Anthropology › Section Q · Medical anthropology › Topic Q.2

Ethnomedicine

Every society has a body of knowledge about why people fall ill and how to restore them, from Ayurvedic physicians and Andean curanderos to hospital specialists. Ethnomedicine compares these systems on equal terms as cultural systems. This topic describes how healing systems work; it is not advice about any treatment.

Every society has a medicine

Ethnomedicine is a society's knowledge and practice for understanding, preventing and treating illness: its ideas about the body, its theories of what causes sickness, its healers and its remedies. The term once meant only non-Western traditions, but anthropologists now apply it to every system, including biomedicine, the science-based medicine of hospitals and clinics. Studying a system as ethnomedicine means asking how it makes sense to its users, how healers are trained and trusted, and how people choose between options. It does not mean endorsing or rejecting any particular remedy.

Personalistic and naturalistic causes

In a 1976 article, George Foster proposed a widely used way to compare theories of disease cause. In personalistic systems, illness results from the deliberate action of an agent: a spirit, an ancestor, a witch or a sorcerer, so healing often involves discovering who is responsible and why, perhaps through divination. In naturalistic systems, illness results from impersonal forces, such as an imbalance of bodily elements, exposure to cold or damp, or, in biomedicine, germs and faulty genes. Most real systems mix both, and a single illness can be explained naturalistically at one level and personalistically at another.

Balance and the humours

Many naturalistic systems understand health as balance. Greek medicine, from the Hippocratic writers to Galen, taught that health depends on balancing four humours: blood, phlegm, yellow bile and black bile. Ayurveda, developed in South Asia over more than two thousand years, describes three doshas, vata, pitta and kapha, whose balance shapes health and temperament. Classical Chinese medicine speaks of the flow of qi and the balance of yin and yang. In much of Latin America, many people classify foods, illnesses and remedies as hot or cold and seek to restore balance; scholars debate how much this comes from Spanish humoral medicine and how much from Indigenous ideas.

Worked example: classifying explanations

Use Foster's categories on four explanations. 1. A fever is blamed on an angry ancestor whose ceremonies were neglected: personalistic, because an agent acted on purpose. 2. Stomach pain is blamed on eating too many cold foods: naturalistic, because an impersonal imbalance is the cause. 3. A cough is blamed on a virus: naturalistic, the biomedical version. 4. A family accepts that a virus caused a death but asks a diviner why it struck their son: both, since the virus explains how and the diviner addresses why. 5. Lesson: the categories describe logic, not accuracy, and case 4 shows systems combining.

Healers and their training

Healers are specialists recognised by their communities, and they usually undergo long training or apprenticeship. They include herbalists, bonesetters, midwives, diviners and religious healers. Shamans, a term from the Evenki language of Siberia, are healers believed to travel to or communicate with the spirit world on behalf of patients; many describe being called to the role through their own serious illness. Curanderos and curanderas in Mexico and Central America may combine herbs, prayer and massage. Biomedical doctors, too, pass through a demanding training that teaches values and identity as well as facts.

The effectiveness of symbols

Healing works partly through meaning. In a 1949 essay, The Effectiveness of Symbols, Claude Lévi-Strauss analysed a long song used by a Guna (Kuna) healer of Panama during a difficult childbirth. The song describes a journey through the woman's body to recover her lost soul from a spirit. Lévi-Strauss argued that by giving the woman a language for her pain, the song could help her body respond. His analysis rested on a recorded text rather than observed births, and later scholars have questioned it, but it opened the study of symbolic healing, which links to modern research on placebo effects.

Biomedicine as a cultural system

Biomedicine draws on biology and chemistry and tests treatments in controlled clinical trials. Anthropologists study it as an ethnomedicine because it also carries cultural assumptions: that the body works like a machine with separate parts, that specialists should treat organs, that individuals rather than families make decisions, and that hospitals have their own rules and rituals. Seeing biomedicine as cultural does not deny that its treatments are tested and often highly effective. It means noticing how its values shape care, and how bias, such as racism or sexism, can enter clinical judgements.

Medical pluralism

Medical pluralism is the presence of several healing systems in one society, which people often combine. In Patients and Healers in the Context of Culture (1980), based on research in Taiwan, Arthur Kleinman described three sectors: the popular sector of self-care, family and friends, where most illness is first handled; the folk sector of non-professional specialists such as diviners; and the professional sector of organised, licensed medicine, which in Taiwan included both biomedicine and Chinese medicine. Patients often move between sectors in order, a pattern Lola Romanucci-Ross (1969) called a hierarchy of resort. Pluralism can also be unequal: colonial governments often suppressed Indigenous healing, as Juliet McMullin (2010) documented for Native Hawaiian health.

Plants, knowledge and fairness

Ethnopharmacology studies the use of plants and other substances in healing. Willow bark was used against pain in several traditions; it contains salicin, and in 1897 Felix Hoffmann at Bayer produced acetylsalicylic acid, sold as aspirin. The Chinese scientist Tu Youyou, guided by a fourth-century text by Ge Hong, helped isolate artemisinin from sweet wormwood, a malaria drug that earned her a share of the 2015 Nobel Prize. Such cases raise questions of fairness: the 2010 Nagoya Protocol requires that communities share in benefits from their knowledge. When the WHO opened its Global Centre for Traditional Medicine in 2022, it noted that 170 of its 194 member states had reported traditional medicine use.

Worked example: two systems, one child

Analyse Anne Fadiman's The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down (1997). 1. Case: Lia Lee, daughter of Hmong refugees in Merced, California, had severe seizures from infancy in the 1980s. 2. Two models: doctors diagnosed epilepsy; her family called it qaug dab peg, the spirit catches you and you fall down, linked to soul loss and, for some Hmong, to a gift for becoming a healer. 3. Conflict: complex medicine schedules, language barriers and mistrust led parents to adjust doses, and doctors to involve child protection. 4. Outcome: both sides cared deeply, but neither understood the other's logic. 5. Lesson: pluralism without communication can harm the patient both systems aim to help.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, using ethnomedicine to mean only traditional or non-Western medicine; biomedicine is an ethnomedicine too. Second, assuming personalistic explanations show ignorance of physical causes; many people use both kinds of explanation. Third, treating hot-cold or humoral systems as identical everywhere. Fourth, assuming that calling biomedicine cultural means denying that its treatments work. Fifth, treating medical pluralism as a free market of equal options, ignoring colonial suppression and unequal power. Sixth, reading descriptions of remedies as recommendations to use them.

Key takeaways

Ethnomedicine is any society's system for explaining and treating illness, biomedicine included. Foster (1976) contrasted personalistic causes, agents such as spirits or witches, with naturalistic ones, impersonal forces such as humoral imbalance or germs. Humoral ideas appear in Greek medicine, Ayurveda, Chinese medicine and Latin American hot-cold systems. Healers train long, and Lévi-Strauss's essay on a Guna healing song opened the study of symbolic healing. Kleinman's popular, folk and professional sectors describe medical pluralism, which can be unequal. Aspirin and artemisinin show plant knowledge entering biomedicine, and Fadiman shows systems clashing over one child.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Ethnomedicine

A society's knowledge and practice for explaining, preventing and treating illness

Includes biomedicine.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A family accepts that a virus caused their son's death but consults a diviner to learn why it struck him. How does Foster's scheme classify this?

Question 2 of 5

Why do anthropologists call biomedicine an ethnomedicine?

Question 3 of 5

In Kleinman's model, where is most illness first handled?

Question 4 of 5

What does the history of artemisinin illustrate?

Question 5 of 5

What is the main lesson anthropologists draw from the case of Lia Lee?

← Previous topicNext topic →