Anthropology › Section N · Anthropology of food › Topic N.3
Food and cultural identity
Few things say who we are as quickly as what we eat, refuse to eat and eat with whom. Anthropologists read food rules, feasts and lunchboxes as statements about nation, faith, class and gender, and they compare competing explanations for why those rules exist.
You are what you eat, socially
A cuisine is a group's shared way of choosing, preparing, combining and eating food. It works as a badge: people often define themselves by their dishes and define outsiders by strange or forbidden ones. Food can mark a nation, an ethnic group, a religion, a region, a class or a gender, often several at once. Because eating is repeated daily, it turns abstract belonging into a bodily habit. Anthropologists therefore treat food choices not as mere taste but as cultural identity, the ways people define themselves and distinguish themselves from others.
Rice as self
In Rice as Self (1993), the Japanese-American anthropologist Emiko Ohnuki-Tierney traced how short-grain rice became a metaphor for the Japanese people. Using myths, rituals, tax records and art, she showed that rice was linked to deities, to the emperor and to the land, and was contrasted first with Chinese food and later with Western meat-eating. Japanese people today eat far less rice than their grandparents did, yet domestic rice keeps its symbolic weight. When a cold summer ruined much of the 1993 harvest and Japan imported rice, much of the imported grain was widely rejected as tasting wrong.
Commensality: eating makes kin
Commensality means eating together, and in many societies it creates and displays relationships. Sharing food says we belong together; refusing it can signal distance or enmity. As the topic on kinship noted, Janet Carsten, working in a fishing community on the Malaysian island of Langkawi in the 1980s, described how people who ate rice cooked on the same hearth came to be seen as related, so that kinship was partly made by feeding rather than given by birth alone. The English word companion itself comes from Latin roots meaning someone you share bread with.
Prescriptions, proscriptions and feasts
Food rules come in two kinds. Food prescriptions are foods a group expects people to eat, especially on particular occasions; food proscriptions, or taboos, are foods it forbids. Feasts concentrate prescriptions into special meals: turkey at an American Thanksgiving, zongzi rice dumplings at the Chinese Dragon Boat Festival, which tradition links to the poet Qu Yuan, who died about 278 BCE, and celebratory meals at Eid al-Fitr, which ends the Ramadan fast. Such foods carry memory: eating them repeats the story the occasion tells.
Faith and food
Many food rules are religious, and anthropologists describe them in the terms of those who keep them. Jewish kashrut forbids pork and shellfish and separates meat from dairy. Islamic law classes foods as halal, permitted, or haram, forbidden, including pork and alcohol. Many Hindus are vegetarian, linking diet to ahimsa, non-harm to living beings, though practice varies by region and caste, and Jains follow stricter rules still. During Ramadan, Muslims fast from dawn to sunset. For observers these are matters of obedience, purity and devotion; anthropology studies their social effects without judging their truth.
Explaining a taboo
Anthropologists have offered rival explanations for food taboos. Mary Douglas, in Purity and Danger (1966), argued that the forbidden animals of the Hebrew Bible's Leviticus were those that broke its categories: land animals should chew the cud and have split hooves, and the pig has split hooves but does not chew the cud. Marvin Harris, in Good to Eat (1985), offered a materialist account: pigs need shade, water and grain, so they competed with people in the hot, dry Middle East, and a ban made ecological sense. Claude Lévi-Strauss had earlier remarked that animals are chosen because they are good to think with, not only good to eat.
Worked example: weighing the explanations
Compare the symbolic and materialist accounts of the pork taboo. 1. Douglas predicts that forbidden animals will be category anomalies; shellfish, water creatures without fins and scales, fit this pattern too. 2. Harris predicts bans where an animal is costly to raise; this fits arid pastoral lands but explains less well why pork is banned far from deserts. 3. Both are outsider explanations, while observant Jews and Muslims understand the rule as a divine command. 4. The accounts can coexist: one explains the logic of the rule, the other the conditions in which it took root. 5. Conclusion: anthropologists test explanations against evidence and respect the believers' own account.
Taste and class
Food also marks rank. The French sociologist Pierre Bourdieu, in Distinction (1979), argued that taste is learned in a class setting and then used to signal status: educated elites prized refinement and small portions, while working-class families valued hearty, generous food. The British anthropologist Jack Goody, in Cooking, Cuisine and Class (1982), compared Eurasia and Africa and argued that sharply ranked agrarian states developed distinct high and low cuisines, while many West African societies had less difference between what chiefs and commoners ate.
Food and gender
In many societies, foods, cooking and serving are gendered. Who cooks daily meals, who carves at feasts and which dishes count as manly or feminine are cultural choices, not biological facts. Food can also mark life stages. In the Kinaaldá, the Diné (Navajo) ceremony held for a girl after her first menstruation, she and the women of her family prepare a large corn cake baked in an earth oven, recalling the Holy Person Changing Woman. Anne Allison, writing in 1991, analysed the obentō, the elaborate boxed lunch Japanese mothers make for nursery-school children.
Worked example: reading a lunchbox
Follow Allison's analysis of the obentō. 1. Observation: mothers spent long hours making small, decorated, varied portions, and teachers checked that children ate everything. 2. For the child: finishing the box trained discipline and fitting in with the group. 3. For the mother: the box was judged by others, so it displayed her skill and devotion as a mother. 4. Wider link: Allison argued that schools and the state used this everyday object to reproduce gender roles and national values. 5. Lesson: an ordinary meal can carry ideology about who should do what work.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, treating food choices as purely personal taste when they express group identity. Second, assuming a symbol fades when consumption falls: Japanese rice keeps its meaning though less is eaten. Third, describing religious food rules as irrational or as health rules in disguise, rather than in observers' own terms. Fourth, assuming one explanation must win: symbolic and materialist accounts can answer different questions. Fifth, treating all members of a faith as following identical rules; practice varies. Sixth, treating gendered food habits as natural rather than learned.
Key takeaways
Cuisine is a badge of identity. Ohnuki-Tierney's Rice as Self (1993) shows short-grain rice standing for the Japanese self. Commensality creates relationships, as Carsten found on Langkawi. Food prescriptions and proscriptions, often focused in feasts, mark groups and occasions; kashrut, halal and Hindu vegetarianism are described in believers' terms. Douglas explained taboos through categories, Harris through ecology. Bourdieu and Goody linked taste and cuisine to class. Gendered food practices, from the Diné Kinaaldá corn cake to the Japanese obentō, teach who people are expected to be.
Flashcards
Flashcard
A group's shared way of choosing, preparing, combining and eating food
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
What does Ohnuki-Tierney's study of Japanese rice show about food symbols?
Question 2 of 5
How did Mary Douglas explain why Leviticus forbids pork?
Question 3 of 5
Which practice is an example of commensality creating kinship?
Question 4 of 5
According to Anne Allison, what did the Japanese obentō teach?
Question 5 of 5
Which approach best follows anthropological practice when studying a religious food rule?
