Anthropology › Section S · Indigenous anthropology › Topic S.2
Colonization and anthropology
Anthropology grew up alongside empire, and for a long time it studied colonised peoples without asking what they gained from being studied. Indigenous critics forced the discipline to face that history, and their critique has reshaped how research is done.
A discipline born in empire
Anthropology took shape in the late 19th century, when European empires and settler states such as the United States, Canada and Australia were seizing Indigenous lands. Settlers took territory; anthropologists took knowledge, collecting stories, objects, measurements and remains, often with little consent and no return to the communities. Colonial governments sometimes used anthropological knowledge to rule more efficiently, as Colonialism and categorizing political systems showed for Africa. In Anthropology and the Colonial Encounter (1973), edited by Talal Asad, scholars examined these links directly. The point is not that every anthropologist served empire, but that the discipline's questions and power were shaped by it.
Salvage and the vanishing Indian
Many early researchers in North America practised salvage ethnography: recording languages, myths and customs that they assumed would soon disappear. Franz Boas and his students produced a vast record this way, and many communities now use it to revive languages and ceremonies. But the salvage idea also assumed that Indigenous peoples were doomed, and that only a pre-contact past was authentic. That assumption fed the myth of the vanishing Indian, which treated living Native people, adapting to new conditions, as less real than imagined ancestors. Indigenous nations did not vanish; they survived catastrophe and continued, changed but distinct.
Worked example: reading a Curtis photograph
Edward S. Curtis, a photographer, published The North American Indian in 20 volumes between 1907 and 1930. His 1910 image In a Piegan Lodge shows two Piikani (Blackfoot) men seated in a lodge. Analyse it as a source. 1. Content: the men wear traditional dress in a setting with no modern objects. 2. Evidence of editing: the original negative shows a clock between the men, which was removed from the published print. 3. Motive: Curtis wanted to show Native life as timeless and untouched, in line with the vanishing-Indian idea. 4. Reality: by 1910 his subjects lived on reservations, often in poverty, and used manufactured goods. 5. Conclusion: the photograph is valuable, but as evidence of Curtis's vision as much as of Piikani life.
Deloria's challenge
In 1969 Vine Deloria Jr., a Standing Rock Sioux scholar and activist, published Custer Died for Your Sins. A chapter titled Anthropologists and Other Friends mocked researchers who arrived every summer, built careers and book sales on Native communities, and gave little back, while their abstract debates ignored urgent problems such as poverty and treaty rights. Deloria later argued, in Red Earth, White Lies (1995), that science often dismissed Indigenous knowledge. His critique hurt, and it worked. Anthropologists responded with essays and reforms, collected in Indians and Anthropologists (1997), and Deloria's writing helped inspire Native American studies programmes from the 1970s.
Othering
Othering means portraying a group as fundamentally different from, and usually inferior to, one's own. Edward Said's Orientalism (1978) showed how Western scholarship constructed the East as exotic and backward. The Māori scholar Linda Tuhiwai Smith, in Decolonizing Methodologies (1999), applied similar arguments to research on Indigenous peoples, showing how Western science had defined them, classified them and spoken for them. Othering has practical effects. Canada's National Inquiry into Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Girls reported in 2019 that persistent racism and the failure of police and governments to act contributed to very high levels of violence, which it described as a genocide.
Research harms
The Havasupai case shows why trust broke down. In 1990 researchers at Arizona State University collected blood from members of the Havasupai Tribe, whose homeland is in the Grand Canyon, for a study of diabetes. Many participants later learned that their samples had also been used, without their understanding or consent, for studies of schizophrenia, inbreeding and ancient migration, the last of which contradicted the tribe's own account of its origins. The tribe sued, and in 2010 the university settled, paying $700,000 to 41 tribal members and returning the remaining samples. The case pushed tribes to set their own research rules.
Collaborators, not informants
Older ethnographies called the people who explained their culture informants, a word that hides their expertise. Many were in fact scholars in their own right. George Hunt, raised among the Kwakwaka'wakw of British Columbia, wrote thousands of pages of texts in Kwak'wala for Franz Boas. Ella Cara Deloria, a Yankton Dakota linguist and Vine Deloria Jr.'s aunt, recorded and translated Dakota texts. Francis La Flesche, an Omaha ethnologist, co-wrote The Omaha Tribe (1911) with Alice Fletcher. Today many researchers name community experts as co-authors, and tribes increasingly commission research and keep the right to review what is published.
Frozen in time?
Outsiders often judge Indigenous communities against a picture of the 19th century: if people drive cars, live in suburbs or attend church, they are said to be no longer really Native. Anthropologists reject this. Every culture changes, borrowing technologies and ideas, and a community can adopt Christianity or smartphones while keeping its language, kinship, ceremonies and sense of nationhood. Treating change as loss of authenticity has real costs, because claims to land, recognition or rights are sometimes challenged on the grounds that a people has changed too much. Cultural continuity lies in how a people carries its past forward, not in standing still.
Worked example: an old field note
A tribal language programme finds a 1930s notebook in which an anthropologist recorded a ceremony described by an elder. Decide how to use it. 1. Who spoke: the elder was a knowledgeable community member who chose to share the account, so it carries real authority. 2. Who wrote: the anthropologist translated and summarised, and may have shaped the account to fit his theories or missed its meaning. 3. Check: compare the note with the knowledge of today's elders and with other records. 4. Respect: ask whether the ceremony's details were meant for outsiders, and restrict access if not. 5. Use: treat the note as one voice in a conversation between generations, neither as untouchable truth nor as worthless.
Decolonising anthropology
From the 1970s, and more forcefully after Faye Harrison's edited volume Decolonizing Anthropology (1991), scholars called for research that served the people studied. This includes returning knowledge: during the 1990s the Coquille scholar George Wasson led an Oregon project that copied archival records about western Oregon tribes and gave them to those tribes. The Lakota anthropologist Beatrice Medicine, from Standing Rock, showed in her teaching and in a 2001 book on remaining Native while becoming an anthropologist how the discipline could work for Native communities.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, assuming early anthropology was neutral: its questions and access were shaped by colonial power. Second, the opposite error, dismissing all old ethnography as useless, when many communities use it to revive languages and practices. Third, calling community experts mere informants. Fourth, treating cultural change as the loss of Indigenous identity. Fifth, reading staged images such as Curtis's as straightforward records. Sixth, thinking consent once given covers any later use of data or samples; the Havasupai case shows it does not.
Key takeaways
Anthropology developed alongside colonialism, collecting Indigenous knowledge with little consent or return. Salvage ethnography preserved much but assumed peoples were vanishing; Curtis's staged photographs, such as the retouched In a Piegan Lodge (1910), show that vision. Vine Deloria Jr.'s Custer Died for Your Sins (1969) forced reform, and Linda Tuhiwai Smith analysed research as othering. The Havasupai settlement of 2010 showed the harm of misusing samples. Experts such as George Hunt, Ella Deloria and Francis La Flesche were scholars, not informants. Culture changes without losing authenticity, and decolonising work returns knowledge and puts communities in charge.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Talal Asad's 1973 volume examining anthropology's links to empire
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
What does the removal of a clock from Curtis's In a Piegan Lodge show?
Question 2 of 5
What was the core of Vine Deloria Jr.'s critique in Custer Died for Your Sins?
Question 3 of 5
Why was the Havasupai case a breach of research ethics?
Question 4 of 5
A community adopts Christianity and modern technology while keeping its language and ceremonies. How do anthropologists view its authenticity?
Question 5 of 5
How should a tribal programme treat a 1930s field note recording an elder's account of a ceremony?
