Anthropology › Section A · What is anthropology? › Topic A.2

The four-field approach

No single kind of evidence can tell the whole human story. Anthropology splits the work into four fields, which study bodies, things, ways of life and words, and its best results come when they combine.

Four kinds of evidence

How did people first reach islands such as Tonga and Samoa, thousands of kilometres across open ocean? A skeleton can carry ancient DNA. Broken pottery shows where and when people settled. Living navigators hold knowledge of stars, swells and birds. The words of Pacific languages preserve traces of their speakers' journeys. Each clue answers part of the question, and each needs its own training. The study of humanity introduced anthropology's broad aims; this topic shows how the discipline divides the labour among four fields and why it keeps them together.

Why four fields?

In the United States, Franz Boas and his students built anthropology from about 1900 around four subfields: biological anthropology, archaeology, cultural anthropology and linguistic anthropology. Boas himself measured bodies, collected objects, recorded languages and described customs, and he argued that human life could only be understood by combining them. Many American departments still teach all four. In Britain and much of Europe, social anthropology, archaeology and biological anthropology often sit in separate departments. Some writers add applied anthropology as a fifth field, though it is more often seen as a kind of work done within all four.

Biological anthropology

Biological anthropology, also called physical anthropology, studies humans as living organisms. Palaeoanthropologists trace human evolution through fossils. Primatologists study our closest relatives: from 1960 Jane Goodall's observations at Gombe in Tanzania showed chimpanzees making and using tools, which challenged the idea that toolmaking alone defined humans. Others study human genetics, growth, nutrition and adaptation, such as the ways some highland populations cope with low oxygen. Forensic anthropologists apply this knowledge to identify human remains for courts, mass-grave investigations and disaster recovery, estimating age, sex, time since death and signs of injury.

Archaeology

Archaeology studies human life through material remains: artefacts such as tools and pottery, features such as hearths and walls, and traces such as seeds, bones and pollen. Writing appeared only about 5,000 years ago, so for more than 98 per cent of the roughly 300,000-year history of our species, archaeology is the main source of evidence. Historical archaeology works alongside written records and often recovers the lives of people those records ignore. Archaeologists also study the present: from 1973 William Rathje's Garbage Project sorted household rubbish in Tucson, Arizona, and found that what people threw away often differed from what they told interviewers.

Cultural anthropology

Cultural anthropology, called social anthropology in Britain, studies living societies: their families, economies, politics, religions, arts and ways of seeing the world. Its central method is long-term fieldwork, living among people, joining in their daily life and talking with them over months or years, then writing an ethnography, a detailed account of that way of life. The methods themselves are covered in Ethnography and ethnology and in Participant observation and interviewing. Early cultural anthropologists mostly studied small, distant communities; today they also work in hospitals, banks, refugee camps, factories and online games.

Linguistic anthropology

Linguistic anthropology studies language in social life. It asks how languages vary and change, how speech marks identity and status, how people use words to persuade, joke, pray and exclude, and whether the language we speak influences how we think, a question taken up in Language and the mind. Many linguistic anthropologists document endangered languages and work with communities that are revitalising them. A simple example of their interest is code-switching, when a bilingual speaker moves between languages in one conversation, often to signal closeness, authority or belonging.

Worked example: settling the Pacific

Combine the four fields on the question from the first card. 1. Archaeology: distinctive Lapita pottery appears on islands from the Bismarck Archipelago to Tonga and Samoa between about 3,300 and 2,800 years ago, marking a rapid spread of settlers. 2. Biological anthropology: ancient DNA from early skeletons in Vanuatu and Tonga, published in 2016, shows mainly East Asian ancestry. 3. Linguistic anthropology: Pacific languages belong to the Austronesian family, whose deepest branches are in Taiwan. 4. Cultural anthropology: the Micronesian navigator Mau Piailug guided the voyaging canoe Hōkūleʻa from Hawaiʻi to Tahiti in 1976 without instruments. 5. Conclusion: deliberate voyaging by skilled navigators is the best-supported explanation.

Worked example: the idea of race

Apply the four fields to race. 1. Biological: human traits such as skin colour change gradually across geography, and in 1972 Richard Lewontin found that about 85 per cent of human genetic variation lies within populations, so no clear boundaries divide humanity into races. 2. Cultural: societies draw racial lines differently; Brazil's census uses several colour categories, while US practice long followed a one-drop rule. 3. Archaeology: excavations of the homes of enslaved and free Black Americans show how racism shaped housing, diet and possessions. 4. Linguistic: everyday labels show how categories are made and changed. 5. Conclusion: race is not biological, but racism is real.

Where the fields meet

The boundaries between fields are busy crossroads. Bioarchaeologists study ancient skeletons to learn about diet, disease and violence in the past. Ethnoarchaeologists watch how living people make and discard objects to help interpret ancient sites. Forensic anthropologists and archaeologists excavate together. The fields do not always agree on method: biological anthropologists often test hypotheses with measurement, while many cultural anthropologists rely on interpretation of meaning. Anthropologists increasingly argue that big problems, such as health inequality or climate change, need both styles at once.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, thinking archaeology studies dinosaurs: that is palaeontology, and the non-bird dinosaurs died out about 66 million years ago, tens of millions of years before humans appeared. Second, treating biological anthropology as only fossils: it includes primates, genetics, health and forensics. Third, assuming cultural anthropologists study only remote villages. Fourth, confusing linguistic anthropology with learning to speak many languages: it studies how language works in social life. Fifth, treating the four fields as rivals: the strongest answers, as with Pacific settlement, combine them.

Key takeaways

Boas and his students organised American anthropology into four fields; in Britain and Europe they are often separate departments, and applied work runs through all of them. Biological anthropology studies evolution, primates, genetics, adaptation and forensic identification. Archaeology studies the past through material remains and is the main evidence for more than 98 per cent of our species' history. Cultural (social) anthropology studies living societies through fieldwork and ethnography. Linguistic anthropology studies language in social life. Combined, the fields explain Pacific settlement and show that race is a social category, not a biological one.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Four-field approach

Biological anthropology, archaeology, cultural anthropology, linguistic anthropology

Built by Boas and his students in the US.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A researcher examines a skeleton from a disaster site to estimate the person's age and sex for identification. Which field is this?

Question 2 of 5

Why is archaeology the main source of evidence for most of our species' history?

Question 3 of 5

In the Pacific settlement example, what did the linguistic evidence contribute?

Question 4 of 5

What does Lewontin's 1972 finding imply about human races?

Question 5 of 5

Which statement about the four fields is most accurate?

← Previous topicNext topic →