Anthropology › Section A · What is anthropology? › Topic A.7

Reaching for an insider's point of view

Anthropologists try to see a way of life as the people who live it see it, and then to explain it in terms outsiders can compare. This topic introduces the emic and etic views, asks whether an insider's view can ever really be reached, and shows how collaboration helps.

Seeing from the inside

Bronislaw Malinowski, who worked in the Trobriand Islands of Papua New Guinea between 1915 and 1918, wrote in Argonauts of the Western Pacific (1922) that the goal of fieldwork was to grasp the point of view of the people studied, their vision of their own world. He used the language of his time, "the native's point of view", a phrase anthropologists now use carefully. The goal itself has lasted. Cultural anthropologists pursue it by living alongside people and talking with them; archaeologists by reading meaning from objects and sites; linguistic anthropologists by learning how people themselves classify and speak about their world.

Emic and etic

Two terms help separate views. An emic account describes a practice in the categories and meanings used by the people themselves: what they call it, why they say they do it, what it feels like to them. An etic account uses the outside analyst's categories, chosen so that cases can be compared across societies. The linguist Kenneth Pike coined the terms in 1954 from phonemic, the sound differences speakers notice, and phonetic, the sounds a trained observer measures. The anthropologist Marvin Harris made them central to anthropology. Good research usually needs both, and keeps clear which is which.

Worked example: India's sacred cattle

In 1966 Marvin Harris analysed why cattle are protected in much of India. 1. Emic view: for many Hindus the cow is sacred, linked to the principle of ahimsa, non-harm, and honoured as a source of life; killing one is deeply wrong. 2. Etic view: Harris argued that cattle also do essential work, as oxen pull ploughs, dung serves as fuel and fertiliser, and cows give milk, so protecting them made ecological and economic sense. 3. Both views can be true at once. 4. Critique: many scholars argued that Harris reduced religious meaning to ecology. 5. Lesson: label each explanation clearly and never present the etic as what people "really" think.

Worked example: a college football game

Apply both views to a familiar event. 1. Emic: fans speak of loyalty, family tradition, school pride and the joy of tailgating with friends; a rival's win can feel like a personal loss. 2. Etic: an analyst may describe the game as a ritual with special dress, chants and sacred spaces; as a way of building group identity; and as a business with ticket, television and merchandise revenue. 3. Compare: the etic terms let the game be compared with festivals or religious rites elsewhere. 4. Check with insiders: many fans would accept "ritual" but reject being reduced to customers. 5. Conclusion: both views add something.

Can anyone fully get inside?

Reaching an insider's view is an aim, never a finished achievement. Every researcher brings their own enculturation, and their gender, age, nationality, race and wealth shape what people tell them and what they notice. When Malinowski's private field diary was published in 1967, readers found frustration and contempt for the people he was studying, a shock that pushed anthropologists to reflect on the gap between ideals and practice. Since the 1960s and 1970s the discipline has asked openly how power, including colonial power, shapes fieldwork. A careful anthropologist therefore treats the insider's view as something to reach for honestly, not something to claim.

One culture, many insiders

There is rarely a single insider's view, because members of a culture disagree. Ruth Benedict's The Chrysanthemum and the Sword (1946) described a unified Japanese national character. It was written in wartime without fieldwork in Japan, using interviews with Japanese Americans, films and documents, and critics have argued that it flattened a varied society into a few traits. Even "insider" is not simple. In 1993 the anthropologist Kirin Narayan asked how "native" a native anthropologist really is: someone studying their own community may share a language but differ in class, education or gender. Everyone is an insider in some ways and an outsider in others.

Collaboration

One answer to these problems is to work with people rather than only on them. From the 1880s, the anthropologist Alice Fletcher worked for decades with Francis La Flesche, a member of the Omaha Nation, and their study The Omaha Tribe (1911) named him as co-author, unusual at the time. Today collaborative ethnography, championed by Luke Eric Lassiter in work with Kiowa singers in Oklahoma, invites community members to shape questions, read drafts and add their own interpretations. Detailed methods for this kind of fieldwork are covered in Participant observation and interviewing.

Good-enough and engaged anthropology

If perfect understanding is impossible, should anthropologists stop trying? Most say no, since giving up would also give up the insight and empathy that cross-cultural research can produce. Nancy Scheper-Hughes called the realistic aim "good-enough ethnography": careful, honest and accountable, though never complete. Close relationships often lead to engaged anthropology, in which researchers support the communities they study. Stuart Kirsch, who worked with Yonggom people in Papua New Guinea, supported their legal campaign in the 1990s against pollution from the Ok Tedi copper and gold mine. Engagement raises its own questions about objectivity, which anthropologists discuss openly.

Why the effort matters

Reaching for insiders' views changes results. Programmes designed only from an etic view, such as a health campaign written far away, often fail because they miss what people care about and how they make decisions. Listening for emic meanings reveals reasons, worries and existing local solutions. Collaboration also corrects errors and shares the benefits of research with the people who made it possible. And for students, the practice of trying to see the world from someone else's position is one of the most useful skills anthropology teaches, at home as much as abroad.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, mixing up emic and etic: emic is the insiders' own categories, etic the analyst's comparative ones. Second, treating the etic view as the "real" explanation and the emic as mere belief. Third, assuming one person can speak for a whole culture. Fourth, thinking that sharing a nationality or language makes someone a complete insider. Fifth, believing that because full understanding is impossible, the attempt is worthless: good-enough ethnography is still valuable.

Key takeaways

Malinowski (Argonauts, 1922) made grasping the insider's view a goal of fieldwork. Emic accounts use insiders' categories; etic accounts use analysts' comparative ones; Pike coined the terms in 1954 and Harris applied them, as in his 1966 analysis of India's sacred cattle. An insider's view is never fully reached, because researchers bring their own position and power. Cultures hold many insider views, as critiques of Benedict (1946) and Narayan's 1993 essay show. Collaboration, from Fletcher and La Flesche (1911) to Lassiter, aims for good-enough ethnography; engaged anthropologists such as Kirsch support the communities they study.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Insider's point of view

How a way of life looks and feels to the people who live it

A goal of research, never fully reached.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A researcher describes a festival as "a ritual reinforcing group identity", while participants say they attend "to honour our ancestors". Which is which?

Question 2 of 5

What is the main criticism of Harris's analysis of India's sacred cattle?

Question 3 of 5

Why can an insider's point of view never be perfectly achieved?

Question 4 of 5

What made The Omaha Tribe (1911) unusual for its time?

Question 5 of 5

What did Kirin Narayan's 1993 question about "native" anthropologists suggest?

← Previous topicNext topic →