Anthropology › Section G · Economic anthropology › Topic G.6
Exchange, value, and consumption
Goods do not just move from producers to users; they carry relationships, obligations and meanings with them. Economic anthropology asks why a gift can bind people for life, why some things cannot be bought, and what people say about themselves through what they consume.
More than markets
The Microeconomics course explains how prices form in markets. Anthropologists ask a wider question: by what routes do goods move between people, and what do those routes do to relationships? Building on Karl Polanyi, introduced in Two ways to study economies, they usually distinguish reciprocity, the exchange of goods between people bound by social ties; redistribution, in which goods flow to a centre and are given out again; and market exchange, buying and selling at prices that respond to supply and demand. Every society uses more than one, and the mix usually matches its main mode of subsistence. Even in market societies, family life still runs largely on reciprocity.
Sahlins's spectrum of reciprocity
In Stone Age Economics (1972), Marshall Sahlins arranged reciprocity along a line of social distance. Generalised reciprocity is giving without counting or expecting a set return, as among close kin or within a foraging band; a parent feeding a child is the clearest case. Balanced reciprocity expects a return of roughly equal value within a reasonable time, as between neighbours, friends or trading partners, and failing to repay strains the relationship. Negative reciprocity tries to get something for nothing, or as much as possible for as little as possible, through hard bargaining, cheating or theft, and is usually reserved for strangers or enemies. The closer the relationship, the less people count.
Mauss and the gift
Marcel Mauss's The Gift (1925) argued that gifts are never simply free. Across many societies he found three linked obligations: to give, to receive and to return. Refusing a gift, or failing to repay it, insults the giver and breaks the relationship. Mauss drew on a Māori explanation, given by the scholar Tamati Ranapiri to the ethnographer Elsdon Best, of hau, often translated as the spirit of the gift, which seemed to make a gift want to return to its source; anthropologists still debate whether he interpreted it correctly. His central insight is widely accepted: a gift carries something of the giver, so exchanging gifts creates lasting social bonds and obligations, not just a transfer of things.
The kula ring
Bronisław Malinowski's Argonauts of the Western Pacific (1922) described the kula of the Trobriand Islands and neighbouring islands of Papua New Guinea. Men made long canoe voyages to give shell valuables to partners on other islands: red shell necklaces travelled clockwise around the ring of islands, and white armshells anticlockwise. The valuables were not kept for long; their worth lay in their histories and in the fame of those who passed them on. Ordinary trade, gimwali, was kept separate. Annette Weiner (1976) later showed that Malinowski had largely overlooked Trobriand women's own wealth, bundles of banana leaves exchanged at mortuary ceremonies.
Worked example: naming the exchange
Classify each transaction. 1. A grandmother pays for her grandson's school shoes and would be hurt if he tried to repay her. No accounts are kept within close kinship: generalised reciprocity. 2. Two neighbours take turns hosting each other's families for dinner, and one feels awkward after three invitations without returning one. A roughly equal return is expected: balanced reciprocity. 3. A tourist pays a street vendor three times the usual price for a fake designer bag. The seller gains at a stranger's expense: negative reciprocity. 4. A city collects property taxes and uses them to run public libraries. Goods flow to a centre and back out: redistribution. 5. Check: the type depends on the relationship, not on the object.
Redistribution and the potlatch
Redistribution concentrates goods in a central person or institution, which then gives them out. Chiefs who collect tribute and host feasts are classic examples, and taxation is the redistribution of modern states. Among Northwest Coast peoples such as the Kwakwaka'wakw, hosts at a potlatch marked births, marriages, deaths and the transfer of titles by giving away large quantities of goods, gaining status through generosity. Canada banned the potlatch in a law in force from 1885 until 1951, and US authorities also suppressed it, as part of efforts to assimilate Indigenous peoples. Communities kept the practice alive, often in secret, and potlatches are held openly today.
