Anthropology › Section O · Anthropology of media › Topic O.4

Photography, representation, and memory

A photograph seems simply to show what was there. Anthropologists ask who took it, for whom, and why, because photographs shape how people see others, how they present themselves, and what they remember.

Pictures that teach ways of seeing

Besides making their own images, visual anthropologists study how people use photographs to represent themselves and others. A picture records a moment, but it is also selected, framed and captioned, and it reaches viewers through magazines, albums, archives or social media. Each step shapes its meaning. A portrait made for a family album, a police file, a missionary fundraising leaflet or a fashion feed may show the same face and still tell very different stories. Anthropologists therefore study three things together: the people who make images, the images themselves, and the people who look at them.

Reading National Geographic

National Geographic, founded in 1888, long served many American families as a window on the world. The anthropologist Catherine Lutz and the sociologist Jane Collins studied it holistically in Reading National Geographic (1993). They researched how editors and photographers worked, analysed the content of about 600 photographs of non-Western peoples published between 1950 and 1986, and interviewed readers about how they understood them. The photographs mostly showed people as exotic, idealised, happy and close to nature, with few traces of colonial history, poverty, war or national politics. A message of common humanity sat beside an implied ladder, with the viewer placed higher, as if 'they' had not yet become modern.

A magazine looks back

The critique eventually reached the magazine itself. In 2018 its then editor, Susan Goldberg, published an issue on race and acknowledged that the magazine's coverage over many decades had been racist. She had asked the historian John Edwin Mason to review its archive. He found that for long periods people of colour in the United States were largely ignored, while people abroad were often shown as exotic, frequently unclothed and in picturesque settings, rarely as workers, professionals or citizens. Scholarly critique had changed how the image-makers saw their own work.

The gaze

In the 1970s, film theorists developed the concept of the gaze: a way of looking at images of people that is shaped by the identities of viewer and viewed. Two features matter most. First, the gaze is voyeuristic: the people looked at are not aware of, or cannot respond to, the person looking. Second, it carries power: the viewer can scrutinise, judge and use the image for knowledge, pleasure or criticism, while the people pictured have no say. Anthropologists use the idea to ask whose way of looking an image invites, and who is placed on the other side of the lens.

The male gaze and its critics

The British film theorist Laura Mulvey, in her essay Visual Pleasure and Narrative Cinema (1975), argued that mainstream Hollywood film is built around a male gaze: the camera invites viewers to look at women as objects of desire, from the point of view of male characters. Scholars extended the idea to advertising and beauty culture, arguing that many women learn to see their own bodies through others' judging eyes. Others refined it. The writer and scholar bell hooks, in Black Looks (1992), described an oppositional gaze, the critical looking back of Black women viewers, showing that audiences are not only objects but also active, resistant viewers.

The imperial gaze

Photography spread after its public announcement in 1839, just as European powers were extending colonial rule across Africa, Asia and the Pacific. Scholars use the term imperial gaze for the conventions by which colonising societies viewed colonised peoples and lands. Surveys, maps and documentary photographs presented territories as open for rule and their inhabitants as specimens or curiosities. Some nineteenth-century scientists photographed people against measuring grids to classify supposed racial types, work now recognised as scientifically wrong and deeply harmful. Lutz and Collins argued that echoes of this gaze persisted in late twentieth-century magazine photography.

Worked example: missionary photographs

The historian Paul Jenkins (1993), who worked with the Basel Mission's photographic archive, examined images taken by Swiss and German missionaries in the Gold Coast, now Ghana, in the later nineteenth century. 1. Image: portraits of African children in European clothes, taken in the 1860s by the missionary Christian Hornberger. 2. Purpose: such photographs were sold to European supporters to raise money. 3. Backstory: according to Jenkins, many of these children had been enslaved or pawned for debts; European supporters paid for a particular child's release and upkeep, and the child received a Christian name. 4. Experience: many were unhappy on the mission station, some ran back to their communities, and the scheme was soon dropped. 5. Conclusion: the photographs cast missionaries as rescuers, while hiding how the children themselves experienced the arrangement.

Studio portraits and self-fashioning

Postcolonial photographers and their clients created their own ways of looking. In Bamako, Mali, Seydou Keïta's studio portraits from the late 1940s to the early 1960s showed sitters in fine clothes, with props such as scooters and radios, posed as they wished to be seen. The anthropologist Liam Buckley (2000) studied studio photography in the Gambia. Older portraits valued jikko, a faithful likeness of a person's character. From about the 1970s, many young people preferred painted backdrops of airports, appliances and travel, with props such as sunglasses and pens, to express jamano, fashionable novelty. Photographs became tools for imagining and announcing a desired, modern self.

Photographs and memory

Photographs also shape memory. Family albums select which moments are kept, and in many communities, such as in Ghana, portraits of the deceased are displayed prominently at funerals and on posters. The scholar Marianne Hirsch (1997) used the term postmemory for the way children of survivors of traumatic events, such as the Holocaust, come to 'remember' them through family photographs and stories rather than direct experience. Archives decide what is kept and shown, so collections built by colonial officials, missionaries and anthropologists often hold images that the communities pictured have never seen.

Worked example: returning photographs

A museum holds early twentieth-century photographs of an Aboriginal community in Australia and wants to share them. 1. Recognise protocols: in many Aboriginal communities, images of people who have died should not be shown freely, and some ceremonial images are restricted by gender or status. 2. Consult: work with community members to identify people, places and restrictions. 3. Choose a tool: the Mukurtu platform, developed from about 2007 with the Warumungu community, lets communities set who may view each item. 4. Add knowledge: record names and stories the community supplies, correcting old captions. 5. Conclusion: returning photographs turns colonial records into community memory, with control over access restored to the people pictured and their descendants.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, treating a photograph as a neutral, complete record: selection, framing, captions and purpose all shape meaning. Second, reading the gaze as simply looking: it involves power over people who cannot look back. Third, assuming the people photographed are always passive; studio clients and critical viewers create and contest images too. Fourth, forgetting the backstory, as with mission portraits that hid children's own experiences. Fifth, assuming old images can be shared freely, when communities may have protocols about who may see them.

Key takeaways

Photographs are made, selected and viewed in social contexts. Lutz and Collins (1993) showed National Geographic presenting non-Western peoples as exotic and outside history, and in 2018 the magazine acknowledged its racist past coverage. The gaze is voyeuristic and carries power; Mulvey (1975) described the male gaze, and hooks (1992) the oppositional gaze. The imperial gaze framed colonised peoples, as mission photographs in the Gold Coast show. Studio portraits, from Keïta in Mali to the Gambian backdrops Buckley studied, express self-fashioning. Photographs shape memory, including postmemory, and returning archives with community protocols restores control.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Reading National Geographic

Lutz and Collins's 1993 study of the magazine's images

Production, content analysis and reader interviews.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

What did Lutz and Collins find about how National Geographic photographed non-Western peoples between 1950 and 1986?

Question 2 of 5

Which pair names the two key features of the gaze described in this topic?

Question 3 of 5

According to Paul Jenkins, why are the Basel Mission portraits of children in European clothes misleading on their own?

Question 4 of 5

In Liam Buckley's study of Gambian studio photography, what did young people express with backdrops of airports and appliances?

Question 5 of 5

A museum wants to put old photographs of an Aboriginal community online. What should it do first?

← Previous topicNext topic →