Anthropology › Section L · Gender and sexuality › Topic L.3

The power of gender: patriarchy and matriarchy

Gender is a system of power as well as of difference. Anthropologists ask how male authority becomes built into families, laws and everyday habits, why no society ruled by women has been documented, and how women exercise power and influence in many societies anyway.

Gender ideology

A gender ideology is a connected set of ideas about what genders exist, how they differ, how they should relate and which of them should hold authority. Such ideas are built into institutions: inheritance rules, marriage customs, religious offices, law and the organisation of work. Much of their force comes from operating below conscious thought. When an arrangement comes to seem like plain common sense, scholars following the Italian theorist Antonio Gramsci call it hegemonic: people may criticise an ideology in words while still taking part in the customs that express it. Anthropologists therefore study what people do, not only what they say they believe.

Worked example: a name at marriage

A Pew Research Center survey published in 2023 found that about 79% of US women in opposite-sex marriages took their husband's last name, about 14% kept their own and about 5% hyphenated, while about 5% of men took their wife's name. Analyse the custom as gender ideology. 1. Measure the asymmetry: 79 divided by 5 is about 16, so women were roughly 16 times as likely as men to change names. 2. Trace its origin: in English common law a wife's legal identity was absorbed into her husband's, a doctrine called coverture. 3. Note change: younger women were more likely to keep their names. 4. Conclusion: a choice that feels personal follows a pattern whose roots lie in older ideas of male household headship.

Patriarchy

Patriarchy is a gender ideology and social system in which senior men hold authority in the household and in public life. Typical features include descent and inheritance through men, wives moving to their husbands' family homes, men's control of land and money, and men's monopoly of political and religious office. Patriarchy varies greatly in form and intensity. It can be moderated by women's control of their own trade income, strong ties to their birth families or laws granting equal rights; in harsher forms it has included practices such as child marriage and the seclusion of women, which reform movements and laws have challenged.

Where did patriarchy come from?

No one knows for certain. Friedrich Engels, in The Origin of the Family, Private Property and the State (1884), linked women's subordination to private property and men's concern to pass it to their own sons. The historian Gerda Lerner, in The Creation of Patriarchy (1986), traced its institutionalisation in early Mesopotamian states. The economist Ester Boserup (1970) observed that plough agriculture, which demands upper-body strength, tended to shift fieldwork to men, and a 2013 study by Alberto Alesina, Paola Giuliano and Nathan Nunn found less equal gender attitudes today among descendants of plough-using societies.

The search for matriarchy

Matriarchy would mean a society in which women, as a group, hold authority over men in the household and in public life. Nineteenth-century writers such as J. J. Bachofen, in Mother Right (1861), and Engels proposed that matriarchy was humanity's original form, later overthrown. The archaeologist Marija Gimbutas, writing up to 1991, argued that peaceful, goddess-worshipping societies of Neolithic Europe were conquered by patriarchal invaders. Most archaeologists find this unsupported: female figurines may have had many meanings, and her conclusions went beyond the evidence. Anthropologists have documented no society in which women as a group rule men, although many show relative equality between genders.

Matrilineal is not matriarchal

A common confusion is between descent and power. In a matrilineal society, people belong to their mother's kin group, and property and titles pass through women. Yet authority over the kin group is often held by men, especially a woman's brother, the maternal uncle of her children. Among the Akan of Ghana, for example, descent is matrilineal and chiefs are men, but the queen mother, a senior woman of the royal lineage, plays a central part in nominating a new chief. Matriliny often gives women security, since they keep strong ties to their birth families and land, but it is not rule by women.

Women with power: three cases

Among the Haudenosaunee (Iroquois) of northeastern North America, clan mothers have long chosen the men who serve as chiefs and could remove those who failed their duties; women historically managed longhouses and fields. The Minangkabau of West Sumatra, in Indonesia, are often described as the largest matrilineal society in the world: ancestral land and houses pass from mother to daughter, and this custom, called adat, is combined with Islam. Peggy Reeves Sanday (2002) argued that they understand matriarchy as maternal care at the centre of social life, not female rule. Among the Mosuo of southwestern China, partners traditionally live apart and children are raised in their mother's household.

Worked example: classifying a society

A society traces descent through mothers, children inherit land from their mothers, senior women choose which men will lead, and men speak for the group in councils. Is it matriarchal? 1. Descent: through mothers, so the society is matrilineal. 2. Property: women control inheritance of land, a significant source of security and influence. 3. Leadership: men hold the public offices, but women select and can remove them. 4. Compare with the definition: matriarchy requires women as a group to hold authority over men in both household and public life, and here authority is shared. 5. Conclusion: it is matrilineal with substantial female power, close to the Haudenosaunee pattern, but not a matriarchy.

Power in everyday life

Recent anthropologists study less the origins of patriarchy and more how people live within and against it. In Veiled Sentiments (1986), Lila Abu-Lughod described Awlad 'Ali Bedouin communities in Egypt's Western Desert, where a public code of honour expected self-control, yet women and young men expressed love, grief and vulnerability in short oral poems. In Politics of Piety (2005), Saba Mahmood studied women in a mosque movement in Cairo and argued that agency is not only resistance: women cultivating religious discipline were pursuing their own goals. Both studies warn against portraying women in patriarchal societies as passive victims.

Patriarchy in public life

Formal politics remains largely male-dominated worldwide. According to the Inter-Parliamentary Union, women held about 27.5% of seats in national parliaments at the start of 2026. That means about 275 of every 1,000 seats, so reaching parity would require about 225 more women per 1,000 seats. A few countries have passed parity: Rwanda, whose 2003 constitution reserves at least 30% of decision-making posts for women, has had women in more than 60% of its lower-house seats. Such figures measure one kind of power; influence in households, lineages, markets and religion may follow different patterns.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, equating matrilineal with matriarchal: descent through women often coexists with male authority. Second, assuming that ancient matriarchies have been proven; the archaeological case is weak. Third, treating patriarchy as one uniform system rather than a range of forms and intensities. Fourth, portraying women in patriarchal societies as passive, ignoring poetry, piety, trade and kin networks as sources of influence. Fifth, assuming that customs people choose freely, such as name changes, are free of ideology. Sixth, using tourist labels such as kingdom of women for the Mosuo instead of describing their family system accurately.

Key takeaways

A gender ideology is built into institutions and becomes hegemonic when it seems like common sense. Patriarchy places senior men in authority and varies widely; explanations for its origins include private property (Engels), early states (Lerner) and plough agriculture (Boserup). No society in which women as a group rule men has been documented, and claims of ancient matriarchy are weakly supported. Matrilineal societies such as the Akan and Minangkabau, and Haudenosaunee clan mothers, show women's substantial power without matriarchy. Women held about 27.5% of parliamentary seats worldwide in 2026.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Gender ideology

Connected ideas about genders, their relations and their authority

Built into institutions.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

In a matrilineal society, which statement is most often true?

Question 2 of 5

Pew found about 79% of US wives took their husband's name and about 5% of husbands took their wife's. Roughly how many times as likely were women to change names?

Question 3 of 5

How do most archaeologists assess Marija Gimbutas's theory of matriarchal Neolithic Europe?

Question 4 of 5

A society traces descent through mothers, and senior women choose and can remove male chiefs. How is it best classified?

Question 5 of 5

What did Saba Mahmood's Politics of Piety argue about women in a Cairo mosque movement?

← Previous topicNext topic →