Anthropology › Section L · Gender and sexuality › Topic L.2

Performing gender categories

If gender is not simply dictated by biology, how does it come to feel so natural? Anthropologists study how gender is learned, practised and policed every day, how men's lives are gendered too, and how many societies have recognised more than two gender categories.

Essentialism and naturalisation

Essentialism is the belief that a category of people shares a deep, fixed inner nature that explains how they behave. Gender essentialism produces circular reasoning: when a boy breaks a window, someone says boys will be boys, explaining the act by the category and the category by the act. Anthropologists argue that gender is not so much natural as naturalised, made to seem natural. Because gender is tied to the body, it can feel more inborn than class or religion, even though the content of gender roles varies greatly. Some cultures stress large differences between women and men; others treat them as broadly alike in temperament and ability.

Mead's three societies

Margaret Mead's Sex and Temperament in Three Primitive Societies (1935), a title that reflects the language of its time, compared three peoples of Papua New Guinea. She reported that Arapesh women and men were both expected to be gentle and cooperative, that Mundugumor (now usually called Biwat) women and men were both expected to be assertive, and that among the Tchambuli (Chambri) women were brisk and practical while men were more concerned with art and display. She concluded that temperament is shaped by culture, not fixed by sex. Later fieldwork, such as Deborah Gewertz's among the Chambri in the 1970s and 1980s, supported cultural variation but questioned Mead's neat contrasts.

Gender as performance

The philosopher Judith Butler, in Gender Trouble (1990), argued that gender is performative: it is produced through repeated acts, such as ways of walking, speaking, dressing and caring for the body, that cite shared norms. Gender is not a costume chosen each morning. People are taught the norms of their assigned category from childhood, and those who perform them in unexpected ways may face ridicule, discipline or violence. Repetition makes the categories feel real and natural. For anthropologists, the idea directs attention to how people actually enact, adjust or resist gender ideals in a particular place.

Feminist anthropology and the public sphere

In the early 1970s many women anthropologists noticed that ethnographies described mainly men's activities, often told by male informants to male researchers. The collection Woman, Culture, and Society (1974), edited by Michelle Rosaldo and Louise Lamphere, sought an anthropology of women. Rosaldo argued that women's status tends to be lower where social life is sharply divided between a domestic sphere, assigned to women, and a public sphere of politics and exchange, controlled by men. In the same volume Sherry Ortner asked whether women are widely associated with nature and men with culture. Later scholars criticised both arguments for assuming that women's subordination is universal.

Intersectionality

Gender never operates alone. The legal scholar Kimberlé Crenshaw introduced the term intersectionality in 1989 to describe how race, gender, class and other categories combine to shape people's experiences, so that, for example, Black women may face forms of discrimination that neither race nor gender alone explains. The idea complicated the public and domestic model. In the United States, many women of colour and working-class women have always worked outside their own homes, often as domestic workers in wealthier households, where someone else's private sphere was their workplace. Anthropologists now ask which women, in which circumstances, rather than speaking of women in general.

Men and masculinities

Men were long studied as typical members of their cultures rather than as gendered people. From the 1990s, studies of masculinity asked how men learn and perform manhood. The sociologist Raewyn Connell described hegemonic masculinity, the most honoured way of being a man in a society, which few men fully achieve. In The Meanings of Macho (1996), the anthropologist Matthew Gutmann studied working-class men in a neighbourhood of Mexico City and found that many did childcare and housework, and that the macho stereotype oversimplified men's lives. Masculinity, like femininity, is plural, learned and changing, and it is defined largely in relation to femininity.

Worked example: Aka fathers

In Intimate Fathers (1991), Barry Hewlett reported that fathers among the Aka, forest foragers of the Central African Republic and Republic of the Congo, spend more time holding and caring for infants than fathers in any other society then documented. Explain this cause and effect. 1. Work: Aka couples often hunt together with nets, so husbands and wives spend much of the day side by side. 2. Proximity: fathers are close to their infants for much of the day, making care easy. 3. Values: Aka life is relatively egalitarian, and there is little prestige in avoiding childcare. 4. Lesson: men's involvement in infant care depends on work patterns and values, not on fixed male nature.

More than two genders

Many societies have recognised gender categories beyond woman and man. The anthropologist Serena Nanda has compared such systems in Native North America, South Asia, Polynesia, Southeast Asia and elsewhere. Among many Native nations, people who combined or crossed gender roles held recognised and often respected places, with their own names in each language, such as nádleehí among the Diné (Navajo) and winkte among the Lakota. European observers used the term berdache, now considered offensive. In 1990 Indigenous activists adopted Two-Spirit as a contemporary pan-Indigenous umbrella term. Colonial policies, including boarding schools, suppressed these roles, and many communities are now reclaiming them.

Hijras of South Asia

Hijras are a long-established community in India, Pakistan, Bangladesh and Nepal. Most hijras were assigned male at birth, some are intersex, and many describe themselves as neither man nor woman, or today as transgender women; some prefer the term kinnar. They often live in households led by a guru, a senior hijra who teaches and supports disciples called chelas. Hijras have a traditional ritual role, blessing newborns and newlyweds, often linked to devotion to the goddess Bahuchara Mata. Many also face poverty and discrimination. Courts and governments have recognised a third gender, including Nepal in 2007, Bangladesh in 2013 and India's Supreme Court in 2014.

Worked example: naming the concept

Match each case to a concept from this topic. 1. A teacher excuses a boy's fighting by saying it is in boys' nature. The act is explained by an inner essence: gender essentialism. 2. A teenager practises walking and speaking in ways her friends call feminine, and is teased when she stops. Gender is produced and policed through repeated acts: performativity. 3. A study finds that immigrant women cleaners face different workplace problems from both immigrant men and native-born women. Categories combine: intersectionality. 4. A community recognises a long-standing role for people who are neither men nor women. A multiple gender system.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, treating gender roles as natural because they feel natural; feeling natural is what naturalisation produces. Second, reading performativity as free choice, like picking an outfit, when norms are taught and enforced. Third, assuming all women share the same position, ignoring intersectionality. Fourth, treating men as ungendered. Fifth, using outdated or outsider terms such as berdache, or treating Two-Spirit as an ancient word rather than a term adopted in 1990. Sixth, assuming that recognition of a third gender means full equality; hijras face serious discrimination. Seventh, exoticising multiple-gender roles instead of describing them as communities describe themselves.

Key takeaways

Gender essentialism explains behaviour by a supposed inner nature; anthropologists see gender as naturalised. Mead (1935) argued that temperament is shaped by culture, though later work questioned her contrasts. Butler (1990) described gender as performative, produced by repeated, enforced acts. Feminist anthropology examined women's lives and the public and domestic divide, later refined by intersectionality (Crenshaw, 1989). Masculinities are plural and learned, as Gutmann and Hewlett showed. Many societies recognise more than two genders, including Two-Spirit people in Native North America and hijras in South Asia, recognised legally in several countries.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Gender essentialism

Belief that a gender shares a fixed inner nature explaining behaviour

Boys will be boys.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A parent says a son's rough play is just because he is a boy. Which concept does this illustrate?

Question 2 of 5

What did Judith Butler mean by calling gender performative?

Question 3 of 5

Why did Barry Hewlett find that Aka fathers do so much infant care?

Question 4 of 5

Which statement about the term Two-Spirit is accurate?

Question 5 of 5

What did the idea of intersectionality add to the public and domestic sphere model?

← Previous topicNext topic →