Anthropology › Section P · Art, music, and sport › Topic P.4

Representation and performance

A raised fist on an Olympic podium, a rap verse or a painted wall can say more in a moment than a speech. Anthropologists study performances as public acts that represent identities and can challenge the powerful, and they ask who gets to represent whom.

Showing and doing

Art, music and sport are not only made; they are performed before audiences, and performance both shows something and does something. A national anthem at a match represents the nation and also asks everyone present to stand inside it. A protest song describes injustice and also gathers listeners into a movement. Anthropologists therefore study two linked questions. Representation asks how groups and identities are portrayed, and by whom. Performance asks what public, framed actions accomplish for performers and audiences. Both questions lead back to power: who controls the stage, the image and the microphone.

Theories of performance

In the 1950s the anthropologist Milton Singer, studying Madras in India, described cultural performances, such as festivals, recitations and plays, as occasions in which a society displays itself to itself and to visitors. Victor Turner developed the idea of social drama, a sequence of breach, crisis, redress and reintegration, and stressed the liminal phase in which ordinary rules are suspended; his later work, such as From Ritual to Theatre (1982), joined him with the theatre scholar Richard Schechner in founding performance studies. The sociologist Erving Goffman's The Presentation of Self in Everyday Life (1959) extended the idea of performance to ordinary social interaction.

Who represents whom?

Representation becomes contested when one group portrays another. For decades many US sports teams used Native American names, images and mock rituals. Many Native nations and organisations objected that these mascots froze living peoples into stereotypes and turned sacred items such as feathered headdresses into costumes. In 2005 the American Psychological Association called for retiring American Indian mascots, citing harm to Native young people. The Cleveland baseball team became the Guardians in 2021, and Washington's football team, which dropped its name in 2020, became the Commanders in 2022.

Worked example: analysing a mascot debate

A school debates its Native American mascot. Analyse the debate anthropologically. 1. Representation: who created the image? Usually non-Native people, so it shows outsiders' ideas of Native life rather than Native self-representation. 2. Performance: fans' chants and costumes enact a stereotype at every game. 3. Voices: supporters say it honours Native people; many Native nations and organisations reply that honour cannot be granted without consent. 4. Effects: psychological research cited in 2005 linked such images to harm among Native young people. 5. Conclusion: the central question is who has the right to represent a people, which favours the voices of those represented.

Walls that speak

Writing on walls is ancient: graffiti preserved at Pompeii, buried in 79 CE, records election slogans, jokes and insults, and helps historians judge how widely ordinary Romans could read. Modern graffiti writing grew in Philadelphia and New York in the late 1960s and 1970s, when young people tagged names on walls and subway trains. Murals have also carried political messages, from the Mexican muralists of the 1920s, such as Diego Rivera, to the murals of Belfast. The English street artist known as Banksy, whose identity is unconfirmed, began in Bristol in the 1990s. To some, graffiti is vandalism; to others, a claim on public space by people otherwise unheard.

Hip-hop as voice

Hip-hop is usually traced to a party held by DJ Kool Herc in the Bronx, New York, on 11 August 1973. It grew among Black and Latino young people as four elements: DJing, MCing or rapping, breaking and graffiti. Lyrics often commented on poverty, policing and racism, as in Public Enemy's work of the late 1980s. Hip-hop then spread worldwide and was localised; the anthropologist Ian Condry's Hip-Hop Japan (2006) studied Tokyo clubs where artists reworked it in Japanese. Native American artists such as Frank Waln, a Sicangu Lakota rapper, use it to tell their nations' stories. In 2018 Kendrick Lamar's album DAMN. won the Pulitzer Prize for Music.

Sport as protest

Athletes have long used their visibility to protest. In 1967 the boxer Muhammad Ali refused induction into the US Army, citing his religious beliefs and opposition to the Vietnam War, and was stripped of his title. At the 1968 Olympics in Mexico City, the American sprinters Tommie Smith and John Carlos, gold and bronze medallists in the 200 metres, each lifted a fist in a black glove on the podium. In 2016 the American football quarterback Colin Kaepernick began sitting, and then kneeling, during the national anthem to protest police killings of Black Americans and racial injustice. Each act turned a ceremony of national unity into a stage for criticism, and each brought heavy penalties for the athlete at the time.

Worked example: the 1968 podium

Read the Smith and Carlos protest as a performance. 1. Setting: a medal ceremony, a ritual of national pride watched worldwide. 2. Symbols: raised black-gloved fists; shoeless black socks, which the athletes later said represented Black poverty; Carlos's beads, for victims of lynching. 3. Allies: the Australian silver medallist Peter Norman wore a badge of the Olympic Project for Human Rights in support. 4. Consequences: the International Olympic Committee had both Americans suspended from their team and sent home. 5. Later meaning: the image became an icon, and in 2019 both were inducted into the US Olympic and Paralympic Hall of Fame. Performance can change meaning over time.

Performing culture for visitors

Performances staged for tourists raise their own questions. The sociologist Dean MacCannell (1973) described staged authenticity: tourists seek the real culture behind the scenes, and hosts present a version of backstage life designed for them. Yet staged performance is not necessarily false. In Hawaii, hula was suppressed by missionaries in the nineteenth century and later commercialised for tourists, but during the Hawaiian Renaissance of the 1970s Native Hawaiians revived ancient forms, and competitions such as the Merrie Monarch Festival in Hilo now celebrate them. The same dance can be a tourist show, a sacred practice and an assertion of identity.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, treating art, music and sport as neutral entertainment, when they represent identities and can challenge power. Second, assuming a representation is respectful because its makers intend honour; consent and self-representation matter. Third, seeing graffiti or hip-hop only as vandalism or noise, missing their meaning to those who create them. Fourth, assuming a performance has one fixed meaning; the 1968 podium was condemned and later honoured. Fifth, assuming anything staged for tourists must be fake, as the revival of hula shows.

Key takeaways

Performances both show and do, so anthropologists study representation and performance together. Singer's cultural performances, Turner's social drama and Goffman's everyday performance give tools for analysis. Native mascots show contests over who may represent a people; the Cleveland Guardians (2021) and Washington Commanders (2022) changed names. Graffiti, from Pompeii to Banksy, and hip-hop, from the Bronx in 1973 to Tokyo and Lakota artists, claim a voice. Smith and Carlos in 1968 and Kaepernick in 2016 turned ceremonies into protest. Staged authenticity complicates tourism, yet hula's revival shows staged forms can carry real identity.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Representation

How groups and identities are portrayed, and by whom

Leads to questions of power.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

What do anthropologists mean when they say a performance both shows and does something?

Question 2 of 5

In analysing a Native American mascot, which question do anthropologists treat as central?

Question 3 of 5

Which statement about the 1968 Olympic podium protest is accurate?

Question 4 of 5

What did Ian Condry's Hip-Hop Japan show?

Question 5 of 5

Why does the revival of hula complicate MacCannell's idea of staged authenticity?

← Previous topicNext topic →