Anthropology › Section O · Anthropology of media › Topic O.5
News media, the public sphere, and nationalism
News tells people what happened today, and also what matters and who 'we' are. Anthropologists study how newsrooms work, how news builds publics and nations, and why rival outlets can describe the same country so differently.
News as a worldview
Reading or watching the news teaches more than current events. It also teaches what counts as news, and so, by omission, what does not. Front pages of national papers usually feature presidents, ministers, parliaments and chief executives, presenting politics as a drama between leaders and between nation-states. Economic coverage is often market-centred, following share prices, growth figures and investors' gains and losses, rather than people-centred, following wages, working conditions or environmental damage. Over time, regular audiences learn to see the world through these priorities and to place themselves and their communities within them, usually without noticing that a selection has been made.
Early newspapers
Handwritten newsletters reporting wars, politics and trade circulated in Venice in the 1500s, sold to merchants and officials. In the early 1600s printers in German-speaking lands and the Netherlands began producing regular printed news; a weekly called Relation, published in Strasbourg from 1605, is often cited as the first newspaper. Readers were mostly merchants, officials and other literate townspeople. In the coffeehouses and salons of the 1600s and 1700s, they read papers aloud and argued about them. Newspapers both reported and fed this new culture of public discussion, which is why scholars link the press so closely to the history of public opinion.
The public sphere
The German philosopher Jürgen Habermas, in The Structural Transformation of the Public Sphere (1962; English translation 1989), called this arena the public sphere. Ideally, it is a space where private people come together to discuss issues of common concern and form public opinion, separate both from the household and market and from the state, with its government, police and army. In Habermas's account, newspapers and coffeehouse debate helped build this sphere in western Europe and supported the rise of democratic government. He also argued that it later declined, as commercial mass media and advertising turned citizens who debated into consumers who were addressed.
Critics of the public sphere
Habermas's model is influential but has been sharply criticised. The political theorist Nancy Fraser (1990) pointed out that the coffeehouse public excluded most women, workers and people without property, so its claim to speak for everyone was partial. She argued that excluded groups form counterpublics, such as women's associations, workers' newspapers or Black presses, with their own debates that later feed into wider ones. Anthropologists add that public discussion takes many forms beyond print and coffeehouses, including radio call-in shows, markets, church meetings and online forums. Most scholars now treat the public sphere as an ideal and speak of multiple, overlapping publics.
News and the imagined nation
As the topic Modern nation-states explained, Benedict Anderson argued that print helped people imagine a nation of fellow citizens they would never meet. Newspapers were central. They helped standardise national languages, and readers knew that thousands of others were reading the same stories each morning, a daily shared ritual. Radio, television and websites extended this work. The media anthropologist John Postill (2006) studied the Iban of Sarawak, on the island of Borneo, and showed how Malaysian state media, alongside schooling and development programmes, helped bind them to the nation. According to Postill, state media promoted an approved version of Iban cultural heritage while political autonomy was limited.
State and independent media
State media are print and broadcast outlets wholly or partly owned and financed by the government, and subject to its influence. Independent media are privately owned. In the United States, the professional ideal casts journalists as watchdogs who hold the powerful to account. Yet governments everywhere shape news through briefings, press releases and access to officials. Independent media are not free of pressure either. Owners have political interests, advertisers fund most commercial outlets, and the need for large audiences can reward sensational conflict and rumour over careful reporting. Both kinds of media are shaped by power; the forms of pressure differ.
Worked example: two presses in Ghana
In the 1990s Jennifer Hasty found Ghana's state and private newspapers telling opposite stories. 1. Observation: state papers showed President Jerry Rawlings launching roads and markets; private papers portrayed him as a former coup leader and alleged corruption. 2. Puzzle: journalists on both sides said they defended democracy and objectivity. 3. Fieldwork at the state-owned Daily Graphic: reporters were invited to official events, handed copies of speeches, offered refreshments and given soli, a small cash gift, short for solidarity. 4. Fieldwork at private papers: reporters were shut out by officials and threatened with libel suits, and sources feared speaking openly, so stories relied on anonymous sources and rumour. 5. Conclusion: each press described the state as its journalists experienced it, creating a contentious public sphere.
Worked example: reading a front page
Apply these ideas to a hypothetical lead story: "Markets surge as factory deal is signed." 1. Whose voices? The story quotes a minister and a company director, but no workers or local residents. 2. What frame? It is market-centred, measuring success by share prices and investment. 3. What is missing? Wages, working conditions and the effect on a nearby river. 4. Who benefits from the frame? The officials and investors whose view becomes common sense. 5. Conclusion: the story may be accurate in every detail and still present one perspective as the whole picture, which is why anthropologists study selection, not only accuracy.
Studying audiences
The anthropologist Elizabeth Bird was among the first in her discipline to take news audiences seriously. In For Enquiring Minds (1992) she studied American supermarket tabloids, showing how their stories echoed older folklore and interviewing readers about why they read them. Readers had many reasons, from entertainment to distrust of mainstream institutions, and they read with varied strategies, sometimes sceptically. In The Audience in Everyday Life (2003), she argued that the audience is not a single mass but a varied set of people who select and reuse media as they build identities. Her later work on the Asaba massacre of 1967 in Nigeria studies media and memory.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, treating news as a neutral mirror of events: selection and framing shape what audiences take to be important. Second, assuming state media are always propaganda and private media always free; both face pressures, from officials or from owners, advertisers and the market. Third, forgetting that the classic public sphere excluded many people. Fourth, judging journalists' claims only by what they say, when fieldwork can reveal the working conditions that shape their stories. Fifth, imagining one uniform audience that reads every story the same way.
Key takeaways
News teaches a worldview, often centred on leaders and markets. Newsletters circulated in Venice in the 1500s, and printed weeklies appeared from 1605. Habermas described the public sphere as an arena of public debate between private life and the state; Fraser (1990) showed its exclusions and the role of counterpublics. Newspapers helped build Anderson's imagined communities, and Postill's study of the Iban shows state media binding people to Malaysia. State and independent media face different pressures, as Hasty's fieldwork on Ghana's two presses and soli shows. Bird's research reveals varied, active audiences.
Flashcards
Flashcard
News teaches what counts as important, and what does not
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Which description best matches Habermas's idea of the public sphere?
Question 2 of 5
What was Nancy Fraser's main criticism of the classic public sphere?
Question 3 of 5
In Hasty's fieldwork, why did Ghana's private newspapers rely heavily on anonymous sources and rumour?
Question 4 of 5
A story about a new factory quotes only a minister and a company director and reports share prices. What is the strongest critique?
Question 5 of 5
What did Elizabeth Bird's research on tabloid readers show?
