Anthropology › Section D · Evolution, primates, and early hominins › Topic D.5

What is a primate?

Humans belong to the order Primates, along with more than 500 other living species, from mouse lemurs to gorillas. Knowing what makes a primate, and how our relatives live, is the baseline against which anthropologists ask what is distinctive about being human.

Why study our relatives?

Primatology gives anthropology a comparison. If chimpanzees make tools, then toolmaking alone cannot define humanity; if some monkey groups pass on local habits, culture may have deep roots. Primates are also a test of evolutionary ideas, because closely related species living in different settings show how environment shapes bodies and behaviour. No single trait marks a primate. Instead, primates share a cluster of features that, taken together, separate them from other mammals, and humans have kept most of them in modified forms.

Hands, eyes and noses

Most primates have grasping hands and feet with five digits, and in many species an opposable thumb that can press against the fingertips; most nonhuman primates also have an opposable big toe. Flat nails replace claws on most digits, backed by sensitive fingertip pads. Vision is emphasised: the eyes face forward, so their fields overlap and give depth perception, and many species, including humans and other Old World primates, see in full colour. A bony bar, the postorbital bar, surrounds the outside of each eye socket. In exchange, the snout is generally shorter and the sense of smell less dominant than in most mammals.

Big brains and slow lives

Primates have large brains for their body size, and they live life slowly. Pregnancies are long, most species usually give birth to one infant at a time, and youngsters depend on adults for a long period of growth and learning. Adults live a long time and reproduce slowly. This slow pace goes with intense social lives: most primates live in groups where they recognise individuals, form alliances, and learn from one another. The combination of large brains, long childhoods and social learning is the platform on which human culture was later built.

Why primates evolved these traits

Three hypotheses compete. The arboreal hypothesis, proposed in the early twentieth century, says grasping hands and depth perception evolved for life in the trees. The anthropologist Matt Cartmill objected in the 1970s that squirrels climb well with claws and side-facing eyes, while cats and owls have forward-facing eyes for hunting. His visual predation hypothesis argues that early primates hunted insects among slender branches by sight. The angiosperm hypothesis, developed by Robert Sussman, links the traits to feeding on the fruits and flowers of flowering plants at the ends of branches. Elements of all three may be right.

Worked example: is it a primate?

Compare a squirrel with a slow loris, using the trait cluster. 1. Digits: the squirrel has claws; the loris has nails on most digits and a powerful grip. 2. Eyes: the squirrel's face the sides, giving wide but shallow vision; the loris's face forward, giving depth perception. 3. Eye socket: the loris has a bony postorbital bar. 4. Life history: the loris usually has one or two young after a long pregnancy for its size. 5. Conclude: the loris shows the primate cluster and the squirrel does not, even though both climb trees. Climbing alone does not make a primate.

Strepsirrhines and haplorhines

Living primates fall into two suborders. Strepsirrhines include the lemurs, found only on Madagascar, and the lorises and galagos of Africa and Asia. They have a moist nose, rely more on smell, and carry a toothcomb, front teeth in the lower jaw that project forward for grooming, plus a grooming claw on the second toe. Haplorhines include tarsiers, monkeys and apes; they have a dry nose and, unlike strepsirrhines, cannot make their own vitamin C. Tarsiers, small nocturnal hunters of Southeast Asia that eat only animal prey, were once grouped with lemurs, but DNA places them with the haplorhines.

Monkeys and apes

The anthropoids, monkeys and apes, form two groups. Platyrrhines, the monkeys of Central and South America, have flat noses with nostrils facing sideways and three premolars on each side of each jaw; some, such as spider monkeys, have a prehensile tail that can grip. Catarrhines live in Africa and Asia, with narrow, downward-facing nostrils and two premolars. They include the Old World monkeys, such as baboons, macaques and leaf-eating colobus monkeys, and the hominoids, or apes: gibbons, orangutans, gorillas, chimpanzees, bonobos and humans. Apes have no tail, flexible shoulders and relatively large brains.

Behaviour and culture

Long-term fieldwork transformed what is known of primate behaviour. Jane Goodall, studying chimpanzees at Gombe in Tanzania from 1960, saw them strip twigs to fish termites from mounds and hunt monkeys; Dian Fossey studied mountain gorillas and Biruté Galdikas orangutans. At Fongoli in Senegal, the primatologist Jill Pruetz reported in 2007 that savanna chimpanzees sharpen sticks to jab bush babies hiding in tree hollows, and that females and young chimpanzees do this often. In 1999 a team led by Andrew Whiten compared long-term sites and found dozens of behaviours, such as tool techniques and grooming styles, that differed between communities without ecological explanation. Many researchers call these traditions cultures.

Chimpanzees, bonobos and conservation

Chimpanzees and bonobos, both in the genus Pan, are equally close relatives of humans, sharing about 98 to 99% of directly comparable DNA with us, but live differently. Chimpanzee communities are dominated by males and sometimes wage lethal conflict with neighbours. Bonobos, found only south of the Congo River, form strong bonds among females and often defuse tension through sexual behaviour. The contrast warns against claims that any one ape shows "natural" human behaviour. Both are endangered. A 2017 review led by Alejandro Estrada estimated that about 60% of primate species are threatened with extinction, mainly by habitat loss, hunting and trade, and every great ape species except our own is listed as Endangered or Critically Endangered.

Worked example: a trait that changed jobs

Why do humans have forward-facing eyes and grasping hands? 1. Origin: these traits evolved in early primates living among branches, whether for leaping, catching insects or picking fruit. 2. Change: much later, hominins began walking upright, which freed the hands from locomotion. 3. New use: hands built for gripping branches could now carry, throw and shape stone tools, guided by eyes good at judging depth. 4. Name the process: a trait that evolved for one function and was later co-opted for another is an exaptation. 5. Lesson: evolution reuses what exists; it does not design features in advance for future needs.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, thinking one trait defines a primate: it is a cluster. Second, saying all primates have opposable thumbs or prehensile tails: some lack thumbs, and only some American monkeys have gripping tails. Third, calling apes monkeys: apes have no tail and are a separate group. Fourth, assuming humans descend from chimpanzees: we share a common ancestor. Fifth, treating chimpanzee aggression or bonobo peacefulness as proof of human nature. Sixth, grouping tarsiers with lemurs, which DNA does not support.

Key takeaways

Primates share a cluster of traits: grasping hands and feet, nails, forward-facing eyes with depth perception, a postorbital bar, reduced reliance on smell, large brains and slow, social lives. Arboreal, visual predation and angiosperm hypotheses try to explain them. Strepsirrhines (lemurs, lorises, galagos) differ from haplorhines (tarsiers, monkeys, apes). Platyrrhines live in the Americas; catarrhines, including Old World monkeys and apes, in Africa and Asia. Field studies reveal tool use and local traditions. About 60% of primate species are threatened, and all great apes besides humans are endangered.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Primate trait cluster

Grasping hands, nails, forward eyes, big brains, slow lives

No single trait defines a primate.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A small tree-living mammal has claws on every digit, eyes on the sides of its head and a long snout. Why is it probably not a primate?

Question 2 of 5

Which feature identifies a strepsirrhine primate rather than a haplorhine?

Question 3 of 5

A monkey in a Peruvian rainforest has sideways-facing nostrils and three premolars on each side of each jaw. What is it?

Question 4 of 5

Grasping hands first evolved for life among branches and were later used for making tools. What is this called?

Question 5 of 5

What do the contrasts between chimpanzee and bonobo societies suggest about human nature?

← Previous topicNext topic →