political anthropology

The study of power, authority and decision-making in all kinds of communities

Not only governments: also elders, councils and mediators.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

What did Fortes and Evans-Pritchard mean by an acephalous society?

Question 2 of 5

Which statement best describes how most anthropologists now treat Service's band, tribe, chiefdom and state types?

Question 3 of 5

A village head is followed because people believe she has extraordinary gifts of vision and speech, not because of custom or any written rule. Which of Weber's types of authority is this?

Question 4 of 5

A 1905 colonial report says a people 'have no government'. What is the best way to use this source?

Question 5 of 5

Which pair correctly matches a type of power with a typical setting?

← Previous topicNext topic →