Anthropology › Section A · What is anthropology? › Topic A.3
Overcoming ethnocentrism
Everyone grows up thinking their own ways are simply normal. Anthropology names that tendency, shows how it was turned into stereotypes that justified empire, and teaches habits for seeing past it.
That feels wrong
A student from Seoul visits a friend in Texas and is startled when the family walks through the house in outdoor shoes. The Texan friend, visiting Seoul later, is just as surprised to be handed a metal spoon for rice and to see diners waiting for the eldest person to start eating. Each reaction comes fast, before any thought: that is not how things are done. These gut reactions are the raw material of this topic. They are normal, but left unexamined they turn into judgements about whose ways are right.
Enculturation
Anthropologists call the process of learning one's own culture enculturation. From infancy, parents, relatives, teachers, religious leaders and friends teach us how to eat, dress, speak, show respect and tell right from wrong. Most of this is absorbed without anyone explaining it, so by adulthood it feels like common sense rather than one way among many. Enculturation is essential: no one could survive without learning a culture. But because it works so quietly, it leaves us with the impression that our habits are natural and that other people's habits are odd.
Ethnocentrism
Ethnocentrism is judging other cultures by the standards of one's own and treating one's own ways as the correct measure, often as superior. The American sociologist William Graham Sumner popularised the term in Folkways (1906). It is found in every society; many groups' names for themselves simply mean "the people". Mild ethnocentrism can strengthen group pride and solidarity. The danger comes when it closes the mind, so that people no longer ask what other ways of life mean to those who live them, or when it is backed by power.
When ethnocentrism meets power
From the fifteenth century onwards, European empires used ethnocentric ideas to justify conquest, slavery and the seizure of land, describing colonised peoples as needing to be "civilised". In the late nineteenth and twentieth centuries, governments in the United States and Canada removed many Indigenous children to boarding and residential schools designed to replace their languages, religions and family ways. Canada's Truth and Reconciliation Commission, which reported in 2015, described the Canadian system as cultural genocide. Here ethnocentrism was no longer a private prejudice but state policy, with harms that communities still live with.
Self and other
Ethnocentric thinking often works by building a cultural other: a simplified, stereotyped picture of another people, used to define "us" by contrast with "them". If they are described as irrational, we must be rational; if they are wild, we must be civilised. The picture says more about the people drawing it than about the people drawn. Historians and anthropologists have identified two especially influential European styles of othering that grew up alongside colonial expansion: primitivism and orientalism. Both still echo in films, advertising and news today.
Primitivism
Primitivism portrayed African and Indigenous American peoples as simple, childlike, ruled by instinct, potentially violent and closer to nature than to civilisation. The nineteenth-century explorer Henry Morton Stanley titled a book Through the Dark Continent (1878), a phrase that stuck to Africa for generations. In fact the societies described included kingdoms, trading networks and complex legal and religious systems. A softer version, the "noble savage", pictured the same peoples as innocent and at peace with nature. It sounds kinder, but it is still a stereotype that denies people history, debate and change.
Orientalism
In Orientalism (1978), the Palestinian American literary scholar Edward Said argued that European writers, artists and officials had long portrayed the Middle East and Asia as exotic, sensual, irrational, fanatical and despotic. Said argued that this picture served empire: by imagining an unchanging "Orient", Europeans could present themselves as rational, modern and fit to rule. Where primitivism stressed closeness to nature, orientalism stressed excess, mystery and tyranny. Said's work became foundational for postcolonial studies, though critics have argued that he sometimes treated Western writing as more uniform than it was.
Worked example: a holiday advert
Analyse this invented advert: "Escape to untouched Africa, where time stands still and smiling tribes live as they have for thousands of years." 1. Identify the self: a modern, busy traveller from a fast-moving society. 2. Identify the other: unnamed "tribes" with no history, frozen in time. 3. Name the style: primitivism, in its gentle noble-savage version. 4. Test it against evidence: every African community has a long history of change, trade, migration and debate, and most Africans today live in towns and cities. 5. Rewrite: name the specific people and place, and describe them as they describe themselves.
Worked example: a film villain
Analyse this invented film plot: a calm, clever Western agent outwits a raging Middle Eastern villain who hates freedom, while veiled women watch silently. 1. Self: the Western hero, rational and in control. 2. Other: a fanatical man and voiceless women. 3. Style: orientalism, which casts the region as irrational, violent and oppressive. 4. Consequence: repeated images like this can shape how audiences treat Arab and Muslim neighbours, and how voters judge foreign policy. 5. Correction: show varied characters with their own motives, careers and opinions, as in any real society.
Habits for overcoming ethnocentrism
Anthropologists practise a few habits. Notice the gut reaction and treat it as information about yourself. Ask what the practice means to the people who do it, and who within the group may disagree. Learn its setting: history, economy, religion, environment. Turn the lens around and describe one of your own customs as an outsider would. These habits lead directly to the method set out in Cross-cultural comparison and cultural relativism. Overcoming ethnocentrism does not mean deciding that another culture is better than your own; that opposite error is called xenocentrism.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, thinking only other people are ethnocentric: enculturation makes everyone prone to it. Second, assuming ethnocentrism is always hostile: pity and romantic admiration, as in the noble-savage image, are forms of it too. Third, treating primitivism and orientalism as old history: their images still circulate. Fourth, confusing orientalism, a style of representation analysed by Said, with simple interest in Asian cultures. Fifth, believing that overcoming ethnocentrism means giving up your own values or praising every other culture.
Key takeaways
Enculturation is learning one's own culture; it makes our ways feel natural. Ethnocentrism, popularised as a term by Sumner (1906), judges others by one's own standards and is found everywhere; backed by power, it justified conquest, slavery and policies such as residential schools. Ethnocentric thinking builds a cultural other to define "us". Primitivism portrayed Africans and Indigenous Americans as simple and close to nature; the noble savage is its romantic version. Orientalism, analysed by Said (1978), portrayed Asia and the Middle East as irrational and despotic. Noticing, asking, contextualising and turning the lens on yourself help overcome it.
Flashcards
Flashcard
The process of learning one's own culture
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Why does anthropology treat ethnocentrism as something found in every society?
Question 2 of 5
An advert describes a people as innocent, timeless and living in perfect harmony with nature. Which style of othering is this?
Question 3 of 5
According to Edward Said, what purpose did orientalist images serve?
Question 4 of 5
What made the boarding and residential school systems for Indigenous children an example of ethnocentrism becoming harmful policy?
Question 5 of 5
A student returns from abroad insisting her home culture is worse in every way. What does this show?
