Anthropology › Section D · Evolution, primates, and early hominins › Topic D.6
Origin and classification of primates
The primate story begins soon after the dinosaurs disappeared, about 66 million years ago. Reading it means thinking in deep time, dating rocks and bones, and classifying fossils from teeth and fragments.
Thinking in deep time
Earth is about 4.6 billion years old, and geologists divide its history into eons, eras, periods and epochs. Primate history belongs to the Cenozoic era, which began about 66 million years ago (abbreviated Ma, for mega-annum) after the mass extinction that ended the age of non-avian dinosaurs. Its epochs, with approximate start dates, are the Palaeocene (66 Ma), Eocene (56 Ma), Oligocene (34 Ma), Miocene (23 Ma), Pliocene (5.3 Ma), Pleistocene (2.6 Ma) and Holocene (about 11,700 years ago). Each epoch has its characteristic primates, and climate change across them, especially cooling and drying after the Eocene, reshaped where primates could live.
What fossils are and why they are rare
A fossil is any preserved trace of past life: bones and teeth turned to stone, impressions, footprints or even burrows. Most organisms rot or are scavenged; fossilisation needs rapid burial, often in river silt, lake mud, cave deposits or volcanic ash. Teeth, made of hard enamel, survive best, which is why many fossil primate species are known mainly from jaws and teeth. Forest floors, where many primates lived, are acidic and rarely preserve bone. As a result the record is patchy: whole lineages are known from a handful of specimens, and new finds regularly change the picture.
Relative dating
Relative dating places finds in order without giving ages in years. Stratigraphy rests on the law of superposition: in undisturbed layers, or strata, lower layers were laid down first and are older. Biostratigraphy uses fossils of fast-evolving animals to match layers between sites; in eastern Africa, the changing species of fossil pigs have long been used this way. If a primate fossil lies with a pig species known elsewhere only from a certain interval, it probably dates to that interval too. Relative methods fail where layers have been folded, eroded or dug through, so they work best alongside absolute dating.
Absolute dating
Absolute, or chronometric, methods give an age in years with a margin of error. Most rely on radioactive decay, which proceeds at a steady rate measured by the half-life, the time for half of a radioactive isotope to decay. Radiocarbon dating measures carbon-14, half-life about 5,730 years, in once-living material, and works only back to about 50,000 years. For primate fossils, far older, scientists date volcanic layers by potassium-argon or argon-argon dating: potassium-40 decays, partly to argon-40 gas, with a half-life of about 1.25 billion years. Thermoluminescence measures energy that minerals store from natural radiation after being heated or buried, and reaches back a few hundred thousand years.
Worked example: the limits of radiocarbon
A bone retains one eighth of its original carbon-14. How old is it, and could radiocarbon date a 30-million-year-old primate? 1. Count half-lives: one half, one quarter, one eighth is three half-lives. 2. Multiply: \(3 \times 5730 = 17{,}190\) years, so about 17,000 years. 3. Test the limit: the fraction left after \(t\) years is \(\left(\frac{1}{2}\right)^{t/5730}\). After 50,000 years that is about 0.0024, or 0.24%, already too little to measure reliably. 4. Conclude: after 30 million years no measurable carbon-14 remains, so radiocarbon is useless for primate origins; potassium-argon dating of volcanic rock is used instead.
Worked example: bracketing a fossil
A fossil jaw lies in sediment between two volcanic ash layers. The ash below dates by argon-argon to about 3.40 Ma and the ash above to about 3.20 Ma. How old is the jaw? 1. Apply superposition: the jaw is above the lower ash, so it is younger than about 3.40 Ma. 2. It is below the upper ash, so it is older than about 3.20 Ma. 3. Combine: the jaw dates to between about 3.40 and 3.20 Ma. 4. Check the assumptions: the layers must be undisturbed and the jaw must not have been washed in from elsewhere. Bracketing like this is how many East African fossils are dated.
The first primates
The Palaeocene has the earliest primate-like mammals, the plesiadapiforms. One of the oldest, Purgatorius, is known from teeth and ankle bones in Montana, about 65 Ma. A 2015 study of its ankle bones argued that it climbed in trees, though plesiadapiforms lacked the forward-facing eyes of later primates, and researchers debate whether it was a true primate or a close relative. In the warm Eocene, primates of modern type appear across North America, Europe, Asia and Africa: the lemur-like adapoids and the tarsier-like omomyoids, with nails and a bony postorbital bar. When climates cooled after the Eocene, primates largely vanished from North America and Europe, though apes later returned to Europe.
Monkeys appear
Possible early anthropoids, such as Eosimias from China, about 45 Ma, suggest that monkeys may have originated in Asia, though this is debated. The richest early record comes from the Fayum in Egypt, dated to about 37 to 30 Ma. Fossils are classified largely by teeth, using the dental formula: the number of incisors, canines, premolars and molars in one quarter of the jaw. Catarrhines, including humans, have 2.1.2.3, or 32 teeth; platyrrhines usually have 2.1.3.3, or 36. Fayum parapithecids kept three premolars, while propliopithecids such as Aegyptopithecus, about 30 Ma, had the catarrhine formula. Monkeys reached South America, probably by rafting from Africa, by roughly 36 Ma.
The age of apes
The Miocene was a heyday for apes, with far more species than today. Proconsul, from East Africa about 20 Ma, had no tail but walked on all fours along branches, a generalised early ape. Later apes spread into Europe and Asia. Sivapithecus, from South Asia about 12 to 8.5 Ma, has a face strikingly like an orangutan's and is widely seen as related to the orangutan lineage. Fossils of the ancestors of African apes are scarce, perhaps because forests preserve bone poorly, but finds such as Nakalipithecus from Kenya, about 10 Ma, and Ouranopithecus from Greece, about 9 Ma, are candidates. The lineage leading to humans emerges at the end of the Miocene, the subject of The earliest hominins.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, using radiocarbon for ancient fossils: it reaches back only about 50,000 years. Second, treating relative dates as ages in years: superposition gives order, not numbers. Third, assuming the oldest fossil found is the first member of a group: the record is patchy, so origins are usually older than the earliest find. Fourth, thinking primates descend from living lemurs or monkeys: living species are cousins, not ancestors. Fifth, miscounting the dental formula: it describes one quarter of the jaw, so multiply by four for the total.
Key takeaways
Primate evolution unfolds in the Cenozoic, from about 66 Ma, across the Palaeocene, Eocene, Oligocene, Miocene and Pliocene. Fossils are rare and biased towards teeth. Stratigraphy and biostratigraphy give relative order; radiometric methods give ages, with radiocarbon limited to about 50,000 years and potassium-argon used for millions of years. Plesiadapiforms such as Purgatorius come first, then Eocene adapoids and omomyoids, then anthropoids classified by dental formula in the Fayum, then Miocene apes such as Proconsul and Sivapithecus. The hominin story begins at the end of the Miocene.
Flashcards
Flashcard
The current era, from about 66 million years ago
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
A charcoal sample keeps one quarter of its original carbon-14. About how old is it?
Question 2 of 5
Why is potassium-argon dating, rather than radiocarbon, used for a 30-million-year-old primate fossil?
Question 3 of 5
A fossil lies between an ash layer dated to 2.5 Ma below it and one dated to 2.3 Ma above it. What can be concluded?
Question 4 of 5
A fossil jaw from the Fayum shows two premolars in each quarter of the jaw, so its tooth count per quarter reads 2.1.2.3. What does this suggest?
Question 5 of 5
Why might the oldest known fossil of a group be younger than the group's real origin?
