Anthropology › Section H · Political anthropology › Topic H.3

Chiefdoms and states

When farming produces a surplus, someone can store it, distribute it and take a share. Chiefdoms and states grew from that possibility, concentrating economic, religious and military power in formal offices, and inventing ideas that made the resulting inequality seem natural.

From surplus to centralised power

Most horticultural and herding communities produce little beyond what they consume. Some intensify farming with irrigation, terraces or the plough. Such works need organised labour, and their harvests create a surplus that can feed specialists: potters, priests, warriors, administrators. Elders or big men who organise this work may gain the right to command labour, control stores and manage trade. If they pass that role to their children, leadership becomes hereditary and one lineage can become a ruling line. This is a common path, not a universal law: trade, warfare and religion also mattered, and many societies intensified farming without creating chiefs.

Chiefdoms: hereditary office and fused power

A chief holds a formal, inherited office of leadership; a chiefdom unites several villages under one or more chiefs. Chiefdoms are ranked societies: in Polynesia, for instance, a person's rank depended on genealogical closeness to the senior line. The defining feature is fusion. Economic power (control of land and stores), religious power (leading key rituals, often as a sacred person), military power (raising warriors) and judicial power (settling disputes) are all concentrated in the chief. Chiefs typically collect part of the harvest and redistribute it at feasts or in hard times, supporting the community while displaying their status.

Hawaii: chiefs and the sacred

Archaeologist Timothy Earle linked the power of Hawaiian chiefs (ali'i) before European contact in 1778 to irrigated taro fields and fishponds: chiefs allocated land to commoner households in return for labour and produce. Religion underpinned rank: high chiefs were treated as descendants of gods, protected by strict taboos (kapu), and led the rituals believed to bring fertility. Some archaeologists, notably Patrick Kirch (2010), argue that by the 1600s the largest Hawaiian polities had become small archaic states with divine kings, a reminder that the line between chiefdom and state is blurred.

Asante: power with checks

The Asante confederation of present-day Ghana was founded about 1701, when allied Akan chiefs under Osei Tutu defeated their overlord, Denkyira. Its ruler, the Asantehene, commanded a powerful army and collected tribute from conquered neighbours; the Golden Stool symbolised the unity of the nation. Yet chiefs were not the unchecked despots colonial writers imagined. A council of elders and the queen mother advised each chief, and she helped choose successors. A group of commoners, the asafo, voiced public opinion. A chief who abused power could be destooled: formally removed from office and replaced.

States: a new scale of power

From roughly 5,500 to 5,000 years ago, a new political form emerged in Mesopotamia and Egypt, and later, independently, in the Indus Valley, China, Mesoamerica and the Andes. A state has a centralised government ruling a defined territory; a permanent bureaucracy; taxation or tribute; law enforced by courts and police; and, in Max Weber's well-known definition, a successful claim to a monopoly on the legitimate use of force. States are socially stratified, with classes or castes that have unequal access to wealth and power, and they often expand by conquest into multiethnic empires. Most grew gradually out of large chiefdoms, and many early states proved fragile.

Why states form: integrative and conflict pressures

Theories of state formation emphasise two kinds of pressure. Integrative pressures come from the need to coordinate a growing population: larger irrigation works, more trade and bigger markets all reward central management. Karl Wittfogel's 1957 'hydraulic' theory, tying states to large irrigation systems, is the best-known version, though many states arose without big canals. Conflict pressures come from threats. Robert Carneiro argued in 1970 that where farmland was circumscribed, hemmed in by deserts, mountains or sea, defeated groups could not move away, so warfare produced conquest rather than dispersal. Internal conflict matters too: once classes form, rulers need law, force and persuasion to keep the less privileged cooperating.

Worked example: what can a surplus support?

