Anthropology › Section A · What is anthropology? › Topic A.5

Holism, anthropology's distinctive approach

Pull one thread of a way of life and others move with it. Holism is anthropology's habit of following those threads, across a society and across biology and culture, and it often turns up connections nobody expected.

Pull one thread

Imagine a paved road finally reaching a mountain village. Trucks can now carry crops to the city, so families plant more for sale. Young men leave for city jobs and send money home. Women take on more of the farm work and the decisions. A festival that once needed everyone at home is shortened. Television arrives, and new ideas about marriage with it. Nobody planned these changes; the road was meant only to move goods. Following such chains of effects is the heart of holism, the approach this topic explains.

What holism means

Holism is the anthropological principle that the parts of a way of life, such as work, family, religion, politics, health, language and environment, are connected, and that each is best understood in relation to the others. It has two scales. Within a society, it means placing any practice in its full setting. Across the discipline, it means combining biology, the past, language and culture, the four fields described in The four-field approach. Either way, the question is the same: what else is this connected to? Holism does not mean studying literally everything, but refusing to cut a practice off from its context.

Parts that hold each other up

Sometimes the parts reinforce one another. In The Nuer (1940), E. E. Evans-Pritchard described how cattle ran through every part of life among the Nuer, who call themselves Naath, in what is now South Sudan. Cattle supplied milk and wealth, moved between families as bridewealth to make marriages, settled disputes as compensation, and were offered in sacrifice. Kinship, politics and religion all ran through the herds. His account is a classic of holistic writing, though later scholars noted that it was written under colonial rule and described a more fixed way of life than the Nuer actually lived.

Hidden connections

Holism often reveals links that specialists miss. In 2007 the mobile-money service M-Pesa launched in Kenya, letting people send money by text message. Economists Tavneet Suri and William Jack reported in 2016 that access to it lifted about 2 per cent of Kenyan households out of extreme poverty, with the largest gains in households headed by women. An anthropologist would point to the reason: money could now flow instantly through networks of relatives, so a family could gather funds for a hospital visit, school fees or a failed harvest. A payments technology turned out to be about kinship.

Holism is not harmony

Early twentieth-century anthropologists such as Bronislaw Malinowski and A. R. Radcliffe-Brown often pictured a society as a balanced organism, each part working to keep the whole stable. This view, called functionalism, produced detailed studies but tended to treat societies as closed and unchanging. Holism today is different. The parts of a way of life can contradict one another, generating conflict and change, and outside forces such as markets, states and migration are part of the picture. Anthropologists use holism to explain breakdown and transformation as much as stability.

Worked example: steel axes

In 1952 Lauriston Sharp described the Yir Yoront of Cape York in northern Australia. Trace the effects. 1. Before: stone axes belonged mainly to older men, came through long trade partnerships, and were lent to women and young men, marking authority. 2. The change: missionaries handed out steel axes, often directly to women and young men. 3. Ripples: older men's authority weakened, trading partnerships and gatherings lost purpose, and beliefs linking each object to ancestral origins were unsettled. 4. Caution: later scholars noted that Sharp underplayed wider colonial pressures and pictured earlier life as too stable. 5. Lesson: one new tool reshaped age, gender, trade and belief.

Worked example: back to the road

Apply holism to the village in the first card, a composite case. 1. Start with one change: the road. 2. Economy: crops for sale replace some crops for eating. 3. Kinship and gender: men migrate; women manage farms; money from the city creates new obligations between relatives. 4. Religion and ritual: the festival shrinks because migrants cannot return. 5. Environment: more land is cleared for cash crops. 6. Contradictions: elders lose influence while wage-earning sons gain it, causing family arguments. 7. Check: each effect is linked to another, which is what makes the analysis holistic rather than a list.

Biology and culture together

Holism also links bodies and culture. Most mammals lose the ability to digest lactose, the sugar in milk, after weaning, and so do most humans. But in several herding populations, in parts of Europe, East Africa and the Middle East, genetic variants that keep lactase working into adulthood became common within roughly the last 10,000 years. Dairying, a cultural practice, changed the conditions under which those genes were favoured. Different populations evolved different variants for the same trait. Neither biology nor culture alone explains the pattern; together they do, which is exactly what a holistic approach expects.

Holism as a method

In practice, holism guides research in a few ways. Anthropologists often begin with one practice or one change and follow it outwards, asking who is affected and how. They use several kinds of evidence, such as interviews, observation, household budgets, archives or genetics. They pay attention to people who disagree, because disagreement shows where the parts strain against each other. And they look beyond the local community to the markets, governments and global forces that reach into it. The aim is an account in which the connections, not just the parts, are visible.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, thinking holism means describing every aspect of a society in equal detail: it means following the connections that matter. Second, equating holism with harmony: parts can clash and drive change. Third, studying a community as if it were sealed off from states, markets and migration. Fourth, splitting biology and culture as though one could never shape the other. Fifth, treating classic holistic studies as timeless: they were written at particular moments, often under colonial rule, and should be read with their dates.

Key takeaways

Holism is the principle that the parts of a way of life are connected and best understood together, within a society and across biology and culture. Evans-Pritchard's The Nuer (1940) showed cattle linking economy, kinship, politics and religion. M-Pesa (from 2007) showed a technology working through kin networks. Functionalism pictured societies as balanced organisms; holism today includes contradiction, change and outside forces. Sharp's steel axes (1952) traced one tool's effects on age, gender, trade and belief. Lactase persistence shows culture and genes shaping each other. As a method, holism follows one change outwards using many kinds of evidence.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Holism

The principle that the parts of a way of life are connected and best understood together

Ask: what else is this connected to?

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Which research question is most holistic?

Question 2 of 5

What does the M-Pesa example show about holism?

Question 3 of 5

How does holism today differ from early functionalism?

Question 4 of 5

In Sharp's study, why did steel axes disrupt Yir Yoront society?

Question 5 of 5

Why is lactase persistence a good example of holism across biology and culture?

← Previous topicNext topic →