Anthropology › Section A · What is anthropology? › Topic A.6
Cross-cultural comparison and cultural relativism
To compare cultures fairly, you first have to understand each one in its own terms. Cultural relativism is anthropology's method for doing that. It asks you to hold back judgement while you learn, not to give up judgement for good.
Understand first
On the high Tibetan plateau, some families carry out a funeral known in Tibetan as jhator, often translated "sky burial": trained specialists prepare the body on a mountainside and offer it to vultures. A first-time visitor may feel shock. An anthropologist asks what the practice means to those who carry it out. Buddhist teaching treats the body after death as an empty vessel, and offering it to other living beings is an act of generosity. Practically, the ground is often rocky or frozen and wood for cremation is scarce. Understood in context, the practice is careful and respectful.
Comparing cultures
Cross-cultural comparison is one of anthropology's oldest methods: setting many societies side by side to see which features are widespread, which vary and what varies with what. To make large comparisons possible, Yale researchers founded the Human Relations Area Files in 1949, an archive that organises ethnographies of hundreds of societies by topic, such as marriage, warfare or healing. Comparison only works if each case is understood correctly first. Comparing "marriage" across societies is meaningless if a researcher misreads what marriage means in each one. That is why comparison and relativism go together.
Cultural relativism
Cultural relativism is the principle that any belief or practice should be understood within the wider whole of the culture it belongs to, rather than judged by the standards of an outsider's culture. It builds on holism: a practice makes sense only in relation to the economy, religion, kinship and history around it. The idea was developed by Franz Boas and his students in the early twentieth century, among them Ruth Benedict, whose Patterns of Culture (1934) reached a wide public, and Melville Herskovits, who did much to define and defend it. It was a direct answer to the ladder-of-progress thinking described in Western bias in assumptions about humanity.
A method, not moral indifference
Anthropologists distinguish two ideas that share a name. Methodological relativism is a research method: suspend judgement temporarily so that you can understand a practice as its participants do. Strong moral relativism is a philosophical claim: that right and wrong exist only relative to each culture, so no practice can ever be judged from outside. Most anthropologists today accept the first and reject the second. Critics who say relativism means "anything goes" are usually attacking the second. Understanding why people do something is not the same as approving of it.
Worked example: sky burial
Apply methodological relativism to jhator, from the first card. 1. Notice the reaction: discomfort, perhaps disgust; set it aside for now. 2. Ask the meaning: in local Buddhist understanding, consciousness has left the body, and giving it to vultures is a final act of generosity. 3. Find the setting: rocky or frozen ground and scarce fuel make burial and cremation difficult. 4. Look for variety: practices differ between regions and families, and cremation and other rites are also used. 5. Compare: many societies, including Western ones, have ways of returning the body to nature. 6. Conclusion: what looked shocking is coherent within its own whole.
Problems with strong moral relativism
Strong moral relativism runs into serious difficulties. If each culture's standards are the only test, then no one outside could condemn slavery or genocide, and reformers inside a society, who challenge its own customs, would always be wrong by definition. It also assumes that a culture speaks with one voice. In practice, every society contains disagreement: the powerful and the powerless, the old and the young, women and men may judge the same custom very differently. Asking "whose standards?" usually reveals that the culture's "view" is contested from within.
Relativism and human rights
In 1947, as the United Nations drafted what became the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (1948), the American Anthropological Association sent a statement, drafted largely by Herskovits, warning against imposing one culture's values as universal standards. Critics later argued that it underplayed real abuses. In 1999 the association adopted a Declaration on Anthropology and Human Rights that supports universal rights while insisting they be understood and pursued with knowledge of local contexts. The debate continues between universalists, who stress shared standards, and relativists, who stress local meaning; many anthropologists seek a position that respects both.
Worked example: female genital cutting
UNICEF estimated in 2024 that more than 230 million girls and women alive had undergone female genital cutting, which the World Health Organization calls female genital mutilation and opposes for its serious health harms. 1. Context: anthropologists such as Bettina Shell-Duncan found that families often see it as protecting a daughter's honour and marriage prospects. 2. Decision-makers: wider kin networks, not only parents, often press for it. 3. Inside debate: UNICEF reports that about two-thirds of people in practising countries in Africa and the Middle East oppose it. 4. Action: campaigns led by local communities work better than outside condemnation. 5. Understanding is not approval: Shell-Duncan's research has informed programmes to end the practice.
Why relativism helps
Relativism makes anthropologists better at understanding and often better at helping. Outsiders who condemn a practice without understanding it may provoke resistance, as people defend customs under attack. Outsiders who first listen can find the people within a community who already want change, the reasons a practice persists, and the alternatives that might work locally. Relativism also protects against the opposite mistake of romanticising other cultures. Because it treats every culture as made by people with interests and arguments, it never assumes that a custom is wise simply because it is old or foreign.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, equating cultural relativism with "anything goes": as a method, it pauses judgement rather than abolishing it. Second, confusing methodological relativism with strong moral relativism. Third, treating a culture as speaking with one voice, which hides the people inside it who disagree. Fourth, comparing practices across societies before understanding each in its own setting. Fifth, thinking relativism and human rights must be enemies: the 1999 AAA declaration supports rights pursued with local knowledge.
Key takeaways
Cross-cultural comparison sets societies side by side; the Human Relations Area Files (1949) made large comparisons possible. Cultural relativism means understanding each practice within the whole of its culture; it was developed by Boas, Benedict and Herskovits. Methodological relativism suspends judgement temporarily and is widely accepted; strong moral relativism, which denies any outside judgement, is widely rejected because it silences reformers and ignores internal disagreement. The AAA's 1947 statement cautioned against universal standards; its 1999 declaration supports human rights informed by context. Debates over female genital cutting show relativism used to understand and to support locally led change.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Setting many societies side by side to find patterns
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Which statement best describes methodological relativism?
Question 2 of 5
What is a major objection to strong moral relativism?
Question 3 of 5
Why must cross-cultural comparison be paired with relativism?
Question 4 of 5
How did the AAA's position on human rights change between 1947 and 1999?
Question 5 of 5
In the female genital cutting example, what did a relativist approach reveal that outside condemnation missed?
