Anthropology › Section I · Social inequalities › Topic I.1
Theories of inequity and inequality
Why do some people have more wealth, respect and power than others, and is that ever fair? Anthropology's answers have changed dramatically, from nineteenth-century theories that justified hierarchy to modern frameworks that trace how power, history and everyday habits produce it.
Equal, ranked and stratified societies
A division of labour is not in itself a hierarchy; hierarchy appears when some roles carry more power and prestige. Morton Fried (1967) offered a classic comparison. In egalitarian societies, such as many forager bands, there are as many positions of prestige as people able to fill them, and no one controls others' access to basic resources. In rank societies, prestige positions are limited, as with Polynesian chiefly rank, but everyone still has access to land and food. In stratified societies, some groups have privileged access to basic resources while others do not. Social stratification is the ordering of groups into such ranked layers, by class, caste, race, gender, religion or descent.
Inequality, inequity and oppression
Two similar words do different jobs. Inequality is simply an unequal distribution of resources, such as income, land or schooling. Inequity is an unequal distribution produced by an unjust power imbalance, often the result of past or present discrimination against particular groups. A surgeon earning more than a trainee may be defended as fair; a group receiving less because of who they are is inequitable. Oppression is the unjust exercise of power, open or hidden, to control or harm whole groups of people. Anthropologists ask of any gap: how was it produced, who decided, and who benefits?
Levels of inequality
Inequality operates at levels that reinforce each other. Interpersonal inequality arises from personal bias in everyday encounters. Institutional inequality comes from the policies and practices of organisations such as schools, banks, employers or governments. Structural inequality is the accumulated effect of institutional decisions across a whole society and its history, which makes it pervasive and hard to change. Systemic inequality is the combination of all three, often named with an '-ism': racism, sexism, classism. Systematic oppression is deliberate mistreatment carried out methodically. Systemic oppression is built into the workings of a whole system, so it can continue even when no one intends it.
Worked example: inequality or inequity?
Two hypothetical school districts in one state spend different amounts per pupil: District A spends $14,000 and District B $10,500. 1. Measure the gap: \(14{,}000 - 10{,}500 = \$3{,}500\) per pupil, so A spends \(14{,}000 \div 10{,}500 \approx 1.33\) times as much. 2. Scale it up: for a class of 25, the gap is \(25 \times 3{,}500 = \$87{,}500\) a year. 3. Ask what causes it: both districts rely on local property taxes, and B's property values are low. 4. Ask how that arose: suppose 1930s federal lending maps marked B's neighbourhoods high risk because of residents' race, starving them of loans for decades. 5. Conclude: the spending gap is an inequality; its roots in discriminatory policy make it an inequity, and a structural one.
Theories that justified hierarchy
Anthropology's early theories often upheld inequality. Herbert Spencer, who coined 'survival of the fittest' in 1864, applied evolution to societies and treated the success of some classes and nations as proof of their fitness; this view became known as social Darwinism. Within anthropology, E. B. Tylor (1871) and Lewis Henry Morgan (1877) proposed unilinear cultural evolution, in which all societies pass through the same stages, which Morgan called 'savagery', 'barbarism' and 'civilisation'. These terms, quoted here only as historical usage, ranked peoples and made colonial conquest look like progress. From the early 1900s, Franz Boas and his students argued that cultures must be understood in their own histories, not on a single ladder.
Functionalism and conflict theory
Functionalists, following Émile Durkheim, asked what each social arrangement does for society as a whole. Bronisław Malinowski and A. R. Radcliffe-Brown studied how institutions maintained order; applied to inequality, functionalism suggests ranks reward those most useful to the group, like the Davis-Moore thesis in the Sociology course. Critics called it ahistorical, ignoring the colonial forces shaping the societies studied. Conflict theory, rooted in Karl Marx, sees hierarchy as the source of conflict: the bourgeoisie own the means of production and the proletariat sell their labour. W. E. B. Du Bois, in his fieldwork study The Philadelphia Negro (1899), showed that race also structured work and opportunity, and that Black Philadelphians were divided by class, not one uniform group.
