Anthropology › Section F · Language and communication › Topic F.1
The emergence and development of language
Every human society has language, and any healthy baby can learn any of the world's roughly 7,000 languages. How did this capacity arise, what makes it different from animal communication, and how do children master it so quickly?
Born ready for any language
A baby born in Lagos, Lima or Lahore could grow up speaking Yoruba, Quechua, Urdu or Japanese, depending only on the people around it. Without formal lessons, toddlers absorb thousands of words and complex grammatical rules simply by hearing or seeing language used. Language is the main channel through which culture is passed on, and linguistic anthropology studies it as part of social life. Linguists analyse every language at several levels: phonology, its system of phonemes, sounds that tell words apart, as p and b do in pat and bat; morphology, how words are built from morphemes, the smallest meaningful units, as in un-break-able; syntax, how words form sentences; semantics, meaning; and pragmatics, how context shapes meaning in use.
Communication versus language
Communication is any transfer of information from a sender to a receiver, and all animals do it. Language is a special kind: a system of words or signs that combine by rules into sentences able to express an unlimited range of meanings. The linguist Charles Hockett listed design features of human language in about 1960. They include productivity, creating endless new sentences; displacement, talking about things absent, past, future or imaginary; arbitrariness, no natural link between most words and their meanings; duality of patterning, meaningless sounds combining into meaningful units; and cultural transmission, being learned rather than inherited.
Animals and apes
Animal communication can be remarkable. The honeybee's waggle dance, decoded by Karl von Frisch, shows hive-mates the direction and distance of food. In Kenya around 1980, Robert Seyfarth and Dorothy Cheney found that vervet monkeys give different alarm calls for leopards, eagles and snakes, and listeners respond to each appropriately. Yet these systems are closed: a bee cannot dance about yesterday's weather. Apes raised by humans, such as the gorilla Koko and the bonobo Kanzi, learned hundreds of signs or symbols, but they combined them only in short strings, and some researchers dispute claims about their abilities. Such skills may resemble a protolanguage, a simple precursor to language.
The body behind speech
Humans have a lowered larynx and a rounded tongue that allow a wide range of speech sounds, plus fine control of breathing. The hyoid, a small throat bone that anchors the tongue, is modern in shape in Neanderthals and in fossils from Sima de los Huesos in Spain dated to about 430,000 years ago. In the brain, Broca's area, linked to speech production, and Wernicke's area, linked to comprehension, usually sit in the left hemisphere. The gene FOXP2, identified in a London family with an inherited speech disorder around 2001, affects fine control of the mouth. Neanderthals shared the human version, and researchers agree no single gene creates language.
Tools, gestures and symbols
Speech leaves no fossils, so researchers combine indirect clues. Making stone tools, which began at least 2.6 million years ago with the Oldowan industry, requires planning a sequence of steps and learning by imitation. The neuroscientist Michael Arbib proposed that imitation and gesture came first and that speech grew out of them, though this gesture-first idea is debated. Symbolic objects offer later evidence: pieces of ochre engraved with cross-hatched lines at Blombos Cave in South Africa date to about 75,000 to 100,000 years ago. Estimates for fully modern language range widely, from about 50,000 to more than 200,000 years ago.
How children acquire language
Children worldwide follow a similar path. Babies babble at around six months, say first words at about one year, combine two words by about two, and use complex sentences by about four. Learning is easiest early in life, a sensitive period. Noam Chomsky argued from the 1960s that humans have an innate universal grammar, which would explain how children learn so much from limited input. Other researchers, such as Michael Tomasello, argue that general learning abilities and social interaction explain acquisition without a special grammar module. Being bilingual or multilingual from childhood is normal in much of the world.
Sign languages
Sign languages, such as American Sign Language and British Sign Language, are full natural languages with their own grammars, not gestures or codes for spoken English; ASL and BSL are not even mutually intelligible. Nicaraguan Sign Language offers rare evidence of how a language is born. When new schools in Managua brought deaf children together in the late 1970s and 1980s, they built a shared signing system, and younger children who learned it made it more regular and complex. Researchers such as Ann Senghas have shown that each new group of child learners added grammatical structure.
Worked example: a brand-new sentence
Analyse the sentence "Next winter my cousin's tortoise will learn to play the trumpet." 1. Productivity: it has almost certainly never been said before, yet any fluent English speaker understands it. 2. Displacement: it refers to a future time and an imaginary event. 3. Arbitrariness: nothing in the sound of "tortoise" resembles a tortoise. 4. Duality of patterning: meaningless sounds such as t, or and s build the meaningful word. 5. Structure: swap "cousin's tortoise" to "tortoise's cousin" and the meaning changes. 6. Check: no known animal system can do all of these together.
Worked example: weighing the evidence
Ask what each clue can and cannot show about language origins. 1. A modern-shaped Neanderthal hyoid: the anatomy for speech sounds existed, but anatomy does not prove language was used. 2. The shared FOXP2 variant: Neanderthals had one ingredient linked to speech control, not proof of full grammar. 3. Engraved ochre at Blombos: people made symbols, suggesting the symbolic thinking language needs. 4. Oldowan tools: planning and imitation existed early, but tools could be taught by demonstration alone. 5. Check: each clue is indirect, which is why estimates span more than 150,000 years.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, treating all animal communication as language: language is open-ended and rule-governed. Second, calling FOXP2 "the language gene": many genes are involved. Third, thinking sign languages are just gestures or spoken English on the hands. Fourth, believing some languages are primitive: every language studied is fully complex. Fifth, presenting the date of language's origin as settled, when evidence is indirect and estimates range widely.
Key takeaways
Language is a rule-based system of words or signs that can express unlimited meanings; communication is broader. Hockett's design features include productivity, displacement, arbitrariness, duality of patterning and cultural transmission. Bee dances and vervet calls are sophisticated but closed; trained apes show protolanguage-like skills. Evidence for origins comes from anatomy, brain, genes such as FOXP2, tools and symbols such as Blombos ochre. Children acquire language rapidly in a sensitive period; Chomsky's universal grammar is debated. Sign languages are full languages, as Nicaraguan Sign Language shows.
Flashcards
Flashcard
A sound that tells words apart; the smallest unit of meaning
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
A friend describes a dream she had last week about a city on the moon. Which design feature of language makes this possible?
Question 2 of 5
Why is the honeybee's waggle dance not considered language?
Question 3 of 5
What is the best conclusion about the gene FOXP2?
Question 4 of 5
What does the emergence of Nicaraguan Sign Language show?
Question 5 of 5
Engraved ochre from Blombos Cave dates to about 75,000 to 100,000 years ago. What can it most reasonably show?
