Anthropology › Section H · Political anthropology › Topic H.5

Resistance, revolution, and social movements

Politics does not happen only in parliaments. People grumble, drag their feet, march, occupy, petition and sometimes overthrow governments. Anthropologists study these actions up close, asking what people resist, how they do it and what their struggles reveal about power.

Politics outside government

Much of politics happens outside formal institutions, when people respond to conditions they find unjust. A social movement is an organised, sustained effort by a group outside government to bring about, or to block, social change. The Sociology course examines why movements arise and how they mobilise resources and frame issues. Anthropology adds close, long-term fieldwork: living alongside activists, villagers or workers to understand how they see their situation, what they believe is at stake, and how their actions fit into local histories, religions and ways of life.

Resistance, reform and revolution

Anthropologists distinguish three broad aims, which a single movement may move between. Resistance is the expression of disagreement with the social order, whether open or hidden, without necessarily proposing a specific remedy: protesting an election result or a new law, for instance. Reform seeks particular changes within the existing system, such as new rules for police training or stricter pollution limits. Revolution replaces one social order with another, changing the structure of the political system itself, whether by peaceful or violent means. The labels describe goals, not methods.

Parties and movements

In democracies, political parties are movements that have become formal institutions: they contest elections, form governments and write laws. Most social movements stay informal and work from outside, often because people feel formal channels do not represent them. Political scientist Martin Gilens (2012), for example, found that US federal policy tracked the preferences of affluent citizens far more closely than those of low-income citizens when the two disagreed, a finding other scholars debate. Movements often begin with a triggering event, such as a disaster or a violent incident, that people believe officials or media have misrepresented.

Everyday resistance

Not all resistance is public. The political scientist and anthropologist James C. Scott lived in a Malaysian rice-farming village, which he called Sedaka, from 1978 to 1980. After new combine harvesters cut the work available to poor families, he found few protests, but plenty of quiet resistance: foot-dragging, gossip about stingy landowners, petty theft of grain, feigned ignorance and sabotage. In Weapons of the Weak (1985) he argued that such everyday resistance is the most common politics of people who cannot risk open revolt. In 1990 he added the idea of hidden transcripts: the critiques that subordinates voice among themselves, behind the public deference they show the powerful.

Worked example: is it resistance?

A fieldworker on a hypothetical plantation records four acts. Decide which count as everyday resistance in Scott's sense. 1. Workers privately mock a supervisor's speeches and give him an unflattering nickname: this is a hidden transcript, criticism kept out of the powerful's hearing, so yes. 2. Pickers slow down whenever the piece rate is cut: deliberate foot-dragging aimed at the terms of work, so yes. 3. A worker arrives late because the bus broke down: no intention to challenge power, so no. 4. A worker steals from a fellow worker's locker: it targets an equal, not the plantation's control, so no. 5. Check the test: Scott's examples share intention, a target in the structure of domination and a low risk of open confrontation.

The romance of resistance

Lila Abu-Lughod, who lived with Awlad 'Ali Bedouin communities in Egypt's Western Desert from the late 1970s, warned in 1990 against a 'romance of resistance': celebrating every act of defiance as proof that people are free and heroic. Young women's secret love poetry and refusals of arranged marriages did challenge elders. But she suggested using resistance as a diagnostic of power: each form of resistance shows what kind of power is being opposed. When young women adopted consumer fashions to resist elders, they were drawn into new dependencies on markets and the state. Resistance to one power can tie people more closely to another.

Revolution and its uncertain outcomes

The Arab Spring shows how quickly resistance can become revolutionary, and how varied the results can be. In December 2010 a Tunisian street vendor set himself on fire after harassment by officials; protests spread and the president fled in January 2011. Protests, amplified by social media, spread to Egypt, Libya, Yemen, Syria, Bahrain and beyond, demanding participation and fairer distribution of wealth. Outcomes diverged. Tunisia adopted a democratic constitution in 2014, though in 2021 its president suspended parliament and expanded his own powers. Egypt's elected president was removed by the military in 2013. Libya, Syria and Yemen descended into civil wars. Revolutions change structures, but not always in the direction their first participants hoped.

Law, harmony and control

The legal anthropologist Laura Nader began fieldwork in the Zapotec town of Talea, in Oaxaca, Mexico, in the late 1950s. Its courts sought harmony: they brought disputants together to reach a balanced settlement rather than to assign blame. In Harmony Ideology (1990), Nader traced this ideal partly to Spanish colonial and missionary teaching that valued peaceful submission. Taleans, she argued, had turned it to their own purposes, settling disputes locally to keep outside authorities away. In the United States, she argued, pressure for harmony and confidential settlements can silence people seeking justice against powerful corporations. The same ideal can serve resistance or control.

Indigenous and environmental movements

Many movements defend land, water and sacred places. In 2004 thousands of people in Cajamarca, Peru, protested plans to expand gold mining onto Cerro Quilish, a mountain that supplies the region's water and that many residents regard as a living, sacred being; the permit was withdrawn that year. Anthropologist Fabiana Li (2015) showed companies answering such protests with technical fixes and expert reports. In 2016 the Standing Rock Sioux Tribe and thousands of supporters camped near the Dakota Access Pipeline route, citing risks to drinking water and sacred sites. The pipeline began operating in 2017, and legal challenges over its permits continued for years afterwards.

Worked example: two ways of seeing a mountain

Analyse the Cerro Quilish conflict through the questions an anthropologist would ask. 1. What did each side say was at stake? The company described an ore body and the engineering needed to protect water supplies; many residents and activists described a sacred, living mountain and the source of their water. 2. How did each side argue? The company relied on technical studies; protesters used marches, road blockades and religious language. 3. Why did technical answers not settle it? They addressed only part of what protesters valued, and residents distrusted the experts. 4. What does it reveal about power? Deciding whose knowledge counts is itself political. 5. Conclusion: the movement combined environmental reform, defence of livelihoods and resistance to outside control.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, resistance need not be public or organised: everyday resistance and hidden transcripts count. Second, revolution means changing the structure of the political order, not simply holding a large protest. Third, do not romanticise resistance; ask what power it reveals and what new dependencies it may create. Fourth, a movement's aims are not fixed: resistance can grow into reform or revolution, and revolutions can be reversed. Fifth, describe contested movements neutrally, setting out what each side claims and the evidence, rather than taking a side.

Key takeaways

Social movements are organised efforts outside government to promote or resist change, with aims ranging from resistance through reform to revolution. Parties are movements turned into institutions. James Scott showed that everyday resistance and hidden transcripts are the politics of people who cannot risk open revolt; Lila Abu-Lughod urged using resistance as a diagnostic of power. The Arab Spring shows revolutions' uncertain outcomes. Laura Nader showed how harmony ideology can serve resistance or control. Indigenous and environmental movements, from Cerro Quilish to Standing Rock, contest whose knowledge and values count.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Social movement

An organised, sustained effort outside government to promote or block social change

Consistent with the Sociology course definition.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A campaign demands that a city adopt new rules on police use of force, while keeping the existing city government. Which aim does this campaign have?

Question 2 of 5

In James Scott's Malaysian village, which act is the clearest example of everyday resistance?

Question 3 of 5

What did Lila Abu-Lughod mean by using resistance 'as a diagnostic of power'?

Question 4 of 5

Which statement about the outcomes of the Arab Spring is accurate?

Question 5 of 5

Why, according to Fabiana Li's research, did technical fixes fail to settle disputes such as the Cerro Quilish protest?

← Previous topicNext topic →