Anthropology › Section J · Human migration › Topic J.3

Peasantry and urbanization

Most people in history were peasants, small cultivators tied to towns and states that took a share of what they grew. Their move into cities, one of the great migrations of the last century, is still under way, and anthropologists have followed it from village fields to urban neighbourhoods.

Who are peasants?

Peasants are rural cultivators who work small plots, mainly with household labour, and produce chiefly to feed their families. What sets them apart is their place inside a state. Unlike independent horticulturalists, they must hand part of what they produce to others, as rent, taxes, tribute or low crop prices. Eric Wolf, in Peasants (1966), called this obligation a fund of rent and distinguished peasants from farmers, who run their land as a business for profit. Peasant life therefore depends on cities and elites that peasants do not control. Before industrialisation, peasants were the majority in agrarian states from China to Europe and the Andes.

Little and great traditions

The American anthropologist Robert Redfield was among the first to treat peasants as a distinct subject. In Peasant Society and Culture (1956) he called peasant communities part-societies with part-cultures: they have their own local ways but are always linked to a wider civilisation. He contrasted the little tradition of the village, local customs passed on largely by word of mouth, with the great tradition of the city, the written scriptures, law and learning of priests and scholars. The two influence each other. Redfield's earlier folk-urban continuum, from his work in Yucatán, Mexico, in the 1930s, ranked communities from isolated villages to cities.

Worked example: Tepoztlán studied twice

Redfield studied the Mexican village of Tepoztlán in 1926 and 1927 and described, in 1930, a harmonious, close-knit community. Oscar Lewis restudied it in the 1940s and, in 1951, described distrust, envy, land disputes and poverty. Analyse the contrast. 1. Same place, opposite portraits: if both researchers worked carefully, neither account can simply be dismissed as wrong. 2. Time: nearly two decades of change, including land reform and a new road, separated the studies. 3. Questions: Redfield looked for shared customs and festivals; Lewis measured landholding, diet and quarrels. 4. Outlook: Redfield later accepted that his own values shaped what he saw. 5. Lesson: restudies reveal how a researcher's questions shape findings, a reason to reflect on one's own position.

Closed and open communities

In essays of 1955 and 1957, Wolf contrasted two kinds of peasant community. Closed corporate communities, which he described in highland Mesoamerica and central Java, restrict membership to people born there, control land collectively and discourage outsiders from buying it. They also level wealth: in the cargo system of many Mesoamerican villages, men who prosper are expected to serve in unpaid civil and religious offices and sponsor costly festivals, gaining prestige while spending savings. Open communities, such as coffee-growing districts of Puerto Rico, are tied directly to world markets through cash crops, and their members rise and fall with prices.

How peasant households decide

The Russian economist Alexander Chayanov argued in the 1920s that peasant families do not behave like firms. A household works harder when it has many children to feed and fewer workers, and eases off once needs are met, balancing consumption against the drudgery of extra labour. James C. Scott, in The Moral Economy of the Peasant (1976), added that peasants living close to the margin put safety first, preferring a reliable small harvest to a risky large one. When markets threaten that security, protest can follow. On 1 January 1994, the day NAFTA took effect, the Zapatista uprising began in Chiapas, Mexico, led largely by Indigenous Maya peasants who feared cheap imported maize and the 1992 end of land redistribution.

From village to city

Internal migration from countryside to city has often begun as a household strategy rather than a final break. A family sends a son or daughter to work in construction, domestic service or a factory, and the wages pay for school fees, seeds or a new roof. Migrants keep land and return for harvests and festivals, so village and city form one social field. Michael Kearney, in Reconceptualizing the Peasantry (1996), studied Mixtec people from Oaxaca, Mexico, who combined farming with wage work in Mexican cities and California fields, and argued that the label peasant no longer captures such lives. Some scholars call them post-peasants.

An urbanising world

The UN's World Urbanization Prospects 2025 classified settlements by population size and density, a method called the Degree of Urbanisation. It found that about 45% of the world's 8.2 billion people live in cities, 36% in towns and 19% in rural areas. Using countries' own definitions, only about 58% count as urban, because many places the new method calls towns are treated as rural at home. Sub-Saharan Africa is the only region where the rural population is still growing significantly. UN-Habitat's 2026 reporting puts the number living in slums or informal settlements at more than 1.1 billion. The Sociology course topic Urbanization covers megacities.

Worked example: one world, two counts

Use the 2025 UN figures to see how much definitions matter. 1. People in cities: 45% of 8.2 billion is about 3.69 billion. 2. Towns: 36% of 8.2 billion is about 2.95 billion; rural areas: 19%, about 1.56 billion. 3. Urban by the new method, cities plus towns: 45% + 36% = 81%, about 6.64 billion. 4. Urban by national definitions: 58%, about 4.76 billion. 5. Gap: 81% − 58% = 23 percentage points, about 1.89 billion people. 6. Interpretation: almost two billion people live in places that their own governments call rural but that are dense and built-up. 7. Check: 3.69 + 2.95 + 1.56 = 8.20 billion.

Migrants in the city

Early studies often pictured urban migrants as uprooted and marginal. Oscar Lewis's idea of a culture of poverty, introduced in Five Families (1959) and developed in La Vida (1966), held that poor families pass on fatalistic habits across generations; critics argued it blamed the poor for structural problems. Janice Perlman, in The Myth of Marginality (1976), found that residents of Rio de Janeiro's favelas were not marginal at all: they worked, voted, built houses and held strong hopes for their children. Her later restudy (2010) found many families had gained education and goods but still faced violence and stigma. Moving also changes daily life: households shrink, diets change and children often shift to the national language.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, calling any small farmer a peasant: the term means cultivators inside a state who hand over part of their produce. Second, assuming peasants are isolated or ignorant of markets; they are often keenly aware of prices they cannot control. Third, reading Tepoztlán as a case of one researcher lying; the contrast shows how questions shape findings. Fourth, treating rural-urban migration as a clean break, when many households live across village and city. Fifth, comparing urban percentages without checking the definition. Sixth, assuming urban newcomers are marginal, a view Perlman's favela research challenged.

Key takeaways

Peasants are small cultivators within states who pay a fund of rent (Wolf, 1966). Redfield (1956) saw peasant communities as part-societies, contrasting little and great traditions; his Tepoztlán portrait (1930) clashed with Lewis's restudy (1951). Wolf distinguished closed corporate from open communities. Chayanov's household balance and Scott's safety-first moral economy explain peasant choices; the Zapatista rising of 1994 shows market fears turning to protest. Migration often links village and city. In 2025 about 45% of people lived in cities, 36% in towns and 19% in rural areas, but national definitions count only 58% as urban. Perlman found favela residents far from marginal.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Peasant

Small cultivator within a state who hands over part of the produce

Rent, taxes, tribute or low prices.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

What most clearly distinguishes peasants from farmers in Eric Wolf's account?

Question 2 of 5

Redfield and Lewis gave very different portraits of Tepoztlán. What lesson do anthropologists usually draw?

Question 3 of 5

In many Mesoamerican closed corporate communities, what does the cargo system do?

Question 4 of 5

By the UN's 2025 Degree of Urbanisation, cities and towns together hold 81% of 8.2 billion people, while national definitions count 58% as urban. About how many people fall in the gap?

Question 5 of 5

What did Janice Perlman's research in Rio de Janeiro's favelas show?

← Previous topicNext topic →