Spheres of exchange
Not everything can be swapped for everything else. Paul Bohannan, writing in the 1950s about the Tiv of central Nigeria, described three ranked spheres of exchange. Everyday goods, such as food and tools, were traded among themselves. A prestige sphere included cattle, brass rods and a special white cloth. The highest sphere concerned rights in people, especially in marriage. Exchanges within a sphere were ordinary; converting goods upward into a higher sphere was admired, and trading down was shameful. Such valuables worked as special-purpose money, valid only for certain exchanges, unlike general-purpose money such as dollars, which can buy almost anything. General-purpose money usually does three jobs: it is a means of payment, a common measure of value and a way of storing wealth.
Worked example: when money arrived
Bohannan argued that colonial rule changed Tiv exchange after general-purpose money spread. Trace the cause and effect. 1. Cause: the British colonial government required taxes in cash, so people had to sell goods for money. 2. Mechanism: money could buy goods in every sphere, so food sold at market could be turned into prestige goods or marriage payments. 3. Effect: the barriers between spheres weakened, and elders who had controlled prestige goods and marriages lost some authority to younger traders. 4. Evaluation: later scholars questioned how separate the spheres had ever been, but the case shows that money can reshape relationships, not only make trade easier.
The myth of barter
Economics textbooks often say money was invented to solve the inconvenience of barter. Anthropologists have found little evidence that whole economies ever ran on barter. Caroline Humphrey (1985) noted that no example of a barter economy has been described, and David Graeber's Debt: The First 5,000 Years (2011) argued that credit and debt, recorded in ancient Mesopotamian accounts, came long before coins. Barter usually happens between strangers, or when money fails, as in prisons or currency crises. Morality follows money too: Jonathan Parry and Maurice Bloch (1989) showed that many societies treat short-term trade for gain as acceptable only if it serves long-term social and moral order.
Value and consumption
Consumption is also communication. Mary Douglas and Baron Isherwood, in The World of Goods (1979), argued that people use goods to make social categories visible, as when a family serves a particular meal to mark a holiday. The sociologist Pierre Bourdieu, in Distinction (1979), showed that taste in food, music and furnishings marks and reproduces class. Viviana Zelizer (1994) found that people earmark money, treating a wage, a gift and a windfall as different kinds of money with different proper uses. Daniel Miller and others study shopping as a way people care for one another, not mere materialism.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, treating reciprocity as altruism: balanced reciprocity expects a return, and even generalised reciprocity builds obligations. Second, assuming gifts are free; Mauss showed they create duties to receive and return. Third, calling kula valuables trade goods; ordinary trade, gimwali, was separate. Fourth, assuming redistribution exists only in chiefdoms, when taxation is redistribution. Fifth, repeating the barter story as history. Sixth, confusing special-purpose money, valid for certain exchanges, with general-purpose money.
Key takeaways
Goods move by reciprocity, redistribution and market exchange, usually in combination. Sahlins's spectrum runs from generalised to balanced to negative reciprocity as social distance grows. Mauss's The Gift (1925) identified obligations to give, receive and return. The kula (Malinowski, 1922) circulated shell valuables; Weiner (1976) added women's wealth. Redistribution includes the potlatch, banned in Canada from 1885 to 1951, and taxation. Bohannan's Tiv spheres show special-purpose money and the effects of general-purpose money. Barter economies are largely a myth, and consumption communicates identity and class.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Exchange between people bound by social ties
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Two neighbours take turns hosting dinners, and one feels uneasy after accepting three invitations without returning one. Which type of exchange is this?
Question 2 of 5
According to Mauss's The Gift, which obligations does a gift create?
Question 3 of 5
In the kula ring described by Malinowski, how did the two kinds of shell valuable move?
Question 4 of 5
Among the Tiv, as described by Paul Bohannan, what happened after colonial taxes required cash?
Question 5 of 5
What have anthropologists concluded about the textbook story that money was invented to replace barter?
