Anthropology › Section B · Methods › Topic B.2

Conservation, naturalism, and dating evidence

The great museum collections that anthropologists still use were built in the 19th century by people collecting nature and, controversially, collecting Indigenous cultures too. This topic looks at that history and then at the tools that put dates on what is collected, from pottery styles to the decay of carbon-14.

Conservation and naturalism

From the 1860s, people in Europe and North America saw that settlement, logging and hunting were destroying species and landscapes. The early conservation movement set land aside: the Yosemite Valley was granted to California for protection in 1864, and Yellowstone became the first national park in 1872. Hunters and outdoor enthusiasts were among its strongest supporters, wanting wild places to use. Alongside it grew naturalism, the effort to understand the world by direct observation of nature, which filled new natural history museums with specimens. Those collections still matter: zooarchaeologists compare excavated bones with reference skeletons to identify species.

Indigenous peoples in natural history museums

Natural history museums did not collect only plants and animals. Baskets, clothing, carvings and whole totem poles from Indigenous nations, especially of the Northwest Coast, entered their halls in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. Many objects were bought; others were taken when owners refused to sell. Museums also built dioramas showing Indigenous people as life-size figures in "natural" settings, displayed beside stuffed animals. Critics, Indigenous scholars prominent among them, point out that this placed living peoples in nature rather than in history, as if they were part of the wildlife. Many museums have since removed or reworked such displays with Indigenous co-curators.

Salvage anthropology

Salvage anthropology was the late 19th-century rush to record Indigenous languages, stories and objects before, as collectors assumed, the peoples themselves disappeared. The Bureau of American Ethnology, founded in 1879 within the Smithsonian, employed many such researchers on reservations. Some collecting was fair purchase or patient recording with knowledgeable collaborators; some was theft, and some poorly paid researchers bought objects cheaply and resold them to museums. Most ignored the poverty around them. A few did more: Leo Frachtenberg, who recorded coastal Oregon languages in the early 1900s, is credited with helping tribal members trace unratified 1850s treaties later used in land claims. The founding assumption was wrong; these nations survived and now use the records themselves.

Relative dating

Collections and excavations need dates. Relative dating puts finds in order without giving years. Stratigraphy, from the previous topic, orders layers. Seriation orders graves or sites by changing styles: Flinders Petrie, working on Egyptian burials in the 1890s, arranged them by pottery types whose popularity rose and fell. Cross-dating links sites that share a distinctive object type. Fluorine testing compares bones from one deposit, since buried bone slowly absorbs fluorine from groundwater; in 1953 it helped expose Piltdown Man, "found" in 1912, as a forgery assembled from a human skull only centuries old and an orangutan jaw.

Radiocarbon dating

Willard Libby developed radiocarbon dating in the late 1940s and won the 1960 Nobel Prize in Chemistry. Living things take in carbon, including a small fixed share of radioactive carbon-14. At death intake stops and the carbon-14 decays, halving about every 5,730 years. The age follows from the fraction \(f\) that remains:

t = 5730 \times \log_2\left(\frac{1}{f}\right)

After about 50,000 years only about 0.2% is left, too little to measure reliably, so that is the method's practical limit. It dates organic materials: charcoal, bone, seeds, wood, shell and textiles. Ages are given in years BP, before present, where present means 1950.

Worked example: dating a charred seed

A charred seed retains 30% of the carbon-14 of living plants. How old is it, before calibration? 1. One half-life leaves 50% and two leave 25%, so the answer lies between 5,730 and 11,460 years, nearer the second. 2. Substitute \(f = 0.30\): \(\log_2(1/0.30) = 1.737\) half-lives. 3. Multiply: \(t = 5730 \times 1.737 \approx 9{,}950\) years. 4. Check: \(0.5^{1.737} = 0.30\), as required. 5. Note: laboratories by convention report raw ages with Libby's original half-life, 5,568 years, which gives about 9,670 radiocarbon years BP; calibration then converts this to calendar years.

