Anthropology › Section J · Human migration › Topic J.2

Early global movements and cultural hybridity

Long before smartphones and container ships, empires, trade and forced migration moved people and ideas across oceans. Those movements produced new mixed cultures, and the concepts anthropologists use for them, diaspora, transnationalism and hybridity, help explain the connected world we live in now.

Colonialism as an early global force

When people move, they carry languages, foods, beliefs and skills, and these mix with what they find. Some of the largest movements in history were driven by colonialism: a relationship in which one society takes political control of another, mainly for economic gain. The archaeologist Guillermo Algaze argued that the city of Uruk in southern Mesopotamia set up outposts along trade routes far to the north by about 3500 BCE. Phoenician traders from what is now Lebanon founded Carthage, in modern Tunisia, traditionally in 814 BCE, and it controlled much Mediterranean trade until Rome destroyed it in 146 BCE.

European expansion after 1492

Christopher Columbus's four voyages between 1492 and 1504 opened a new scale of colonisation. Portugal, Spain, the Netherlands, France and Britain built empires across the Americas, Africa and Asia. European writers called the period the Age of Discovery, a label anthropologists use with care, because the lands were already home to millions of people. Diseases such as smallpox and measles, combined with war and forced labour, killed a very large share of the Indigenous population of the Americas. Survivors resisted, fled or were moved; in the Andes, the rising led by Túpac Amaru II from 1780 nearly overthrew Spanish rule in parts of Peru.

The transatlantic slave trade

The largest forced migration of this era was the transatlantic slave trade. According to the SlaveVoyages database, about 12.5 million Africans were forced aboard ships for the Americas between the early 1500s and the 1860s, and about 10.7 million survived the crossing. Families and communities were torn apart, and the suffering and loss of life cannot be measured. Yet the people carried across the ocean also carried knowledge and culture. They shaped the music, foods, languages and religions of the Americas: the banjo developed from West African lutes, okra entered Southern cooking, and Gullah Geechee, a creole language, is still spoken on the coasts of South Carolina and Georgia.

Creolisation and syncretism

Creolisation is the formation of new cultures from the meeting of different ones, especially under colonial rule. Religious blending is called syncretism. In Brazil, Candomblé practitioners came to link Yoruba orixás, divine beings, with Catholic saints, and Haitian Vodou combines West African and Catholic elements. Anthropologists have debated how such cultures formed. Melville Herskovits, in The Myth of the Negro Past (1941), stressed African survivals carried across the Atlantic. Sidney Mintz and Richard Price, in an essay of 1976, argued that enslaved people from many different societies built new institutions in the Americas. Most scholars now see both continuity and creation at work.

After empire: postcolonialism

Most colonies in Asia and Africa won independence between the 1940s and the 1970s, but colonial patterns did not vanish. Postcolonialism refers to the lasting effects of colonial rule: wealth and technology concentrated in former colonising countries, borders drawn by outsiders, and racial hierarchies built into institutions. Ghana's first president, Kwame Nkrumah, popularised the term neocolonialism in a book of 1965 for continued economic control without formal rule. Migration followed these ties. Many people moved from former colonies to the countries that had ruled them, and educated professionals who left created a brain drain, a loss of skills for the countries they left.

Globalisation as flows: Appadurai's scapes

Arjun Appadurai, in an essay of 1990 and the book Modernity at Large (1996), described globalisation as several overlapping flows, each with the suffix -scape to show that it looks different from different positions. Ethnoscapes are flows of people: tourists, migrants, refugees and guest workers. Technoscapes are flows of technology. Financescapes are flows of money and capital. Mediascapes are flows of images and stories through film, television and the internet. Ideoscapes are flows of political ideas such as democracy or rights. The flows move at different speeds and do not line up neatly, producing what Appadurai called disjunctures, so global culture is not one single, uniform thing.