Hegemony and the state apparatus
Why do disadvantaged people often accept the arrangements that disadvantage them? The Italian Marxist Antonio Gramsci, writing his Prison Notebooks in a Fascist jail from 1929 to 1935, answered with hegemony: dominant groups keep power less by force than by spreading values and beliefs, through schools, religion, media and everyday life, until their view seems like common sense. The French philosopher Louis Althusser (1970) distinguished repressive state apparatuses, which work by force (police, courts, prisons, army), from ideological state apparatuses, which work by ideas (schools, churches, families, media, the arts). Ideological institutions can also nurture alternative ideas, becoming sites of struggle.
Biopolitics and necropolitics
Michel Foucault used biopolitics for the ways states divide, count and categorise populations, by citizenship, health, race or religion, in order to manage them. Nolan Kline (2019), for example, found in the US South that immigration policing made many undocumented immigrants afraid to seek medical care. The Cameroonian philosopher Achille Mbembe extended the idea in 2003 with necropolitics: power over who is exposed to death and whose deaths are treated as acceptable. It helps analyse unequal exposure to violence, neglect and pollution.
Agency within structures
Agency is the capacity to act and make choices, and it is shaped by one's position: more power usually means more options. The sociologist Anthony Giddens (1984) proposed structuration theory: structures guide action, but they exist only because people keep reproducing them, so action can also change them. The French sociologist Pierre Bourdieu used habitus for the ingrained dispositions, tastes and ways of moving and speaking that people absorb from their social position from childhood. Habitus explains why inequality feels natural and persists without force, yet it can shift as circumstances change.
Worked example: one village, three lenses
In a hypothetical farming village, five families own most of the irrigated land, and the landless majority work their fields for wages. 1. A functionalist asks what the arrangement does for the whole village, such as keeping canals maintained, and may see rank as rewarding skill. 2. A conflict theorist sees owners and labourers as classes with opposed interests, and asks how wages and rents move value upwards. 3. A Gramscian asks why labourers accept it: perhaps sermons and school lessons present ownership as a reward for virtue. 4. A practice theorist would study habitus, such as labourers' deference in speech. 5. Compare: each lens reveals something, but the last three ask how the arrangement is kept in place, which the first tends to overlook.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, inequality and inequity are not synonyms: inequity means the gap results from an unjust power imbalance. Second, systemic does not mean systematic; systemic oppression can persist with no one intending it. Third, social Darwinism was not Darwin's theory but Spencer's application of evolutionary ideas to societies. Fourth, hegemony works mainly through consent and common sense, not force. Fifth, agency is not unlimited free will: people choose, but from options shaped by their position.
Key takeaways
Fried distinguished egalitarian, rank and stratified societies. Inequality is an unequal distribution; inequity is one produced by an unjust power imbalance, at interpersonal, institutional, structural and systemic levels. Social Darwinism and unilinear evolution justified hierarchy; functionalism was criticised as ahistorical; conflict theory, extended by Du Bois to race, saw hierarchy as conflict. Gramsci's hegemony, Althusser's state apparatuses, Foucault's biopolitics and Mbembe's necropolitics explain how power is kept. Giddens and Bourdieu show how agency and habitus reproduce and can change structures.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Egalitarian, rank and stratified societies
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Two hypothetical districts spend $13,200 and $9,900 per pupil. What is the yearly spending gap for a class of 30?
Question 2 of 5
What makes an inequality an inequity?
Question 3 of 5
A hiring rule that no one designed to exclude anyone nonetheless keeps a historically excluded group out of jobs, decade after decade. Which term fits best?
Question 4 of 5
Which statement about social Darwinism is accurate?
Question 5 of 5
Labourers in a village accept that landowners deserve their wealth because school lessons and sermons present ownership as a reward for virtue. Which concept best describes this?
