Anthropology › Section H · Political anthropology › Topic H.2

Bands and tribes

How do people keep order with no rulers, police or written laws? Bands and lineage-based societies answer with consensus, mediation, generosity and cross-cutting ties, and studying them shows that formal government is only one way to run a community.

Order without offices

Friends choosing where to eat settle on a choice without electing anyone. Acephalous societies work on a similar principle, scaled up. No one holds an office that lets them command others. Experienced people give advice, but their influence depends on persuasion, and anyone who tries to boss others around can simply be ignored. Anthropologists commonly describe three kinds of acephalous organisation: bands of foragers, societies organised through lineages and related groups, and village democracies. (Fortes and Evans-Pritchard's 1940 scheme named the first two; village democracy is a later category.) This topic looks at each, using the labels 'band' and 'tribe' from Service's criticised typology as rough guides rather than fixed boxes.

Bands: consensus among foragers

Bands are small, mobile groups of gatherer-hunters, often a few dozen people, whose membership shifts as families move between camps. They are strongly egalitarian. Decisions about where to camp or when to move are made through discussion, and people with relevant knowledge carry more weight. The anthropologist Frank Marlowe, who worked with the Hadza of Tanzania from the 1990s, reported that women, as the main gatherers, often judged when local foods were exhausted and so when camp should move. The ultimate dispute-settling tool is mobility: people in a serious quarrel, or someone who keeps trying to dominate, can leave for another camp. Bands are not without politics; their politics is spread across everyone.

Levelling: keeping anyone from rising

Egalitarianism is actively maintained, not simply the absence of wealth. The topic 'Gathering and hunting' analysed Richard Lee's 1969 account of how his Ju/'hoansi hosts in the Kalahari belittled a generous gift of meat to stop any hunter growing proud. Seen politically, such teasing is one of many levelling mechanisms: social habits that stop one person's success from turning into power over others. Sharing rules spread food widely; gifts create obligations that circulate rather than pile up; and ridicule or quiet withdrawal greets anyone who boasts or gives orders. Christopher Boehm (1999) called the result a reverse dominance hierarchy: the group as a whole keeps would-be leaders in check.

A warning about the word 'tribe'

Journalists sometimes explain wars in Africa or Asia as 'ancient tribal hatreds', implying irrational, unchanging group loyalties. Anthropologists reject this framing because it ignores history. Many supposedly ancient divisions were sharpened or even created under colonial rule. For this reason, some scholars prefer 'ethnic group' for large groups sharing a sense of common ancestry and culture, and 'lineage-based society' for the political form Service called tribal. Yet many Indigenous nations call themselves tribes; the United States, for example, federally recognised 575 tribal nations as of 2026. The rule is respect: use the names communities use for themselves, and avoid 'tribal' as a label for a whole category of supposedly simpler peoples.

Lineage orders and segmentary lineages

In lineage orders, the main political units are descent groups whose members trace ties to a common ancestor, as explained in 'Reckoning kinship and descent across cultures'. Elders lead by knowledge and persuasion, not office. Some societies have segmentary lineages, nested like boxes: small lineages sit inside larger ones, which sit inside clans. E. E. Evans-Pritchard's study of the Nuer of South Sudan, who call themselves Naath, made this famous in 1940. In a quarrel, people rally to the smallest group that includes them but not their opponent. Two brothers' households unite against a cousin's household; the same people unite with those cousins against a more distant lineage. Groups fuse and divide according to the conflict at hand.

Worked example: who takes whose side?

Imagine a hypothetical segmentary system. Clan K contains maximal lineages K1 and K2. K1 contains minimal lineages a and b; K2 contains c and d. 1. A dispute between a and b: each minimal lineage supports its own members, and the rest of K1 stays out or mediates. 2. A dispute between b and c: b now draws support from a, since both belong to K1, and c draws support from d, within K2. So the sides are K1 against K2. 3. A dispute between a member of clan K and an outside clan: a, b, c and d all unite as K. 4. Check the principle: sides form at the level where the two parties' lineages first diverge, so kinship, not a leader, sets them.

Mediators and big men

Acephalous societies still have influential roles. Among the Nuer, a homicide could trigger a feud, so the killer sought out a leopard-skin chief, a ritual mediator from outside the disputing lineages. Despite the name he was no chief: he could not compel anyone, but he negotiated compensation, typically cattle paid to the victim's kin. In much of Melanesia, a big man gains a following by building wealth and giving it away: sponsoring feasts, helping young men with bridewealth and speaking well. Marshall Sahlins contrasted this achieved, fragile status with the inherited office of a chief in 1963. A big man who stops being generous loses his followers, because his power is persuasive, not coercive.

Age sets and village democracy

Other institutions cut across kinship. An age set is a group of people of similar age who are initiated together and move through life stages, called age grades, together, from youth to elder. Among the Xavante of central Brazil, who call themselves A'uwẽ, David Maybury-Lewis described in the 1960s how named age sets bound men from different lineages, creating loyalties that crosscut kinship, while evening councils debated community affairs. Some acephalous societies built village democracies. In precolonial Igbo communities of south-eastern Nigeria, families, lineages, age grades and women's associations met separately, then joined a general assembly where any adult could speak and leaders chaired the search for consensus.

Worked example: 'ancient tribal hatred'?

Test the claim that the 1994 genocide against the Tutsi in Rwanda grew from ancient tribal hatred. 1. Precolonial evidence: Hutu and Tutsi shared a language, religion and territory, intermarried, and the categories were linked to status and wealth, so people could move between them, although the Tutsi-led monarchy was hierarchical and sharpened the divide in the late 1800s. 2. Colonial change: Belgian rule favoured Tutsi in schooling and administration, and from 1933 issued identity cards recording each person's category, making it fixed and hereditary. 3. Later events: independence-era violence, exile and a civil war from 1990 deepened fear, and extremist propaganda organised the killing. 4. Conclusion: the categories are old, but the deadly rigid division was shaped by colonial policy and recent politics, not timeless hatred.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, egalitarian does not mean identical: band members differ in skill and age, but no one can command the rest. Second, a leopard-skin chief and a big man hold no formal office and cannot enforce decisions. Third, segmentary alliances are relative: opponents in one dispute can be allies in the next. Fourth, 'tribal' explanations of modern conflict usually leave out colonial history. Fifth, these accounts describe particular times: Sharon Hutchinson's 1996 study of the Nuer, for example, traced how war, money and the state transformed cattle and kinship.

Key takeaways

Acephalous societies keep order without offices through consensus, persuasion, mediation and the option of leaving. Bands of foragers are egalitarian and use levelling mechanisms, such as the Ju/'hoansi custom of mocking a hunter's meat. Lineage orders organise politics through descent; segmentary lineages fuse and divide according to the conflict. Leopard-skin chiefs mediate and big men lead through generosity, both by persuasion. Age sets and village democracies, such as precolonial Igbo assemblies, add ties that cross kinship. Use 'tribe' with care: respect self-names, and test 'ancient hatred' stories against colonial history.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Band

A small, mobile, egalitarian group of foragers

Often a few dozen people; decisions by consensus.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

In a hypothetical segmentary system, lineages a and b form K1, and c and d form K2, all within clan K. If a member of b quarrels with a member of c, how do sides usually form?

Question 2 of 5

Why did Ju/'hoansi hosts mock the meat that a successful hunter brought back to camp?

Question 3 of 5

What made a Melanesian big man different from a chief?

Question 4 of 5

Which statement about the 1994 genocide against the Tutsi in Rwanda fits the evidence in this topic?

Question 5 of 5

What is the difference between an age set and an age grade?

← Previous topicNext topic →