Anthropology › Section G · Economic anthropology › Topic G.5

Horticulture and agriculture

Growing crops let people settle, store food and eventually build cities, but it also brought harder work, new diseases and new inequalities. Anthropologists separate two very different ways of cultivating plants and ask what each one does to social life.

Plants under human control

Plant cultivation means deliberately growing plants; domestication is the slower process by which repeated sowing and harvesting change a plant's genes, giving bigger seeds or fruit that stays on the stalk until harvested. Domestication happened independently in several regions. Archaeologists date wheat, barley and lentils in Southwest Asia to roughly 11,000 years ago, rice and millet in China to about 9,000 years ago, and squash and maize in Mesoamerica to roughly 9,000 to 10,000 years ago, with beans domesticated later. Other centres include New Guinea, the Andes, sub-Saharan Africa and eastern North America. Anthropologists divide cultivation into two strategies, extensive horticulture and intensive agriculture.

Horticulture: extensive cultivation

Horticulturalists grow crops with hand tools such as digging sticks and hoes, without ploughs or large-scale irrigation. Many practise shifting cultivation, also called swidden: they cut and burn the vegetation on a plot, using the ash as fertiliser, plant it for a few years, then leave it fallow while the forest regrows and the soil recovers. Several crops are often grown together, a practice called intercropping; the Maya milpa combines maize, beans and squash in one field. Because each family needs several plots at different stages, horticulture uses large areas lightly. It typically supports villages, often of a few dozen to a few hundred people, and much of the work is done by households.

The Hanunóo: rethinking slash and burn

Outsiders long condemned swidden as wasteful forest destruction. Harold Conklin's fieldwork among the Hanunóo of Mindoro, in the Philippines, in the 1950s showed something different. Hanunóo farmers chose plots carefully, burned them under controlled conditions, planted many crops and varieties together and named well over a thousand plant types with great precision. Their fields imitated the layered structure of the forest, and long fallows allowed it to return. Conklin's work became a classic of ethnoscience, the study of local systems of knowledge. Swidden is sustainable when fallows are long and population is low; it becomes damaging when land shortages force farmers to return to plots too soon.

Worked example: how much land does swidden need?

A family farms a 1-hectare plot for 2 years, then leaves it fallow for 12 years before clearing it again. How much land must it hold to keep one plot in use every year? 1. Cycle length: each plot is used and rested for 2 + 12 = 14 years. 2. Plots needed: the family must open a new plot every 2 years, so it needs 14 ÷ 2 = 7 plots. 3. Land: 7 plots × 1 hectare = 7 hectares, of which only 1 is in crops at any time. 4. Share in use: 2 ÷ 14, about 14% of the land. 5. Conclusion: if population growth shortens the fallow, the land requirement falls but soil and forest have less time to recover, which is how swidden can turn unsustainable.

Land rights and ritual

In many horticultural societies land is not bought and sold. A family or lineage holds usufruct, the right to use land and its produce without owning it outright, and leaders allocate plots to members and newcomers. Cultivation is often bound up with ritual. In Pigs for the Ancestors (1968), Roy Rappaport argued that among the Tsembaga Maring of Papua New Guinea, a ritual cycle that ended in a great pig festival, the kaiko, helped keep pig herds, warfare and land use in balance with the environment. Critics questioned whether such balance could be shown, but the study made ecological anthropology a major field.

Agriculture: intensive cultivation

Intensive agriculture farms the same fields year after year, using methods that add labour, energy and capital to each hectare: ploughs and draft animals, irrigation canals, terraces, manure and, later, chemical fertiliser. It produces much more food per hectare than horticulture, though often with more labour per unit of food. Larger and steadier surpluses can feed people who do not farm, so agricultural societies support craft specialists, traders, priests, soldiers and rulers, and often towns, cities and states. Farmers within states become peasants, defined by Eric Wolf (1966) as rural cultivators whose surpluses are transferred to a dominant group of rulers, through rent, taxes or tribute.

Bali: water temples and the Green Revolution

Stephen Lansing's study Priests and Programmers (1991) examined rice farming in Bali, Indonesia. Farmers belong to subak, irrigation associations, and a network of water temples schedules when each subak floods and plants its fields. In the 1970s, Green Revolution programmes encouraged continuous planting of new high-yield rice, ignoring the temple calendar. Pest outbreaks and water shortages followed. Lansing and the ecologist James Kremer built a computer model showing that the temple schedules balanced two needs: sharing water and leaving fields fallow at the same time so pests could not spread. The subak system is now part of a UNESCO World Heritage cultural landscape.

The costs of farming

Farming fed more people, but not always better. Skeletal studies, collected in Paleopathology at the Origins of Agriculture (1984), edited by Mark Cohen and George Armelagos, found that in many regions early farmers had more tooth decay, signs of childhood malnutrition and infectious disease than the foragers before them. Diets narrowed to a few starchy staples, crowded settlements spread infection, and stored surplus made inequality and raiding possible. Jared Diamond (1987) provocatively called agriculture the worst mistake in human history. Many archaeologists find that too sweeping: the effects varied by region, and farming populations grew because they could feed more children.

Worked example: who feeds the world?

A 2021 study by Sarah Lowder, Marco Sánchez and Raffaele Bertini counted more than 608 million farms worldwide. Farms under 2 hectares made up 84% of them, operated about 12% of farmland and produced about 35% of the world's food by value. Interpret this. 1. Output per share of land for small farms: 35 ÷ 12 is about 2.9. 2. For larger farms: they hold 88% of land and produce 65% of food, and 65 ÷ 88 is about 0.74. 3. Comparison: 2.9 ÷ 0.74 is about 3.9, so small farms produce roughly four times as much food value per hectare. 4. Caution: crops, land quality and data gaps differ. 5. Conclusion: most farms are small, and they farm land intensively, even though large farms hold most of the land.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, using agriculture for all plant cultivation: anthropologists reserve it for intensive farming with ploughs, irrigation and continuous use. Second, assuming horticulture is primitive or always destructive; with long fallows it can be sustainable, as Conklin showed. Third, confusing usufruct with ownership. Fourth, assuming farming improved health everywhere; early farmers were often less healthy than foragers. Fifth, thinking higher yield per hectare means less work; intensive farming usually demands more labour or inputs. Sixth, treating local ritual as irrational: in Bali, temple schedules solved real ecological problems that outside planners missed.

Key takeaways

Plants were domesticated independently in several regions, beginning in Southwest Asia roughly 11,000 years ago. Horticulture is extensive: hand tools, swidden, intercropping and fallow, using much land lightly; Conklin's Hanunóo work showed its sophistication. Land is often held as usufruct, and ritual can be tied to ecology, as Rappaport argued for the Tsembaga Maring. Agriculture is intensive: ploughs, irrigation and continuous use, producing surpluses that support specialists, cities, states and peasants. Lansing's Bali study shows local institutions managing ecology. Farming brought costs to health and equality, and today 84% of the world's farms are under 2 hectares.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Domestication

Genetic change in plants or animals through human selection over generations

Bigger seeds, non-shattering stalks.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Which description fits horticulture rather than intensive agriculture?

Question 2 of 5

A family farms each 1-hectare plot for 2 years and then leaves it fallow for 12 years. How many hectares must it hold to keep one plot in crops every year?

Question 3 of 5

What did Stephen Lansing's study of Balinese water temples show?

Question 4 of 5

What did skeletal studies collected by Cohen and Armelagos (1984) find about many early farmers?

Question 5 of 5

Small farms under 2 hectares produce about 35% of the world's food by value on about 12% of farmland. What does this suggest?

← Previous topicNext topic →