Anthropology › Section O · Anthropology of media › Topic O.3
Visual anthropology and ethnographic film
Cameras let anthropologists record, slow down and share what they see in the field. They also raise hard questions: who is filmed, who frames the story, and who decides what audiences will believe they have seen?
Cameras in early fieldwork
Anthropologists picked up cameras almost as soon as portable ones existed. The British anthropologist Alfred Cort Haddon shot some of the earliest ethnographic film footage during the 1898 expedition to the Torres Strait. Margaret Mead took photographs during her first fieldwork in Samoa in the mid-1920s. In Bali and New Guinea in the late 1930s, Mead and Gregory Bateson made visual records central to research, taking tens of thousands of photographs and many thousands of feet of film. They studied childhood, ceremonies and dance, and published the photographic study Balinese Character in 1942, followed by a series of short films.
What visual anthropology is
Visual anthropology is the use of visual media as a research method, or the study of visual media as a research topic. Most fieldworkers take photographs, but visual anthropologists go further. A photograph freezes a moment for careful, shared analysis. Film can be slowed down, replayed or sped up to reveal gestures, timing and group dynamics that the eye misses. Images can be enlarged to show detail or set next to each other to compare. Visual anthropologists also study the images people make for themselves: family photographs, paintings, billboards, graffiti, local television and films.
Trance and Dance in Bali
One of the best-known early films is Trance and Dance in Bali, filmed by Bateson and written and narrated by Mead, released in the early 1950s. It shows a Balinese dance drama in which the witch figure Rangda confronts the Barong, a protective creature, and entranced performers turn their kris daggers against their own chests without harm before being revived with holy water and incense. Most of the footage came from a single performance in December 1937 that the anthropologists commissioned and had staged in daylight for the camera. The film was added to the US National Film Registry in 1999. Even scientific film, then, involved arrangement and choice.
Ethnographic film
Ethnographic film is film used within anthropology: as a way of doing research, as a record of events, or as a way of presenting findings. Like documentary, it is non-fiction: real footage is edited into a structured account, which already involves choices about what to show and in what order. The boundary between documentary and ethnographic film is blurred. Ethnographic films are usually linked to professional anthropologists, are grounded in long-term fieldwork, and focus explicitly on social and cultural processes rather than on spectacle.
Nanook of the North
Outside the discipline, the explorer Robert Flaherty released Nanook of the North (1922), filmed with Inuit in northern Quebec in about 1920 to 1921. It follows a family through hunting, kayaking, travelling by dog sled and building an igloo. Audiences admired its portrait of courageous, skilled people, and it is often called the first feature-length documentary. Critics later showed how much was staged. Nanook was played by a man named Allakariallak; the women cast as his family were reportedly not his own; Flaherty asked hunters to use harpoons rather than the rifles they already used; and an igloo was cut open so the camera had light.
Worked example: weighing Nanook as evidence
Can Nanook of the North serve as evidence of Inuit life? 1. Source: a film by an outside explorer, released in 1922 for paying audiences. 2. Purpose: Flaherty wanted a dramatic story of survival, not a record of everyday life as it was. 3. Staging: rifles were replaced by harpoons and family roles were cast, which made the community look further from contact with traders than it was. 4. Value: it still records real skills, landscapes and Inuit cooperation. 5. Comparison: Atanarjuat: The Fast Runner (2001), directed by the Inuk film-maker Zacharias Kunuk in Inuktitut, tells an Inuit story on Inuit terms. 6. Conclusion: Nanook is good evidence of its makers' vision, and only partial evidence of Inuit life.
Observation and synchronous sound
From the 1950s, some film-makers sought a more observational style that avoided invented drama. John Marshall began filming Ju/'hoansi communities of the Kalahari in the 1950s; his The Hunters (1957) was later criticised, including by Marshall himself, for romanticising them, and his later N!ai, the Story of a !Kung Woman (1980) showed their dispossession. Portable equipment that recorded sound in sync with picture spread in the 1960s, so people on screen could speak for themselves, usually with subtitles. Timothy Asch and Napoleon Chagnon's The Ax Fight (1975) shows raw footage of a Yanomami village dispute, then admits that the film-makers' first explanation was wrong. Chagnon's wider portrayal of the Yanomami remains strongly contested.
Ethics and shared anthropology
From the 1960s, anthropologists increasingly questioned the power dynamics of film: mostly white Western researchers deciding how non-Western peoples would be seen. The French film-maker and anthropologist Jean Rouch called for a shared anthropology, screening footage to the people filmed and inviting their responses; Chronicle of a Summer (1961), made with Edgar Morin, put that conversation on screen. Robert Gardner's Dead Birds (1963), about Dani people in New Guinea, was praised for its images but criticised for a narrator who claimed to voice people's thoughts. David and Judith MacDougall developed participatory approaches in which subjects shape the film and the relationship with the film-maker becomes visible.
Worked example: planning an ethical film
A student plans a short film about a community's annual harvest festival. 1. Consent: explain the project and who will see it, and gain permission from organisers and from each person filmed close up. 2. Limits: ask whether any rites, places or objects must not be filmed, and respect the answer. 3. Collaboration: invite community members to suggest scenes and to speak in their own words. 4. Review: screen a rough cut to participants and correct errors or remove footage they object to. 5. Credit and access: name contributors who wish to be named and give the community copies. 6. Check: these steps follow Rouch's idea that the people filmed are partners, not merely subjects.
Experimental and sensory film
Some recent work treats film less as a lecture and more as an experience. Harvard University's Sensory Ethnography Lab, founded in 2006, encourages films that immerse viewers in sound, texture and time. Manakamana (2013), directed by Stephanie Spray and Pacho Velez, consists of 11 long, unbroken shots of pilgrims and others riding a cable car to a hilltop temple in Nepal. There is no narrator; viewers simply watch faces, talk and the passing landscape. Supporters praise such films for respecting complexity; critics argue that without explanation, viewers may project their own assumptions.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, assuming film is a neutral copy of reality: every shot, edit and narration is a choice. Second, treating staged scenes as fake and therefore worthless; staged films still record skills, places and the makers' views. Third, treating early films such as Nanook as straightforward records of Indigenous life. Fourth, ignoring who controls a film's production and meaning. Fifth, assuming that ethics ends with permission to film; review, credit and access matter too.
Key takeaways
Visual anthropology uses images as a method and studies them as a topic, from Haddon's footage (1898) and Mead and Bateson's work in Bali (late 1930s). Trance and Dance in Bali (early 1950s) drew on a performance commissioned for the camera. Ethnographic film is non-fiction grounded in fieldwork. Nanook of the North (1922) was admired but partly staged, while Atanarjuat (2001) shows Inuit telling their own stories. Observational films and synchronous sound let people speak, and Rouch's shared anthropology and participatory film answered ethical critiques. Sensory films such as Manakamana (2013) offer experience rather than explanation.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Visual media used as a research method or studied as a topic
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Which statement best describes how Trance and Dance in Bali was made?
Question 2 of 5
Which criticism of Nanook of the North is accurate?
Question 3 of 5
What did the spread of synchronous sound in the 1960s change in ethnographic film?
Question 4 of 5
What did Jean Rouch mean by shared anthropology?
Question 5 of 5
A student films a festival, gains consent and then screens a rough cut to participants. Why is the screening an important step?
