Anthropology › Section D · Evolution, primates, and early hominins › Topic D.2
The science of taxonomy
Before anthropologists can say how humans relate to apes or to fossil ancestors, they need a shared way of naming and grouping living things. Taxonomy supplies it, and deciding where one species ends and another begins turns out to be one of the hardest problems in the field.
Why scientific names exist
Common names change from place to place. A "robin" in Britain is a small, red-breasted songbird; a "robin" in North America is a much larger thrush from a different family. Taxonomy, the science of naming and classifying organisms, removes that confusion by giving every species one name used worldwide. Each named group, at any level, is a taxon (plural taxa). For biological anthropologists the stakes are high: deciding whether a fossil belongs to an existing species or a new one shapes the whole story of human evolution.
Linnaeus and two-part names
The Swedish naturalist Carl Linnaeus set out the modern system in Systema Naturae, first published in 1735; its tenth edition of 1758 is the official starting point for animal names. He gave each species a binomial, a two-part Latin name. The first part is the genus, written with a capital letter; the second is the specific name, written in lower case. Both are printed in italics: Homo sapiens. After the first mention the genus may be shortened to its initial, as in H. sapiens. A third name can mark a subspecies, as in Gorilla gorilla gorilla, the western lowland gorilla.
A hierarchy of ranks
Linnaeus nested groups inside larger groups. Linnaeus himself used kingdom, class, order, genus and species; later scientists added phylum and family, and in 1990 the domain, giving the familiar sequence domain, kingdom, phylum, class, order, family, genus, species. Extra ranks with prefixes such as super-, sub- and infra- fit between them, along with the tribe between family and genus. Each step down shares more features. Every mammal has hair and feeds its young on milk, but only members of the order Primates have the full set of traits described in What is a primate?.
Worked example: classifying humans
Place Homo sapiens in the hierarchy, from the top. 1. Domain Eukarya: our cells have nuclei. 2. Kingdom Animalia and phylum Chordata: we are animals with a backbone. 3. Class Mammalia: hair and milk. 4. Order Primates, suborder Haplorhini and infraorder Simiiformes: monkeys and apes. 5. Superfamily Hominoidea: the apes, tailless. 6. Family Hominidae: the great apes, including us. 7. Subfamily Homininae: African apes. 8. Tribe Hominini: humans and extinct relatives closer to us than to chimpanzees, in the scheme most anthropologists use (some place chimpanzees in Hominini too). 9. Genus Homo, species sapiens. Check the format: genus capitalised, species lower case, both italic in print.
From similarity to ancestry
Linnaeus grouped organisms by visible resemblance and did not think in terms of evolution. Since Darwin, classification is meant to reflect descent: each group should be a clade, an ancestor and all its descendants, as the Biology topic Determining evolutionary relationships explains. This has changed how apes are classified. An older scheme put the great apes in one family and humans alone in another, but genetic evidence shows that chimpanzees are closer to humans than to gorillas or orangutans. A family of great apes without humans would therefore leave out descendants, so Hominidae now includes humans.
The biological species
What is a species? The most widely taught answer, the biological species concept associated with Ernst Mayr in 1942, defines a species as a group of populations whose members actually or potentially interbreed and are reproductively isolated from other such groups. Gene flow holds a species together; reproductive isolation keeps it apart from others. The idea works well for living animals that meet in the wild. It cannot be tested on fossils, which cannot be bred, or on organisms that reproduce without sex, so scientists have proposed more than 20 alternative definitions.
Other species definitions
The ecological species concept stresses natural selection: a species occupies its own niche, and selection maintains its boundaries even when some genes cross them. The phylogenetic species concept defines a species as the smallest group that shares at least one unique, inherited trait, which suits fossils because traits can be seen in bone. The mate recognition concept, proposed by the biologist Hugh Paterson, defines a species by a shared system for recognising mates, such as a distinctive song or display. Each definition answers a different question, so they can disagree about the same organisms.
When species meet: hybrid zones
Real populations do not always respect neat boundaries. A hybrid zone is a place where two species meet and produce mixed offspring. In the Awash valley of Ethiopia, olive baboons and hamadryas baboons, which differ in appearance and social organisation, interbreed where their ranges overlap, yet both remain distinct elsewhere. Under a strict biological definition they might count as one species; under ecological or phylogenetic definitions they can count as two. Genomes show that such mixing is common among primates, including our own ancestors, as the topic Tracking genomes: the human story discusses.
Worked example: one species or two?
Two fossil jaws from the same layer differ greatly in size. Are they two species? 1. Compare the variation with living relatives: in gorillas, adult males can weigh about twice as much as females, so large size differences can fall within one species. 2. Look for unique traits: if the large jaw has a feature never seen in the small one, such as a different tooth cusp pattern, the phylogenetic concept points to two species. 3. Consider age: a juvenile jaw differs from an adult one. 4. Conclude cautiously: with only size, one sexually dimorphic species is the simpler hypothesis. Scholars who favour fewer species are nicknamed lumpers, and those who favour more, splitters.
Folk taxonomies
Scientific taxonomy is not the only system of classification. Every society names and sorts the living things around it, and anthropologists call these systems folk taxonomies, or ethnotaxonomies. They are often very precise. The ornithologist Ernst Mayr later recalled that, in the Arfak Mountains of New Guinea in the 1920s, local people had names for 136 of the 137 bird species he distinguished. Folk systems may group organisms by use, behaviour or meaning rather than by ancestry. Researchers increasingly document Indigenous classifications and work alongside their holders, rather than treating them as rough drafts of science.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, writing names wrongly: homo Sapiens is incorrect; the genus is capitalised and the species name is not, and "sapiens" alone is not a species name. Second, thinking the biological species concept settles every case: it cannot be applied to fossils. Third, treating every size difference as a new species: sexual dimorphism and age produce large variation within one species. Fourth, confusing hominid (great apes including humans) with hominin (humans and their closest extinct relatives). Fifth, dismissing folk taxonomies as unscientific guesses.
Key takeaways
Taxonomy names and classifies organisms; each group is a taxon. Linnaeus's binomials, such as Homo sapiens, pair a capitalised genus with a lower-case specific name, both italicised. Ranks run domain, kingdom, phylum, class, order, family, genus, species, with extra ranks between. Modern classification aims to reflect descent, so humans sit in Hominidae with the other great apes and in the tribe Hominini. Species can be defined by interbreeding, niche, unique traits or mate recognition, and fossils force reliance on visible traits. Hybrid zones and sexual dimorphism complicate the boundaries. Folk taxonomies are rich systems in their own right.
Flashcards
Flashcard
The science of naming and classifying organisms
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Which is the correct way to write the scientific name of modern humans in print?
Question 2 of 5
Why can't the biological species concept be applied directly to fossil hominins?
Question 3 of 5
Why does the family Hominidae now include humans as well as the other great apes?
Question 4 of 5
Two fossil jaws from one layer differ only in size, the larger being nearly twice as big. What is the most cautious conclusion?
Question 5 of 5
In Ethiopia's Awash valley, olive and hamadryas baboons interbreed where their ranges meet but stay distinct elsewhere. What does this show?
