Anthropology › Section B · Methods › Topic B.5

Quantitative and qualitative analysis

Some anthropological questions are answered by counting, others only by understanding what people mean. Good research knows which kind of evidence a question needs, often combines the two, and states its conclusions with honest caution.

Counting and understanding

Imagine studying a weekly market. You could count stalls, prices and visitors per hour, and you would learn how big and busy it is. You could also listen to traders and shoppers, and learn why some people walk an hour to buy from a cousin rather than from the cheapest seller. The first kind of evidence is quantitative; the second is qualitative. Neither is more scientific than the other: they answer different questions. Anthropology, with its holistic aim, usually needs both, and the skill lies in matching the evidence to the question.

Quantitative data

Quantitative data are measurable or countable. They answer limited, specific questions directly: how often something happens, how many, how large, how much it changed. Cultural anthropologists gather them through household surveys, records of how people spend their time, market prices and counts of how often a motif appears in a set of carvings. Archaeologists count artefacts and animal bones. A common measure of bones is NISP, the number of identified specimens, sometimes paired with MNI, the minimum number of individual animals the bones could represent. Statistics then summarise patterns, compare groups and track trends over time.

Qualitative data

Qualitative data are words, actions, images and relationships: interview transcripts, field notes, life histories, descriptions of rituals and symbols. They are analysed for meaning rather than frequency. The researcher reads closely, looks for recurring ideas, and asks how people themselves explain what they do. Open-ended answers can be coded, that is, labelled with themes so that patterns across many interviews become visible. Qualitative analysis depends on the researcher's interpretation, so good practice makes that interpretation transparent: quoting people's own words, showing the coding rules, and noting cases that do not fit.

Worked example: comparing two campsites

Two excavated campsites each yield 200 identified animal bones. Site A: 120 deer, 45 rabbit, 35 fish. Site B: 30 deer, 20 rabbit, 150 fish. 1. Convert to percentages: Site A is 60% deer, 22.5% rabbit, 17.5% fish. 2. Site B is 15% deer, 10% rabbit, 75% fish. 3. Check: each set sums to 100%. 4. Interpret: Site A looks like a hunting camp, Site B a fishing camp, perhaps used in a different season. 5. Qualify: fish bones are small and fragile, and deer bones break into many identifiable pieces, so NISP can exaggerate or hide species; an MNI count and the site's setting should be checked before concluding.

Worked example: coding interview answers

A researcher asks residents of a village, "Why do you still farm your family's land?" 1. Read all answers and note repeated ideas. 2. Draft codes: income, food security, duty to ancestors, place and belonging. 3. Apply them consistently; one answer, "My grandfather is buried at the edge of that field, and we eat what it grows", receives two codes, ancestors and food security. 4. Count how many answers carry each code to see which themes dominate. 5. Keep counter-examples, such as people who farm only because they cannot sell. Conclusion: coding turns qualitative material into patterns while keeping people's own words as evidence.

Mixed methods and triangulation

Many projects use mixed methods, combining quantitative and qualitative evidence. Triangulation means checking a finding against several independent kinds of evidence. Suppose a survey finds that most families say they eat fish daily. Observation of meals, market records and interviews with cooks can show whether reported and actual behaviour match, and why fish matters. When the sources agree, confidence rises; when they disagree, the gap itself is a finding, perhaps showing that fish is a valued ideal that poorer families cannot always afford. Combining evidence in this way supports anthropology's holistic view.

Models

A model is a simplified representation that shows relationships in data. Maps, timelines, calendars, graphs, charts and kinship diagrams are all models. A map turns thousands of measured points into a picture of distances and connections, yet it also carries human choices: which names to use, which colours, what to leave out. A map of a region drawn with a community's own place names tells a different story from a colonial survey map of the same land. Every model therefore combines quantitative measurement with qualitative decisions, and readers should ask who made it and for what purpose.

GPS and layered maps

Archaeologists record the coordinates of every find and feature with satellite positioning (GPS), so a site can be modelled on computer and an exact spot found again years later. Geographic information systems (GIS) stack data in layers: sites, trails, water sources, plant-gathering areas and historic buildings, each switchable on or off. Comparing layers from different dates shows how a neighbourhood or landscape changed. Government agencies and tribal governments build such maps to steer roads and pipelines away from cultural sites. Because looters could use them too, the locations of sensitive sites are usually kept confidential.

Anthropology and the scientific method

Much anthropological research follows the scientific method. 1. A question arises from something observed. 2. The researcher states a testable hypothesis. 3. Quantitative or qualitative data are gathered. 4. The data are analysed, sometimes statistically. 5. A conclusion is drawn. Results rarely prove or disprove a hypothesis outright, so conclusions are stated as likely, with their uncertainty. A well-supported theory remains open to revision as new evidence appears. Some interpretive research, aiming to understand meaning rather than test a prediction, works more openly, but it too must rest on evidence others can examine.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, assuming numbers are automatically objective: the categories counted were chosen by someone. Second, treating qualitative work as anecdote, when systematic coding and transparent quotation make it rigorous. Third, comparing raw counts from samples of different sizes instead of percentages or rates. Fourth, reading a bone or artefact count as a direct measure of past behaviour without considering preservation and breakage. Fifth, claiming a hypothesis is proven: evidence makes it more or less likely, and later data may revise it.

Key takeaways

Quantitative data are counts and measurements, such as surveys, time records, NISP and MNI bone counts, and are summarised with statistics. Qualitative data are words, actions and symbols, analysed for meaning and often coded into themes. Mixed methods and triangulation check findings against independent evidence, and disagreements can be findings in themselves. Models, from maps to kinship diagrams, simplify data and embed human choices. GPS and GIS layered maps record sites precisely and help protect them, though sensitive locations stay confidential. Anthropology uses the scientific method, stating conclusions as likely and open to revision.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Quantitative data

Measurable or countable information

How many, how often, how much.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Of 250 identified bones at a site, 175 come from sheep or goats. What percentage is that?

Question 2 of 5

Which research question calls mainly for qualitative evidence?

Question 3 of 5

A survey says most families eat fish daily, but observation of meals finds fish served only twice a week in poorer homes. What is the best response?

Question 4 of 5

Why can a raw count of identified bones (NISP) mislead about which animals people ate most?

Question 5 of 5

How should a well-tested anthropological conclusion be stated?

← Previous topicNext topic →