Anthropology › Section B · Methods › Topic B.6

Collections, museums, and repatriation

Museums and archives hold millions of objects, documents and human remains gathered over two centuries. They are vital for research, but many were taken without consent, and descendant communities are now reshaping who cares for them, who interprets them and where they belong.

Research in the archive

Not all anthropology happens in the field. Archives preserve manuscripts, letters, maps, field notebooks, photographs and sound recordings, kept away from light, damp and careless handling. Research usually starts with a finding aid, a guide describing what a collection contains, and many are online. Archives rarely lend material: researchers book visits, follow handling rules, wearing gloves for photographs, and may need permission to copy or publish. Copies can often be ordered for a fee, which may cost far less than travelling, though a rich collection may justify a visit. Old field notes let researchers revisit questions, and let communities recover their own histories.

Caring for objects

Collections of baskets, pottery, tools, clothing and bones need careful storage, with controlled temperature and humidity. Woven items are supported so their fibres are not strained, and organic objects are often frozen to kill insects. Waterlogged wood dries out and cracks once raised, so it is kept wet or soaked in polyethylene glycol, a wax-like chemical used to stabilise the Vasa warship. Earlier care sometimes caused harm: many 19th- and 20th-century collections were treated with arsenic, mercury or DDT. These residues endanger staff and the communities who receive returned objects, so testing for them is now routine.

Provenience and provenance

Two similar words matter here. Provenience is where an object was found, ideally its exact location and context. Provenance is its history since then: who collected it, how, and who has owned it, though some writers use the word for origin too. Both are essential. A label reading only "New York" could fit several Indigenous nations, so it cannot show where an object belongs; a precise find spot and a documented chain of ownership can. Gaps in provenance can also hide looting. The 1970 UNESCO Convention commits signatory states to fight the illicit import and export of cultural property.

Who owns the past? US law

For generations museums assumed that whatever they acquired was theirs, including objects dug from graves by collectors and looters. Indigenous nations have long objected, especially to holding ancestors' remains, which many regard as a profound violation. US law has changed in stages. The Antiquities Act (1906) made excavation on federal land require a permit. The National Historic Preservation Act (1966) requires, under Section 106, that federal agencies identify historic properties, usually those at least 50 years old, before a project, consulting state and tribal historic preservation officers and affected tribes. It requires consultation, not preservation, so sites can still be destroyed.

NAGPRA

The Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act (NAGPRA), passed in 1990, requires federal agencies and museums receiving federal funds to inventory Native American human remains, funerary objects, sacred objects and objects of cultural patrimony, consult tribes and Native Hawaiian organisations, and return them on request. Before it, tribes had almost no legal route to recover their ancestors. A 2010 rule eased the return of remains whose tribal affiliation was unclear. Revised regulations, in force from 12 January 2024, require consent before such items are displayed or researched, and several large museums closed or covered exhibits. The Smithsonian follows a parallel 1989 law.

Repatriating knowledge

Repatriation can involve knowledge as well as objects. Field notes and recordings made by early anthropologists hold languages, songs and histories that communities lost under assimilation policies. Many archives now give tribes copies at little or no cost and respect restrictions on sacred material, guided by documents such as the Protocols for Native American Archival Materials (drafted in 2006). Oregon's Coquille Indian Tribe, terminated by the federal government in 1954, gathered copies of anthropological records from distant archives and used them in regaining federal recognition in 1989. The CARE Principles (2019) set out Indigenous peoples' authority over data about them.

Restitution across borders

NAGPRA covers only US institutions, and no binding international system governs returns. In 1897 a British military expedition sacked Benin City, in present-day Nigeria, and carried off thousands of brass plaques, carvings and ivories, the Benin Bronzes, which were sold to museums worldwide. After decades of requests, returns accelerated: in 2022 Germany agreed to transfer ownership of over 1,000 objects to Nigeria, and the Smithsonian returned 29. A 2023 Nigerian decree vested ownership in the Oba (king) of Benin, raising questions about care and public access. Many European museums still hold large colonial-era collections.

Who interprets the past?

Interpretation has changed alongside ownership. Early 20th-century culture history built chronologies but often equated pottery styles with peoples. From the 1960s, Lewis Binford's processual archaeology stressed hypothesis testing and adaptation. From the 1980s, Ian Hodder's post-processual archaeology stressed meaning, agency and the interpreter's own biases, and Margaret Conkey and Janet Spector showed in 1984 how assumptions about gender distorted accounts. Today, Indigenous and community archaeology make descendant communities partners in setting questions, and museums increasingly co-curate exhibits with them, correcting labels that misidentified objects' makers, materials or uses.

Worked example: Great Zimbabwe

Great Zimbabwe is a stone city in southern Africa built mostly between about the 11th and 15th centuries CE. 1. Claim: from the 1870s, European writers attributed it to foreign builders, even the Queen of Sheba. 2. Evidence: Gertrude Caton-Thompson's 1929 excavations, and later radiocarbon dates, pottery and trade goods, showed it was built by ancestors of the Shona people. 3. Motive: colonial writers, and later the white-minority government of Rhodesia, resisted crediting Africans with monumental architecture. 4. Result: the site is now a World Heritage Site and gives Zimbabwe its name. Conclusion: interpretation can serve politics, and evidence must be weighed openly.

Worked example: a box in storage

A university museum finds a box labelled "skull and pipe, Ohio, collected 1890s". 1. Law: the museum receives federal funds, so NAGPRA applies to the remains and possibly to the pipe as a funerary object. 2. Provenience is weak: Ohio was the homeland of several nations, many forcibly removed westward in the 19th century. 3. Consult the tribes with ties to the region, and under the 2024 rules allow no display or study without consent. 4. Test the items for pesticide residues before any transfer. 5. Outcome: the decision rests on consultation with the descendant communities, not the museum's preference. Check: the poor label shows why recording provenience matters.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, confusing provenience, the find spot, with provenance, the ownership history. Second, assuming NAGPRA applies everywhere: it covers US agencies and federally funded museums, not private collectors or foreign museums. Third, thinking Section 106 forbids destroying sites: it requires identification and consultation. Fourth, treating repatriation as the end of research: many communities collaborate on research when consulted. Fifth, describing collections as neutral: many objects were bought under pressure, taken without consent or looted, and their labels can carry old errors.

Key takeaways

Archives and object collections support research but need careful storage; old pesticide treatments now pose hazards. Provenience is the find spot; provenance is the ownership history; both are needed for research and return. US law moved from the Antiquities Act (1906) and NHPA Section 106 (1966), which requires consultation, to NAGPRA (1990), which requires inventories, consultation and repatriation; its 2024 regulations require consent for display and research. Knowledge is repatriated too, as the Coquille restoration (1989) shows. Benin Bronzes looted in 1897 have begun to return. Interpretation, as at Great Zimbabwe, must rest on evidence and include descendant communities.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Finding aid

A guide describing what an archival collection contains

The first step in archival research.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A museum label gives an object's exact excavation spot but nothing about how it later reached the museum. What is missing?

Question 2 of 5

What does Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act (1966) require before a federal highway project?

Question 3 of 5

Under NAGPRA's regulations in force from January 2024, what must a museum have before displaying Native American human remains or sacred objects?

Question 4 of 5

What did the evidence from Great Zimbabwe show about its builders?

Question 5 of 5

Why are old museum objects often tested before being repatriated?

← Previous topicNext topic →