Anthropology › Section Q · Medical anthropology › Topic Q.1

What is medical anthropology?

Everyone gets sick, but what sickness means, who is blamed, who heals and what counts as getting better differ from place to place. Medical anthropology studies health, illness and healing as products of biology, culture and power together. It describes healing systems; it does not recommend treatments.

Health between biology and culture

Medical anthropology is the study of how health, illness and healing are shaped by biology, culture, society and history, in every society, including those where hospital medicine dominates. Its researchers might study a herbalist in the Andes, an emergency ward in Boston, a vaccine campaign in Nigeria or the bones of an ancient population. What unites them is the question of how human bodies and human meanings interact. The field describes and compares healing systems and the experience of sickness. It does not offer medical advice or judge which remedies a reader should use.

Defining health

The World Health Organization's constitution, adopted in 1946 and in force from 1948, defines health as "a state of complete physical, mental and social well-being and not merely the absence of disease or infirmity". The definition was ambitious in adding mental and social well-being, though critics note that complete well-being is a state few people ever reach. Anthropologists add that ideas of health vary. For many Diné (Navajo) people, health is closely tied to hózhó, often translated as beauty, harmony and balance with others and the world. Knowing how a community defines health is the first step in studying it.

Disease, illness and sickness

Medical anthropologists separate three ideas that everyday speech blurs. Disease is a biological abnormality in the body's structure or function, the kind a clinician can measure. Illness is the person's own experience of being unwell: pain, fear, disrupted routine and the meaning they give it; the psychiatrist and anthropologist Arthur Kleinman built much of his work, such as Patients and Healers in the Context of Culture (1980), on this distinction. Sickness is the social recognition that someone is unwell, with the rights and expectations that brings. The three often coincide, but they need not.

Worked example: when the three come apart

Classify each case. 1. A man feels fine, but a routine check finds high blood pressure: disease without illness, since nothing is yet experienced as wrong. 2. A woman has disabling pain, but tests find no abnormality and her employer doubts her: illness without recognised disease, and without full sickness status. 3. A student with a cold receives a doctor's note excusing her from an exam: disease, illness and sickness together, since the condition is biological, felt and socially recognised. 4. Lesson: studying only disease would miss the woman's suffering in case 2, and studying only experience would miss the man's condition in case 1.

Early roots: Rivers

Medical anthropology has deep roots. W. H. R. Rivers, a British physician and psychologist, joined the 1898 Cambridge expedition to the Torres Strait, between Australia and New Guinea, led by A. C. Haddon, where he tested islanders' vision and other senses and found no evidence for the racist claim that their perceptions were inferior. His lectures, published after his death as Medicine, Magic and Religion (1924), argued that Indigenous healing practices follow logically from local beliefs about what causes disease. Treatment, he suggested, makes sense once its theory of causation is understood.

Explaining misfortune: the Azande

E. E. Evans-Pritchard's Witchcraft, Oracles and Magic among the Azande (1937), based on fieldwork in central Africa in the late 1920s, became foundational for the study of illness and misfortune. His famous case, analysed in the topic on magic and other religious practices, concerned a granary that collapsed and injured people resting in its shade. Azande knew that termites had eaten the supports. Witchcraft explained something else: why the granary fell at that moment on those particular people. The distinction between how a misfortune happens and why it happens to me continues to shape studies of how people make sense of illness.

Bodies shaped by environment

Franz Boas helped lay the biological foundations. In a study published in 1912, he measured thousands of immigrants to New York and their children and reported that the head shape of children born in the United States differed from that of their parents, even within the same families. At a time when head shape was used to rank races, Boas argued that bodies respond to environment and nutrition. In 2002 Corey Sparks and Richard Jantz reanalysed his data and found the changes small; in 2003 Clarence Gravlee and colleagues replied that the data supported Boas. The debate itself shows how evidence on human biology is tested.

After 1945: a field takes shape

After the Second World War, international health programmes expanded through new bodies such as the WHO, and planners found that projects often failed when they ignored local beliefs and social life. Anthropologists were hired to help. Benjamin Paul's edited volume Health, Culture and Community (1955) collected case studies of such programmes. By the 1960s and 1970s medical anthropology had become a recognised subfield, and George Foster and Barbara Anderson's textbook Medical Anthropology (1978) helped define it. Today medical anthropologists work in universities, hospitals, public health agencies and charities.

Worked example: kuru and the four fields

Analyse kuru, a fatal brain disease among the Fore people of Papua New Guinea's highlands, holistically. 1. Cultural: in mourning feasts, the Fore honoured their dead by eating parts of the body, and women and children consumed the brain most often. 2. Fore explanation: many Fore attributed kuru to sorcery, as Shirley Lindenbaum documented in Kuru Sorcery (1979). 3. Biological: researchers, including Carleton Gajdusek, who shared a 1976 Nobel Prize, showed the disease was transmissible; it is now understood to be caused by prions. 4. Pattern: kuru struck women and children far more than men, matching who ate the brain. 5. Outcome: after mortuary feasting ended in the 1950s and 1960s, cases declined over the following decades.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, thinking medical anthropology studies only non-Western healing; biomedicine is studied too. Second, treating disease and illness as the same: one is a biological abnormality, the other a lived experience. Third, assuming the WHO definition settles what health means everywhere, when communities define it differently. Fourth, reading the Azande account as ignorance of physical causes; Azande knew termites caused the collapse. Fifth, explaining a case like kuru only biologically or only culturally, when both are needed. Sixth, mistaking descriptions of healing systems for treatment advice.

Key takeaways

Medical anthropology studies how biology, culture and power shape health, illness and healing everywhere. The WHO defines health as complete physical, mental and social well-being, but definitions vary, as with Diné ideas of hózhó. Disease is the biological abnormality, illness the lived experience and sickness the social recognition; Kleinman built on this distinction. Rivers showed healing follows theories of causation, and Evans-Pritchard separated how misfortune happens from why. Boas's 1912 immigrant study, still debated, linked bodies to environment. The field took shape after 1945, and kuru shows why its holism matters.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Medical anthropology

The study of how biology, culture, society and history shape health, illness and healing

Describes; does not prescribe.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A routine check finds that a man who feels perfectly well has high blood pressure. Which term fits his condition?

Question 2 of 5

In Evans-Pritchard's account, what did Azande witchcraft explain about the collapsed granary?

Question 3 of 5

What did W. H. R. Rivers argue in Medicine, Magic and Religion?

Question 4 of 5

Why is kuru a good example of medical anthropology's holistic approach?

Question 5 of 5

Which statement best describes the debate over Boas's 1912 immigrant study?

← Previous topicNext topic →