Calibration and AMS

Radiocarbon dating assumes the atmosphere always held the same share of carbon-14, but it did not: the share varied with solar activity, Earth's magnetic field and the carbon cycle. Raw ages are therefore calibrated against records of known age, mainly tree rings, together with corals, cave formations and layered lake sediments, giving a calendar range with a stated probability, written as cal BP. Accelerator mass spectrometry (AMS), in use from the late 1970s, counts carbon-14 atoms directly instead of waiting for decays. It needs only milligrams of material, so a single seed or a thread can be dated without destroying a whole object.

Dendrochronology

Dendrochronology dates wood by its annual growth rings. Wet years produce wide rings and dry years narrow ones, so trees in one region share a pattern. By overlapping patterns from living trees, old buildings and buried timbers, researchers have built continuous sequences reaching back more than 12,000 years in central Europe. A beam whose outermost ring survives can be dated to the exact year its tree was felled. Tree rings also supply the calendar-dated wood used to calibrate radiocarbon. The Laboratory of Tree-Ring Research at the University of Arizona, founded in 1937, pioneered the method in the American Southwest.

Methods for older material

Beyond radiocarbon's range other clocks take over. Potassium-argon and argon-argon dating measure the slow decay of potassium-40 into argon in volcanic rock, so they date ash layers above and below a fossil rather than the fossil itself; they are central to early hominin sites in East Africa. Uranium-series dating works on cave formations and corals up to about half a million years old. Luminescence methods date when grains of quartz or feldspar were last heated, as in pottery or burnt flint, or last exposed to sunlight, as in buried sediment. Archaeomagnetic dating of fired clay and obsidian hydration add further clocks. Strong chronologies combine several independent methods.

Worked example: bracketing a fossil

A hominin tooth lies in lake sediment between two volcanic ash layers. Argon-argon dating gives the ash below as about 1.87 million years old and the ash above as about 1.75 million years old. 1. By superposition the tooth was buried after the lower ash fell. 2. It was covered before the upper ash fell. 3. So its age lies between about 1.87 and 1.75 million years. 4. Radiocarbon cannot test this, since the tooth is far beyond 50,000 years. 5. A luminescence or palaeomagnetic result from the same sediment that agrees with the bracket would strengthen confidence. Conclusion: a bracketed date is a range, not a point.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, applying radiocarbon to stone tools or to anything older than about 50,000 years: it needs organic carbon within its range. Second, thinking each half-life removes a fixed amount: it removes half of whatever remains. Third, treating a raw radiocarbon age as a calendar date before calibration. Fourth, assuming potassium-argon dates the fossil itself rather than the volcanic layers around it. Fifth, describing salvage anthropology as neutral record-keeping: it rested on the false belief that Indigenous peoples were vanishing, and it sometimes took objects without consent.

Key takeaways

Nineteenth-century conservation (Yosemite 1864, Yellowstone 1872) and naturalism filled natural history museums, including with Indigenous objects and dioramas now widely criticised. Salvage anthropology, partly through the Bureau of American Ethnology (1879), recorded cultures it wrongly assumed were vanishing. Relative dating uses stratigraphy, seriation (Petrie), cross-dating and fluorine (Piltdown exposed 1953). Radiocarbon (Libby, Nobel 1960) uses a half-life of about 5,730 years, works to about 50,000 years, needs calibration, and gives BP dates counted from 1950; AMS needs only milligrams. Dendrochronology gives exact years. Argon-argon, uranium-series and luminescence date older material.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Yellowstone, 1872

The first national park

Early conservation movement.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A piece of charcoal retains 1/16 of the carbon-14 found in living wood. About how old is it, before calibration?

Question 2 of 5

Which material could be dated directly by radiocarbon?

Question 3 of 5

A fossil lies between ash layers dated by argon-argon to 2.10 million years (below) and 1.95 million years (above). What can be said about its age?

Question 4 of 5

What was the central assumption behind salvage anthropology in the late 19th century?

Question 5 of 5

Why are raw radiocarbon ages calibrated?

← Previous topicNext topic →