Anthropology › Section L · Gender and sexuality › Topic L.1
Sex, gender, and sexuality in anthropology
Is it a boy or a girl? The question seems simple, but anthropologists find that bodies, roles and desires are organised in strikingly different ways across cultures. Evidence from primates, human biology and archaeology shows how much of what people call natural is shaped by culture.
Three related terms
Anthropologists use sex for biological characteristics such as chromosomes, gonads, hormones and reproductive anatomy. Gender refers to the roles, behaviours, rights and expectations a society attaches to being a woman, a man or another category; it is learned through enculturation and varies across cultures and over time. Gender identity is a person's inner sense of their own gender. Sexuality covers erotic desires, practices and relationships, and sexual orientation is an identity based on whom a person is attracted to. The Sociology course topic Sex, gender, identity, and expression defines these terms in detail; this topic asks what anthropology's cross-cultural and biological evidence adds.
Is sex simply natural?
Sex has several layers that usually, but not always, line up. Intersex people are born with variations in chromosomes, gonads, hormones or anatomy that do not fit typical definitions of female or male. Some scholars also argue that the way bodies are sorted is itself shaped by culture. The historian Thomas Laqueur, in Making Sex (1990), argued that European medicine before the eighteenth century often treated women's bodies as inward versions of men's, a one-sex model, before a sharp two-sex model took hold. Others reply that sex categories reflect real reproductive biology. A fair summary is that sex characteristics are biological, while how societies classify and value them is cultural.
Sexuality across cultures
Every society regulates sexuality, but the rules differ widely. A key anthropological finding is that cultures differ in whether sexual practices define a person's identity. In the contemporary United States, a person's orientation is usually treated as a lasting identity, such as gay, lesbian, bisexual or heterosexual. In many other societies, the same practices have been understood as a phase of life, part of a ritual or simply something people do, without implying a distinct kind of person. Heteronormativity is the assumption that heterosexuality is the natural default. Anthropologists study it as one cultural pattern among many, while recognising that some societies are far less tolerant than others.
Primatology and its biases
Researchers have long looked to other primates for clues about natural gender roles. Early field studies of the 1950s and 1960s, many focused on savanna baboons, described societies organised around male competition and dominance, with females in the background. Later work changed the picture. In 1974 the primatologist Jeanne Altmann showed that observers recorded the conspicuous actions of dominant males most often, and she proposed systematic sampling methods that followed each animal for set periods. Researchers such as Barbara Smuts then documented how female kin groups, female choice of mates and male-female friendships shape social life. Observer expectations had shaped the original data.
Chimpanzees and bonobos
Humans' closest living relatives are chimpanzees and bonobos, which share almost all of their DNA with us and with each other, yet differ sharply. Chimpanzee groups are typically dominated by males, have strict hierarchies and sometimes engage in lethal raids on neighbouring groups. Among bonobos, alliances of females often hold the upper hand, conflict between groups is rarely lethal, and frequent friendly physical contact, including sexual behaviour, seems to ease tension and build bonds. If two such close relatives differ this much, neither can model what is natural for people.
Sexual dimorphism
Sexual dimorphism is the difference in size or form between males and females of a species. Among apes it ranges widely. Male gorillas are roughly twice the mass of females, while male and female gibbons are close in size. Humans show modest dimorphism, with men on average somewhat larger and heavier than women, and with a great deal of overlap. Some researchers link strong dimorphism to intense male competition for mates, and weak dimorphism to pair-bonding. The biological anthropologist Adrienne Zihlman cautioned that each ape species combines anatomy and behaviour in its own pattern, so body size alone does not predict how a species, or humans, will behave.
Worked example: testing a claim about nature
Someone argues that men are naturally dominant over women because male chimpanzees dominate females. Evaluate the argument. 1. Identify the reasoning: it assumes that one related species shows what is natural for humans. 2. Test the premise: bonobos are equally closely related, yet females often hold the upper hand, so the choice of chimpanzees is selective. 3. Consider human evidence: human dimorphism is modest, and gender relations vary greatly across societies, from relatively equal gatherer-hunters to strongly male-dominated agrarian states. 4. Check the logic: even a common pattern would not show that it is fixed or desirable. 5. Conclusion: the argument fails, because primate evidence shows flexibility rather than a single natural order.
Measuring human differences
Claims of great mental differences between men and women were once used to deny women votes and university places. The biologist Anne Fausto-Sterling, in Myths of Gender (1985), found that many such studies had weak methods or tiny effects. The psychologist Janet Hyde's gender similarities hypothesis (2005) reviewed 46 meta-analyses and concluded that men and women are similar on most, but not all, psychological measures; large differences appeared in a few areas, such as some aspects of motor performance. Cross-cultural studies add that where girls and boys are raised with similar freedoms, some measured gaps shrink, which points to learning as well as biology.
Worked example: reading a meta-analysis
Hyde's 2005 review used 124 effect sizes, each measuring the gap between average scores of men and women on one trait. She found that 30% were close to zero and another 48% were small. Interpret this. 1. Close to zero: 30% of 124 is about 37 effect sizes. 2. Small: 48% of 124 is about 60. 3. Combined: 30% + 48% = 78%, or about 97 of the 124. 4. Remainder: about 27 effect sizes were moderate or larger, so some real differences exist. 5. Conclusion: an average gap describes groups, not individuals, and the evidence supports similarity on most traits, not identical sexes or opposite ones.
Archaeology and the origins of gender
In the 1960s the man the hunter model, discussed in Gathering and hunting, cast male hunting as the force behind tools, language and male dominance. In the 1970s sociobiology, launched by E. O. Wilson's Sociobiology (1975), offered evolutionary explanations of gender roles that became popular. Feminist archaeologists replied that the record is biased: stone spear points survive, while digging sticks, baskets and baby slings, likely made and used largely by women, decay. Evidence of women hunters in the past, together with the importance of gathering among recent foragers, suggests that early gender roles were more flexible and varied than the hunting model assumed.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, using sex and gender as if they meant the same thing. Second, assuming that sex categories involve no cultural interpretation, or the opposite error, that biology plays no part. Third, assuming that sexual practices always define an identity, as they often do in the contemporary United States. Fourth, treating one primate species as a model of natural human behaviour. Fifth, reading an average group difference as a description of every individual. Sixth, accepting that the archaeological record shows men's activities mattered more, when organic tools used by women rarely survive.
Key takeaways
Sex refers to biological characteristics, gender to learned roles and expectations, and sexuality to desires, practices and orientation. Sex has several layers, intersex variations exist, and how societies classify bodies is partly cultural. Cultures differ in whether sexual practices define identity. Early primatology reflected observer bias, and chimpanzees and bonobos differ sharply. Human dimorphism is modest. Hyde found 78% of 124 gender differences close to zero or small. The archaeological record favours durable tools, so early gender roles were probably more flexible than once assumed.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Biological characteristics: chromosomes, gonads, hormones, anatomy
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
What did Jeanne Altmann's 1974 work show about early primate field studies?
Question 2 of 5
Why can neither chimpanzees nor bonobos serve as a model of natural human gender relations?
Question 3 of 5
In Hyde's 2005 review of 124 effect sizes, 30% were close to zero and 48% were small. About how many effect sizes were close to zero or small?
Question 4 of 5
Which statement best reflects the anthropological finding about sexuality across cultures?
Question 5 of 5
Why do feminist archaeologists argue that the record may understate women's roles in the past?
