Anthropology › Section D · Evolution, primates, and early hominins › Topic D.4
Evolution in action, past and present
The idea that species change took centuries to win acceptance, and its history includes people textbooks long ignored. Evolution is not only ancient history, either: human populations, and the microbes around us, are still evolving today.
A fixed and ordered world
For much of European history, the dominant view was that species had been created in their present forms and never changed. Living things were ranked in a great chain of being, running from God and the angels through humans to animals, plants and minerals. The chain set humans apart from other animals and implied that every creature had a fixed place. Evolutionary theory had to overturn both ideas: that species are fixed, and that nature is a ladder. Anthropologists still meet the ladder image in popular pictures of evolution, and it is still wrong.
The seeds of change
From the seventeenth century, cracks appeared. Robert Hooke argued in the 1660s that fossils were the remains of once-living things and that Earth's surface had changed. Jean-Baptiste Lamarck, in 1809, proposed the first full theory of species change, driven by the inheritance of acquired characteristics: a giraffe stretching for leaves would pass a longer neck to its young. That mechanism is wrong, but Lamarck rightly linked change to the environment. Georges Cuvier proved that species go extinct, explaining it by catastrophes. Charles Lyell's Principles of Geology (1830 to 1833) argued that slow, ordinary processes shaped the land, which demanded an Earth far older than a few thousand years.
Darwin, Edmonstone and Wallace
As a medical student in Edinburgh in about 1826, Charles Darwin learned taxidermy from John Edmonstone, a formerly enslaved man from what is now Guyana who had gained his freedom and knew South American wildlife well. Those skills later let Darwin preserve specimens on the voyage of HMS Beagle (1831 to 1836), including the Galápagos birds. Reading Thomas Malthus's essay on population (1798), Darwin saw that more offspring are born than can survive. Alfred Russel Wallace, collecting in the Malay Archipelago, reached the same idea independently. Their papers were presented together in 1858, and Darwin's On the Origin of Species followed in 1859.
Natural selection and its misuse
Natural selection follows from a few observations: organisms produce more young than survive, individuals vary, much of that variation is inherited, and individuals with better-suited variants tend to leave more offspring. Over many generations, populations change. The phrase "survival of the fittest" was coined in 1864 by Herbert Spencer, not Darwin, though Darwin later adopted it. Spencer and others turned it into social Darwinism, the claim that some societies or races were more evolved than others, which was used to justify colonialism and scientific racism. Biologically, fitness means reproductive success in a particular environment, not strength or superiority.
Worked example: Lamarck or Darwin?
A village of fishers has, over many generations, become better at holding its breath underwater. Which explanation fits modern evolutionary theory? 1. Lamarck's version: each diver strengthens their lungs by training and passes the gain to their children. 2. Test it: changes acquired during a lifetime are not written into the DNA of eggs or sperm, so training alone cannot be inherited. 3. Darwin's version: divers already vary genetically; those with inherited advantages dive more safely and successfully, and leave more descendants. 4. Conclude: only inherited differences can respond to selection. Training still matters, but its effect stays with the individual.
The forces of evolution
Four forces change allele frequencies, as the Biology topic Population evolution: drift and gene flow explains. Mutation is the only source of new alleles. It is random with respect to need: a useful mutation does not appear because it is needed. Only mutations in the germ line, the cells that make eggs and sperm, are inherited; each newborn carries roughly 70 new ones, most with no effect. Natural selection favours variants that improve survival and reproduction. Genetic drift is chance change, strongest in small populations, such as the small bands of early humans. Gene flow moves alleles between populations when people or animals migrate and interbreed.
How new species form
Speciation, the origin of new species, usually starts when populations stop exchanging genes. In allopatric speciation, a geographic barrier such as a river, mountain range or sea separates them, and they diverge. In peripatric speciation, a small group splits off at the edge of a range, where drift acts strongly. In sympatric speciation, populations diverge without separation, for example through mate choice; some cichlid fish species in small African crater lakes are thought to have formed this way, though such cases are hard to prove. When one ancestor gives rise to many species quickly, filling different niches, the result is an adaptive radiation, like the hundreds of cichlid species of Africa's great lakes.
Gradual or punctuated?
How fast does evolution go? Gradualism holds that species change slowly and steadily. In 1972 the palaeontologists Niles Eldredge and Stephen Jay Gould proposed punctuated equilibrium: long periods of little change interrupted by bursts of rapid change, often at speciation. The fossil record shows examples of both patterns, and most researchers now see them as ends of a range rather than rivals. Either way, evolution branches. It produces a bush of related lineages, many extinct, not a single line climbing towards humans. Keep that bush in mind for the topic The earliest hominins.
Worked example: milk and human evolution
Most mammals, and most adults worldwide, lose the ability to digest lactose, the sugar in milk, after childhood. Some populations keep it, a trait called lactase persistence. Explain why. 1. Genetics: persistence is caused by variants near the lactase gene. 2. Pattern: it is common in parts of Europe and among some herding peoples of Africa and the Middle East. 3. Convergence: East African herders carry different variants from Europeans, so the trait evolved more than once. 4. Timing: ancient DNA shows the main European variant appearing only about 5,000 years ago and staying rare until about 3,000 years ago, thousands of years after dairying began. 5. Interpretation: a 2022 study led by Richard Evershed suggested that famine and disease made milk-drinking risky without the variant, strengthening selection. Culture created the pressure; selection did the rest.
Evolution you can watch
Some evolution happens fast enough to observe. Bacteria evolve resistance to antibiotics: a drug kills susceptible cells, and resistant ones, already present by chance, multiply. Mosquitoes have evolved resistance to insecticides used against malaria. Viruses evolve too: during the COVID-19 pandemic, new variants of SARS-CoV-2 that spread more easily or partly escaped immunity, such as Omicron in late 2021, quickly replaced earlier ones. In each case the environment, often one changed by humans, sets the pressure, and existing variation determines the response.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, crediting Darwin with "survival of the fittest": Spencer coined it. Second, treating fitness as strength or superiority: it means reproductive success in an environment. Third, thinking acquired traits are inherited. Fourth, believing mutations arise because they are needed: they arise at random and selection sorts them. Fifth, picturing evolution as a ladder towards humans: it is a branching bush. Sixth, assuming humans have stopped evolving: lactase persistence spread within the last few thousand years.
Key takeaways
Evolutionary thinking replaced fixed species and the great chain of being, building on Hooke, Lamarck, Cuvier and Lyell. Darwin, trained in taxidermy by John Edmonstone, and Wallace proposed natural selection in 1858; the Origin followed in 1859. Spencer coined "survival of the fittest", and social Darwinism misused it. Mutation, selection, drift and gene flow change allele frequencies. Species form by allopatric, peripatric or sympatric speciation, gradually or in bursts. Evolution is ongoing, from lactase persistence to antibiotic resistance and new virus variants.
Flashcards
Flashcard
A fixed ranking of all things, with humans above animals
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Who first used the phrase "survival of the fittest", and what does fitness mean in biology?
Question 2 of 5
A weightlifter builds large muscles. Why will this not make her children more muscular by evolution?
Question 3 of 5
Which force of evolution is the only source of new alleles?
Question 4 of 5
East African herders and many Europeans can digest milk as adults, but carry different genetic variants for this. What does that show?
Question 5 of 5
Which statement best describes the pattern of evolution according to current thinking?