Diaspora and transnationalism

A diaspora is a population dispersed from a homeland, often by violence or hardship, that keeps a shared memory of that homeland, ties to it, a distinct identity and links with members in other countries. Examples include the African diaspora created by the slave trade, the Irish diaspora after the famine of 1845 to 1852, and the Jewish and Armenian diasporas. As of 2024 India was the largest country of origin, with about 18.5 million emigrants, according to the United Nations. Transnationalism, a term developed by Linda Basch, Nina Glick Schiller and Cristina Szanton Blanc in the early 1990s, describes migrants who live their lives across borders, keeping families, businesses and politics in two or more countries.

Hybridity and its critics

Cultural hybridity is the creation of new cultural forms when elements from different cultures combine through migration and globalisation. The Argentine-Mexican scholar Néstor García Canclini, in Hybrid Cultures (about 1990), studied how Latin Americans mix traditional, popular and mass culture. Homi Bhabha (1994) wrote of a third space where new identities form between cultures. Critics point out that the word can wrongly suggest that cultures were once pure; all cultures are already mixed. Power also matters: some mixtures are celebrated as creative while others are dismissed as inauthentic, and those judgements often follow lines of class and race.

Worked example: diaspora, transnationalism or hybridity?

Consider Punjabi families in Britain, many of whom arrived from the 1950s onward. Sort three facts. 1. Many keep a strong Punjabi identity, memories of Punjab and ties to relatives in India, Canada and the United States: diaspora. 2. Some families own land in Punjab, send money there, return for weddings and follow its politics: transnationalism, a life lived across borders. 3. In the 1980s young British Punjabis fused the rhythms of bhangra, a Punjabi harvest folk dance played on the dhol drum, with disco, reggae and hip hop: hybridity, a new form. 4. Check: one community can show all three, because the terms describe different aspects, not different groups.

Worked example: tracing the scapes

Take a hypothetical case. A Nigerian family in London streams a new Nollywood film on a phone, pays for it with a mobile app, and argues over its portrayal of women's rights. Identify the flows. 1. The family itself, as migrants, is part of an ethnoscape. 2. The film and its images are a mediascape. 3. The phone, network and streaming platform form a technoscape. 4. The payment moving between companies and countries is a financescape. 5. The argument about women's rights draws on an ideoscape. 6. Check for disjuncture: the film reaches London instantly, while the family's visas and travel may be slow and costly, so the flows move at different speeds.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, treating globalisation as new: empires, trade and forced migration linked continents for millennia. Second, calling the Americas empty before 1492; the land was home to many nations. Third, describing enslaved Africans only as victims, forgetting how they shaped the cultures of the Americas. Fourth, mixing up the terms: diaspora is a dispersed population with homeland ties, transnationalism is living across borders, and hybridity is the new forms that result. Fifth, imagining hybrid cultures mixing two once-pure originals. Sixth, assuming colonial effects ended at independence.

Key takeaways

Colonialism, political control for economic gain, dates back at least to Uruk and Carthage and expanded vastly after 1492. About 12.5 million Africans were forced aboard slave ships, about 10.7 million surviving, and their descendants helped create new cultures through creolisation and syncretism. Postcolonialism and neocolonialism (Nkrumah, 1965) describe lasting colonial effects. Appadurai's five scapes show globalisation as uneven flows. Diasporas keep homeland ties; India had about 18.5 million emigrants in 2024. Transnational migrants live across borders. Hybridity produces new forms, but all cultures are already mixed.

Sources and further reading

Flashcards

Flashcard

Colonialism

One society taking political control of another, mainly for economic gain

Ancient roots, vast after 1492.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

What did Sidney Mintz and Richard Price argue, in contrast to Melville Herskovits?

Question 2 of 5

A family in London streams a Nollywood film on a phone. In Appadurai's terms, the phone and streaming platform are part of which scape?

Question 3 of 5

A British Punjabi family owns land in Punjab, sends money there and returns for weddings. Which concept best fits these facts?

Question 4 of 5

What is a common criticism of the concept of cultural hybridity?

Question 5 of 5

According to SlaveVoyages estimates, about how many Africans were forced aboard ships in the transatlantic slave trade?

← Previous topicNext topic →