Consider a hypothetical chiefdom of 400 farming households. Each grows 1,000 kg of grain a year and needs 800 kg to feed itself. The chief takes 15% of every harvest as tribute. 1. Total surplus: \(400 \times (1{,}000 - 800) = 80{,}000\) kg. 2. Tribute: \(400 \times 0.15 \times 1{,}000 = 60{,}000\) kg, which is within the surplus. 3. Specialists supported: if a non-farming household also needs 800 kg, then \(60{,}000 \div 800 = 75\) households of priests, artisans or warriors can be fed. 4. Farmers keep \(1{,}000 \times 0.85 = 850\) kg, a 50 kg buffer. 5. Check the limit: at 25% tribute, farmers keep only 750 kg, 50 kg short of need, so heavier demands require either more intensive farming or coercion.

The Mexica (Aztec) state

The Mexica, as the people usually called Aztecs named themselves, founded Tenochtitlan on an island in Lake Texcoco in about 1325. In 1428 they joined two neighbouring cities in a Triple Alliance that came to dominate central Mexico. Intensive farming, including chinampas, raised fields built from lake mud and vegetation, fed a capital of perhaps 200,000 people or more. Society was sharply stratified: nobles monopolised high office and luxury goods; artisans and long-distance merchants held middle ranks; commoners farmed and paid tribute; at the bottom were people in debt servitude or slavery. Sumptuary laws regulated clothing and housing by rank, making status visible and punishing attempts to claim more.

Ideology and hegemony

Why do most people in a stratified state accept arrangements that favour a few? Force is only part of the answer. An ideology is an organised set of ideas reflecting a group's view of how the world works. Building on the Italian thinker Antonio Gramsci, anthropologists use hegemony for an ideology that has become common sense across society, so that the existing order seems natural. Mexica official religion taught that the gods had sacrificed themselves to set the sun moving, and that human offerings, including war captives, repaid that debt and kept the world alive. Scholars argue that this cosmology also framed commoners' hard labour and tribute as necessary sacrifice for cosmic and social order.

Worked example: chiefdom or state?

An archaeologist finds a hypothetical polity with: a ruler's line traced to a sacred ancestor; tax records kept by full-time scribes; standard weights; a law code; garrisons in conquered towns speaking another language. 1. Hereditary sacred leadership appears in both chiefdoms and states, so it does not decide the case. 2. A permanent bureaucracy and standard measures point to a state. 3. A law code and garrisons suggest enforcement by specialised officials, consistent with a claimed monopoly of force. 4. Rule over people of another language indicates a multiethnic territory. 5. Conclusion: an early state, though, as Hawaii shows, real cases sit on a continuum.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, chiefs are not simply despots: many chiefdoms, such as Asante, had councils, queen mothers and procedures for removing bad rulers. Second, a state is not just a big chiefdom: look for bureaucracy, taxation, law and a claimed monopoly on legitimate force. Third, surplus makes centralisation possible but does not cause it automatically. Fourth, hegemony is not brainwashing: it describes taken-for-granted ideas, and it can be contested. Fifth, early states were not permanent: many collapsed or fragmented.

Key takeaways

Surplus lets leaders control labour, stores and trade; hereditary leadership produces chiefdoms. Chiefs fuse economic, religious, military and judicial power, as in Hawaii and Asante, where councils and destoolment checked rulers. States, emerging independently in several regions from about 5,500 years ago, add territory, bureaucracy, taxation, law and a claimed monopoly on legitimate force, and they are stratified. Integrative and conflict pressures explain their rise. Ideology and hegemony, such as Mexica cosmology, help states win cooperation.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Agricultural intensification

Raising yields with irrigation, terraces or the plough

Creates surplus that can feed specialists.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

What is the defining feature of a chiefdom, according to this topic?

Question 2 of 5

A hypothetical chiefdom has 200 farming households, each growing 1,200 kg of grain and needing 900 kg. The chief takes 10% of each harvest. How many non-farming households needing 900 kg each can the tribute feed?

Question 3 of 5

Robert Carneiro's circumscription theory explains state formation mainly through which mechanism?

Question 4 of 5

Which feature of Asante politics most clearly contradicts the colonial image of African chiefs as unchecked despots?

Question 5 of 5

In anthropology, what does hegemony mean?

← Previous topicNext topic →