Anthropology › Section B · Methods › Topic B.3
Ethnography and ethnology
Cultural anthropology rests on two linked activities: describing one way of life in depth, and comparing many ways of life to find patterns. Knowing how each developed, and whose voices they once left out, explains how anthropologists work today.
Describing one, comparing many
Two similar words name two different tasks. Ethnography is the detailed description of a particular community or way of life, and the word covers both the research and the book or film that results. Ethnology is the comparison of many cultures to find similarities, differences and patterns. Ethnography supplies the evidence; ethnology asks what that evidence, gathered from many places, shows about human life in general. The two depend on each other: comparisons are only as good as the descriptions they rest on, and a single description gains meaning when set beside others.
Ethnography: method and product
As a method, ethnography means close, usually long-term study of a community: living among people, talking with them, joining in daily life and recording what happens. Ethnographers also draw on government records, archives, museum collections and archaeological evidence. As a product, an ethnography is the account that results, traditionally a book-length study, called a monograph, of one group, though today it may be an article, a film or a website made with the community. The next topic, Participant observation and interviewing, looks at the fieldwork techniques in detail.
Armchair anthropology
Much 19th-century anthropology was done from a desk. Armchair anthropologists built theories from secondhand reports by missionaries, travellers and colonial officials. James Frazer's The Golden Bough (first published 1890), a vast comparison of magic and religion, is the classic example. The reports were uneven, often hostile, and stripped of context, so armchair theorists could fit them into ladders of supposed progress from "savage" to "civilised", terms now rejected. Lewis Henry Morgan, writing about the Haudenosaunee (Iroquois) in 1851, partly broke the pattern: he visited Seneca communities and worked closely with the Seneca scholar Ely S. Parker.
Boas and firsthand fieldwork
Franz Boas, a German-born scientist who taught at Columbia University from the 1890s, insisted that anthropologists collect information directly from the people they wrote about, in their own languages, and interpret each culture in its own historical context. He worked across all four fields and trained a generation of fieldworkers, including Ruth Benedict, Margaret Mead, Zora Neale Hurston and the Yankton Dakota scholar Ella Cara Deloria. In Britain, Bronislaw Malinowski made long-term residence in a community the standard. Together they turned fieldwork into the defining practice of cultural anthropology.
Thick description
Ethnography aims to capture meaning, not just behaviour. Clifford Geertz, in a 1973 essay, called this thick description, borrowing the phrase from the philosopher Gilbert Ryle: describing an action along with the shared understandings that make it meaningful to the people involved. A thin account of a funeral lists who attended and what they did; a thick account explains why some mourners wail and others stay silent, what the gifts exchanged mean, and how the event repairs relationships among the living. The topic Culture as shared meaning develops this idea further.
Ethnology: comparing cultures
Early ethnologists compared languages, dress and customs to trace how peoples were related and where they had migrated, including how people first reached the Americas. Modern ethnology tests ideas systematically. The Human Relations Area Files, founded at Yale in 1949, organises ethnographies of hundreds of cultures by subject, so a researcher can compare, for example, childrearing or warfare across a worldwide sample. Comparison has a known trap, called Galton's problem after Francis Galton raised it in 1889: neighbouring or related societies may share a trait by borrowing or common descent, so they are not independent cases.
Worked example: designing a comparison
A student asks whether societies that rely on stored grain hold larger, more formal feasts than societies that do not. 1. Define the variables: stored grain as a main food source, yes or no; feasts measured by number of guests and frequency. 2. Choose a sample spread across world regions, taking only one society from each cluster of closely related neighbours, to avoid Galton's problem. 3. Code each ethnography using the same rules, ideally with two coders checking each other. 4. Compare the two groups. 5. Interpret cautiously: a pattern would show association, not cause, and ethnography from a few societies would be needed to see how the link works.
Ethnoarchaeology
Ethnology also links living and past societies. In ethnoarchaeology, archaeologists study how present-day people make, use and discard things, then use those observations to interpret archaeological remains. Lewis Binford's Nunamiut Ethnoarchaeology (1978) recorded how Nunamiut Iñupiat hunters in northern Alaska butchered, stored and discarded caribou, and showed how different activities leave different patterns of bones. Such analogies are useful but limited: present-day people are not living fossils, and their practices have their own histories, so analogy suggests possibilities that the archaeological evidence must then test.
Whose voices are recorded?
No single person holds the whole of their culture, so ethnographers now seek people of different genders, ages, ranks and opinions. Early ethnographies often relied on male informants and male researchers, and described men's activities as if they were the whole society. Feminist anthropology set out to correct this. Women such as Hurston, Benedict, whose Patterns of Culture appeared in 1934, and Mead, whose Coming of Age in Samoa appeared in 1928, gained wide readerships, though Mead's Samoan work was later fiercely disputed. From the 1970s, edited volumes made women's lives and gender central topics, and Indigenous anthropologists added further perspectives.
Worked example: revisiting a classic
Malinowski's Trobriand Islands ethnographies, from about the 1910s and 1920s, centred on men's kula exchange of shell valuables. Annette Weiner did fieldwork there in the early 1970s. 1. She attended mortuary ceremonies where women distributed thousands of bundles of dried banana leaves and fibre skirts. 2. These distributions publicly settled the dead person's social debts and showed the standing of women's kin groups. 3. Malinowski had mentioned such exchanges but treated them as minor, largely because he worked mainly with men. 4. Weiner's book, Women of Value, Men of Renown (1976), argued that Trobriand economy cannot be understood without them. Conclusion: who the ethnographer talks to shapes what the ethnography sees.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, mixing up the terms: ethnography describes one community, ethnology compares many. Second, treating a classic ethnography as timeless truth: it describes one place at one time, through one researcher's eyes, and later studies may revise it. Third, counting neighbouring societies as independent cases in a comparison. Fourth, treating present-day people in ethnoarchaeology as unchanged survivors of the past. Fifth, assuming one well-informed person can speak for a whole culture: experiences differ by gender, age and position.
Key takeaways
Ethnography is the in-depth description of one community, both as research and as product; ethnology is comparison across cultures. Armchair anthropology, such as Frazer's The Golden Bough (1890), relied on secondhand reports. Boas insisted on firsthand fieldwork in local languages and trained Benedict, Mead, Hurston and Ella Deloria; Malinowski made long-term residence standard. Geertz's thick description (1973) captures meaning. The Human Relations Area Files (1949) support systematic comparison, which must avoid Galton's problem. Ethnoarchaeology, as in Binford's Nunamiut study (1978), links living and past societies. Feminist anthropology, as in Weiner's Trobriand restudy (1976), showed whose voices earlier ethnographies missed.
Flashcards
Flashcard
In-depth description of one community, as research and as product
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
A researcher reads ethnographies of 60 societies to test whether polygyny is linked to a particular way of making a living. What kind of work is this?
Question 2 of 5
In a comparative study, why should a researcher avoid counting several neighbouring, closely related societies as separate cases?
Question 3 of 5
What best distinguishes thick description from a thin account?
Question 4 of 5
What did Annette Weiner's Trobriand fieldwork in the early 1970s add to Malinowski's earlier account?
Question 5 of 5
Which statement about armchair anthropology is accurate?
