Anthropology › Section N · Anthropology of food › Topic N.2
A biocultural approach to food
What people eat feeds their bodies and expresses who they are, and the two cannot be pulled apart. The biocultural approach follows the loop between them: cultural practices change which nutrients reach the body, and bodies, over generations, change in response to culture.
Biology and culture in one meal
A biocultural approach studies food as both nourishment and meaning, and asks how each shapes the other. It joins biological anthropology, with its attention to nutrition, growth and disease, to cultural anthropology, with its attention to belief, technique and social life. The American biological anthropologist George Armelagos (1936-2014) was a leading figure: with Peter Farb he wrote Consuming Passions: The Anthropology of Eating (1980), one of the first anthropology books devoted to food. The approach rejects two shortcuts: explaining diets only by nutritional need, and explaining them only as arbitrary custom.
Nixtamalization
In Mesoamerica, people have long soaked and cooked dried maize in water with lime or wood ash before grinding it into masa for tortillas and tamales. The process, called nixtamalization from a Nahuatl word, softens the hull and changes the grain's chemistry. Crucially, it makes niacin, a B vitamin bound up in maize, available to the body, and it improves the balance of proteins. In 1974 Solomon Katz, Mary Hediger and Linda Valleroy surveyed many societies and found that those depending heavily on maize almost always used an alkali treatment. Cooks had built a nutritional safeguard into ordinary kitchen practice.
Worked example: maize without its method
Trace what happened when maize travelled without nixtamalization. 1. Movement: after 1492 maize spread to Europe and later became a staple of poor farmers in parts of Italy, Spain and France, and later of poor families in the southern United States. 2. Missing step: the crop travelled, but the alkali cooking method did not. 3. Biological effect: diets heavy in untreated maize and short of meat, milk or beans left people short of niacin, causing pellagra, a disease of the skin, gut and nervous system. 4. Social pattern: pellagra struck the poorest hardest, because they could not vary their diet. 5. Lesson: a food's nutritional value depends on the cultural knowledge that comes with it.
Milk and lactase persistence
All infants make lactase, the enzyme that digests the sugar in milk, but most adults worldwide produce much less of it; the US National Library of Medicine estimates that about 65% of people have a reduced ability to digest lactose after infancy. Lactase persistence, keeping the enzyme into adulthood, is common in northern Europe and among some herding peoples of East Africa and the Middle East. Geneticists, including Sarah Tishkoff and colleagues in 2007, found that different genetic variants arose independently in Europe and Africa, each spreading where people kept dairy animals. This is gene-culture coevolution: a cultural practice, dairying, changed the frequency of a gene.
Culture can do the digesting
Lactase persistence is not the only route to using milk. Many herding peoples who do not keep the enzyme turn milk into yoghurt, cheese, butter or fermented drinks, in which bacteria have already broken down much of the lactose. Mongolian herders, for example, rely heavily on fermented and dried dairy foods. The same biological problem can therefore be solved genetically, culturally or both. This is why biocultural anthropologists caution against calling lactose intolerance a disorder: from a global point of view it is the ordinary adult condition, and persistence is the unusual one.
The Three Sisters
Haudenosaunee farmers in what is now New York State grew maize, beans and squash together in small hills: maize stalks support the climbing beans, beans host root bacteria that fix nitrogen in the soil, and broad squash leaves shade out weeds and keep the soil moist. This is intercropping, growing different crops together rather than in separate rows. For the Haudenosaunee the three crops are also sisters, gifts honoured in ceremony and story. Jane Mt. Pleasant, a Haudenosaunee scientist, reported in 2016 that the system yields more food energy and protein per hectare than maize, beans and squash planted as separate monocultures on the same area.
Worked example: how many people can a field feed?
Mt. Pleasant estimated that one hectare of Three Sisters supplies enough food energy for about 13.42 people for a year, and enough protein for about 15.86 people, assuming about 2,500 kilocalories and 60 grams of protein per person per day. How many people could a 2-hectare field support? 1. Energy: 2 × 13.42 = 26.84 people. 2. Protein: 2 × 15.86 = 31.72 people. 3. Limiting factor: energy runs out first, so about 26 people could be fully fed. 4. Check: the protein figure is higher, which fits the role of beans and squash in supplementing maize. 5. Caveat: households also foraged, hunted and stored food, so the field was one part of a wider diet.
Farming's health costs
Biocultural research also shows that new foodways can harm health. In Paleopathology at the Origins of Agriculture (1984), edited by Mark Cohen and George Armelagos, researchers compared skeletons from many regions before and after the adoption of farming. Many farming populations showed more tooth decay, more defects in tooth enamel from childhood illness or hunger, more signs of anaemia and sometimes shorter stature. Denser settlements spread infection, and diets narrowed to a few staple crops. The pattern varied by region, but it overturned the assumption that farming simply made life healthier.
The paleo diet and mismatch
Some popular diets claim to recreate how our ancestors ate. The paleo diet goes back to the gastroenterologist Walter Voegtlin's book The Stone Age Diet (1975) and was popularised after S. Boyd Eaton and Melvin Konner's 1985 article on Palaeolithic nutrition. It rests on the mismatch, or discordance, idea: human bodies evolved for foraging and fit modern diets poorly. Anthropologists such as Melanie Chang and April Nowell (2016) reply that there was no single Palaeolithic diet, that Arctic hunters and tropical foragers ate very differently, and that people ground wild grains on stones at least 30,000 years ago. Describing past diets is research, not dietary advice.
Worked example: testing a diet claim
A website says: Stone Age people never ate grains or dairy, and humans have not evolved since, so we should not either. Evaluate it. 1. First claim, no grains: starch grains on grinding stones from about 30,000 years ago show wild grains were processed, so the claim fails. 2. Second claim, no dairy: true before animals were domesticated, but not a reason in itself to avoid it. 3. Third claim, no evolution since: lactase persistence spread within roughly the last 10,000 years, so humans have kept evolving. 4. Hidden assumption: that one past diet existed, when diets varied with environment. 5. Conclusion: the claim misuses anthropological evidence.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, treating diet as either pure biology or pure custom; the biocultural approach studies the loop between them. Second, assuming a food has fixed nutritional value: untreated maize and nixtamalized maize differ. Third, calling lactose intolerance abnormal when it is the majority adult condition. Fourth, forgetting that culture can solve biological problems, as fermenting milk does. Fifth, assuming farming always improved health; many skeletons say otherwise. Sixth, citing a single Palaeolithic diet, or treating anthropological findings about past diets as health prescriptions.
Key takeaways
The biocultural approach, championed by George Armelagos, studies food as both nourishment and meaning. Nixtamalization releases niacin from maize, and maize eaten without it caused pellagra among the poor. Lactase persistence spread where people kept dairy animals, a case of gene-culture coevolution, while fermentation offered a cultural route to using milk. The Haudenosaunee Three Sisters yield more energy and protein per hectare than the crops grown separately. Early farming often worsened health. The paleo diet's single ancestral diet is not supported by evidence, and past diets are research, not prescriptions.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Studying food as both nourishment and meaning, and how each shapes the other
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Why did pellagra appear in places that adopted maize after 1492?
Question 2 of 5
What makes lactase persistence an example of gene-culture coevolution?
Question 3 of 5
Using Mt. Pleasant's figures of 13.42 people per hectare for energy and 15.86 for protein, about how many people could a 3-hectare Three Sisters field fully feed?
Question 4 of 5
What did Paleopathology at the Origins of Agriculture (1984) generally find?
Question 5 of 5
Which statement is the strongest anthropological objection to the claim that there was one Stone Age diet?
